Log in:  

Register

Sagan Clean?

The Clinic is the only place on Cyclingnews where you can discuss doping-related issues. Ask questions, discuss positives or improvements to procedures.

Moderators: Eshnar, King Boonen, Red Rick, Pricey_sky

Re: Sagan Clean?

13 May 2018 01:02

User avatar TubularBills
Member
 
Posts: 962
Joined: 15 Sep 2010 04:17
Location: Guest

Re: Re:

15 May 2018 17:48

DirtyWorks wrote:
ctaylor wrote:On the bright side, at least he looks like an athletic human, rather than a Salbutamol powered stick man!


Right. I'd argue he's clean-ish given how consistently he rides. Unlike a Froome, he was a prodigious talent.

There is basically no way to compare so called talent. So argumenting with talent doesn't make a sense.
Kokoso
Senior Member
 
Posts: 2,545
Joined: 22 Apr 2012 06:45

Re: Re:

15 May 2018 17:59

DirtyWorks wrote:
ctaylor wrote:On the bright side, at least he looks like an athletic human, rather than a Salbutamol powered stick man!


Right. I'd argue he's clean-ish given how consistently he rides. Unlike a Froome, he was a prodigious talent.

It's a shame Pistolero is banned because now actually would be a good time to bring up Valverde.

Now, given your contrasting Sagan as somebody who has always had the level and consistently so vs. somebody like Froome, who is far less elegant on a bike, has deficiencies in a number of skills and so forth, I actually agree with you to some extent, but that doesn't necessarily make Sagan any cleaner per se, just that were the péloton to be completely paniagua as of tomorrow, we could expect Sagan to continue to be one of the top performers. After all, Valverde was one of the most ridiculously talented kids Spain ever produced. Not just at espoir level (which was actually his weakest time results-wise), not just at junior level, but back to cadets and back to when he was 11 years old when he went on his ridiculous winning streak that led to the "El Imbatido" nickname. Alejandro Valverde is just about the first guy you should be able to point to and say, "that guy always had the talent to be one of the best". But he's also a well-known doper and nobody in their right mind would say that his consistent excellence into his late 30s is a sign of cleanliness. Somewhere along the line he started doping and seemingly never stopped, but we can't pinpoint exactly where, because he kept on getting results.

Sagan, like Valverde, has consistently been a top results-getter from very early on. How clean that makes him is a total crapshoot. All we can say with any certainty is that on the Cipollini scale, he's more like Basso than di Luca.
User avatar Libertine Seguros
Veteran
 
Posts: 19,644
Joined: 20 Feb 2010 11:54
Location: Land of Saíz

15 May 2018 19:55

Basso being that guy that even Aldo Sassi said didn't have the natural talent of others.
It's always a crapshoot with everyone, we can't know
User avatar GuyIncognito
Senior Member
 
Posts: 4,243
Joined: 27 Jun 2013 21:19

Re: Re:

15 May 2018 20:45

Libertine Seguros wrote:
DirtyWorks wrote:
ctaylor wrote:On the bright side, at least he looks like an athletic human, rather than a Salbutamol powered stick man!


Right. I'd argue he's clean-ish given how consistently he rides. Unlike a Froome, he was a prodigious talent.

It's a shame Pistolero is banned because now actually would be a good time to bring up Valverde.

Now, given your contrasting Sagan as somebody who has always had the level and consistently so vs. somebody like Froome, who is far less elegant on a bike, has deficiencies in a number of skills and so forth, I actually agree with you to some extent, but that doesn't necessarily make Sagan any cleaner per se, just that were the péloton to be completely paniagua as of tomorrow, we could expect Sagan to continue to be one of the top performers. After all, Valverde was one of the most ridiculously talented kids Spain ever produced. Not just at espoir level (which was actually his weakest time results-wise), not just at junior level, but back to cadets and back to when he was 11 years old when he went on his ridiculous winning streak that led to the "El Imbatido" nickname. Alejandro Valverde is just about the first guy you should be able to point to and say, "that guy always had the talent to be one of the best". But he's also a well-known doper and nobody in their right mind would say that his consistent excellence into his late 30s is a sign of cleanliness. Somewhere along the line he started doping and seemingly never stopped, but we can't pinpoint exactly where, because he kept on getting results.

Sagan, like Valverde, has consistently been a top results-getter from very early on. How clean that makes him is a total crapshoot. All we can say with any certainty is that on the Cipollini scale, he's more like Basso than di Luca.



Wow, a Valverde/Sagan comparison that actually makes a lot of sense. Actually it is a good comparison. It's riders like both Valverde and Sagan that have always been good and continue to be good won't raise suspicion like a rider who was never good and then becomes great overnight.
User avatar Koronin
Senior Member
 
Posts: 2,638
Joined: 14 Oct 2017 01:42
Location: North Carolina, USA

Re:

15 May 2018 21:47

GuyIncognito wrote:Basso being that guy that even Aldo Sassi said didn't have the natural talent of others.
It's always a crapshoot with everyone, we can't know

Please tell me more. I got into cycling when he had just changed team to CSC, so I got to know him a lot around that period of time because the media in Denmark loved him. Don't really know that much before he joined up with Riis
"Es el mejor con y sin"
WORLD CHAMPION
User avatar Valv.Piti
Veteran
 
Posts: 9,538
Joined: 03 Aug 2015 00:00
Location: Dinamarca, Aalborg

Re: Re:

16 May 2018 03:30

Libertine Seguros wrote:
DirtyWorks wrote:
ctaylor wrote:On the bright side, at least he looks like an athletic human, rather than a Salbutamol powered stick man!


Right. I'd argue he's clean-ish given how consistently he rides. Unlike a Froome, he was a prodigious talent.

It's a shame Pistolero is banned because now actually would be a good time to bring up Valverde.

Now, given your contrasting Sagan as somebody who has always had the level and consistently so vs. somebody like Froome, who is far less elegant on a bike, has deficiencies in a number of skills and so forth, I actually agree with you to some extent, but that doesn't necessarily make Sagan any cleaner per se, just that were the péloton to be completely paniagua as of tomorrow, we could expect Sagan to continue to be one of the top performers. After all, Valverde was one of the most ridiculously talented kids Spain ever produced. Not just at espoir level (which was actually his weakest time results-wise), not just at junior level, but back to cadets and back to when he was 11 years old when he went on his ridiculous winning streak that led to the "El Imbatido" nickname. Alejandro Valverde is just about the first guy you should be able to point to and say, "that guy always had the talent to be one of the best". But he's also a well-known doper and nobody in their right mind would say that his consistent excellence into his late 30s is a sign of cleanliness. Somewhere along the line he started doping and seemingly never stopped, but we can't pinpoint exactly where, because he kept on getting results.

Sagan, like Valverde, has consistently been a top results-getter from very early on. How clean that makes him is a total crapshoot. All we can say with any certainty is that on the Cipollini scale, he's more like Basso than di Luca.


There are always exceptions.

Doping techniques vary. A rider will change techniques over time, and sometimes be forced to change them due to losing a doc or a new test showing up. This can cause serious performance fluctuations for athletes who are big dope users and big dope responders. What are the odds that Valverde has been on a top notch functioning doping programme every year for the last 15-20 years? There has to be a sublime talent level filling in the gaps in dope efficacy at times, in my opinion. (Not saying this to defend Valverde in some strange way.. he's just the example used for the topic)
spiritualride
Junior Member
 
Posts: 186
Joined: 06 Jul 2016 22:19

Re: Re:

18 May 2018 07:36

Valv.Piti wrote:
GuyIncognito wrote:Basso being that guy that even Aldo Sassi said didn't have the natural talent of others.
It's always a crapshoot with everyone, we can't know

Please tell me more. I got into cycling when he had just changed team to CSC, so I got to know him a lot around that period of time because the media in Denmark loved him. Don't really know that much before he joined up with Riis


Haha, no talent whatsoever..Already at the Fassa Bortolo, before CSC, challenging/ripping top dogs like Vinokourov, Beloki, Jaja, Millar and taking white jersey at the TdF :cool:
memyselfandI
Junior Member
 
Posts: 205
Joined: 04 Jun 2009 08:32

Re: Sagan Clean?

20 Jul 2018 15:48

All the comments in the Clinic about Thomas and Dumoulin, but Sagan has been totally ridiculous this Tour.
akrogirl
Junior Member
 
Posts: 60
Joined: 21 Jul 2010 14:54

20 Jul 2018 16:12

Which part is ridiculous? Finishing more than two minutes behind his team on the 35 km TTT or a very tight sprint victory over Kristoff?
Aimar16
New Member
 
Posts: 12
Joined: 04 Jul 2017 15:20

Re: Sagan Clean?

20 Jul 2018 17:43

akrogirl wrote:All the comments in the Clinic about Thomas and Dumoulin, but Sagan has been totally ridiculous this Tour.

I think the issue is that Sagan doesn’t have a large number of people defending him so conversations are not perpetuated.
Vincenzo Nibali:
"I know how to ride a bike"

Reduce your carbon footprint, ride steel.
User avatar King Boonen
Administrator
 
Posts: 7,411
Joined: 25 Jul 2012 14:38

Re: Sagan Clean?

20 Jul 2018 18:03

King Boonen wrote:
akrogirl wrote:All the comments in the Clinic about Thomas and Dumoulin, but Sagan has been totally ridiculous this Tour.

I think the issue is that Sagan doesn’t have a large number of people defending him so conversations are not perpetuated.

Yeah, Sagan is a pretty clear open and shut case. A massive talent who is taking what is necessary to realize his talent in the pro peloton.
User avatar DFA123
Veteran
 
Posts: 6,336
Joined: 07 Nov 2010 16:00
Location: Valencia

Re:

22 Jul 2018 16:45

Aimar16 wrote:Which part is ridiculous? Finishing more than two minutes behind his team on the 35 km TTT or a very tight sprint victory over Kristoff?


As we were watching the team time trial, I told my husband that I thought Sagan was tanking it so that he had a better chance of winning the the sprint the following day.
akrogirl
Junior Member
 
Posts: 60
Joined: 21 Jul 2010 14:54

22 Jul 2018 17:11

So where is the ridiculous stuff??
ctaylor
Newly Registered Member
 
Posts: 7
Joined: 01 Jul 2017 17:31

Re:

23 Jul 2018 10:56

ctaylor wrote:So where is the ridiculous stuff??


in local tabloids regarding his split with wife...i have already read an opinion of some sort of esoteric lady :lol: and expert on gestures :rolleyes: and way way way old quasi celebrity :D
saganftw
Member
 
Posts: 1,320
Joined: 21 May 2010 01:08

Previous

Return to The Clinic

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 14 guests

Back to top