• The Cycling News forum is still looking to add volunteer moderators with. If you're interested in helping keep our discussions on track, send a direct message to @SHaines here on the forum, or use the Contact Us form to message the Community Team.

    In the meanwhile, please use the Report option if you see a post that doesn't fit within the forum rules.

    Thanks!

Stage of the year (2016 edition)

What was the best stage of the year 2016

  • Paris - Nice: stage 7

    Votes: 10 16.1%
  • Vuelta Ciclista al Pais Vasco: stage 5

    Votes: 4 6.5%
  • Giro d'Italia: stage 16

    Votes: 17 27.4%
  • Giro d'Italia: stage 19

    Votes: 32 51.6%
  • Tour de France: stage 12

    Votes: 3 4.8%
  • Tour de Pologne: stage 5

    Votes: 11 17.7%
  • Vuelta a España: stage 10

    Votes: 2 3.2%
  • Vuelta a España: stage 15

    Votes: 34 54.8%
  • Eneco Tour: stage 7

    Votes: 1 1.6%
  • Other

    Votes: 1 1.6%

  • Total voters
    62
I liked the thread last year and since all the important races are over I decided to create another thread. First of all, I only picked WT stages for the thread since most people here probably didn't see many great stages in the Europe or the America Tour so I thought including them in the poll doesn't really make sense. I also only put stages in the poll, not one day races because 1.) stage races and one day races are something completely different for me and personally I can't really compare them and 2.) there already is a thread about the best one day race of the season.
Anyway, here a short description of the stages:

Paris - Nice stage 7: Nice - Nice
Before the final stage of the first WT stage race of the year Contador is only a few seconds behind the leader Geraint Thomas, but still he decides to already attack on the penultimate climb. However the skytrain manages to catch Contador just before the start of the last climb where AC keeps on attacking and finally manages to drop Thomas. However after an incredible chase on the final descent Contador almost gets caught again and the Thomas wins by only 4 seconds.

Vuelta Ciclista al Pais Vasco stage 5: Orio - Arrate
A rosa solo over several passes and one of the cooles winning celebrations of the last years would already have been enough to make this stage memorable, but still there was way more going on. First Purito blew up the peloton with a furious pace 3 climbs before the finish. Contador is almost isolated so team sky tries to get rid of him by letting Landa attack on the penultimate climb, but he gets caught again at the beginning of the last climb where Contador and Henao crush what was still left of the peloton

Giro d'Italia stage 16: Bressanone - Andalo
When the riders entered the penultimate weekend of this years giro there were still a bunch of riders in contention to win the gc, but after the queen stage and a MTT it was obvious that Steven Kruijswijk is the outstanding favorite. This was the reason why on a relatively short stage almost all other gc riders attacked the Dutchman and blew up the race still quite far away from the finish. The only important rider who couldn't follow these early attacks was Esteban Chaves. On the final hard climb the attacking continued, but Kruijswijk was just too strong. However the 2nd biggest favorite of the race at that point, Vincenzo Nibali, cracked and lost so much time that everyone agreet that after this stage he was finally out of contention to win the giro. He even got dropped by Chaves who started a great chase on the last kilometers and limited the damage.

Giro d'Italia stage 19: Pinerolo - Risoul
Many people were afraid that nothing would happen on the stage with the Cima Coppi because of the flat between the penultimate and the last climb but boy, were they wrong. On the penultimate climb, the Colle Agnello Orica and their gc rider Chaves tried again to crush Kruijswijk but it just wasn't possible for them. However Nibali rose from the dead and passed the Agnello together with the other two riders, before he did what he does best, attacking on the descent. His pace was too high for Kruijswijk but the Dutchman did everything to not drop which unfortunately resulted in a crash, which turned the whole giro upside down. Kruijswijk had to do most of the work before the last climb on his own and therefore lost a lot of time on Chaves and especially Nibali, who was 4:40 behind Kruijswijk before this stage and now suddenly had the chance to win the giro again (which he later did)

Tour de France stage 12: Montpellier - Mont Ventoux
This years Tour definitely wasn't one of my favorite ones but this was definitely one of the most memorable stages of the year. First there was a big fight between the teams in the crosswinds in the long flat part of the stage. The crash of Ian Stannard and Froome's infamous pissbreak would usually also be very famous moments but are mostly forgotten because everyone only remembers what happened on the last climb. After two weak attacks by Nairo Quintana, Chris Froome did what he does best, simulate a washing machine and completely crushing his opponents. Quintana cracked and it seemed as if this was the crucial point of the race, but then this happened:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HHfKHpurzR8
The result was later neutralized which means that the pictures of Froome running up the Ventoux will only be memorable, but not crucial for the outcome of the gc. Still an absolutely crazy stage.

Tour de Pologne stage 5: Wieliczka - Zakopane
Talking about crazy stages: What happens if you put Tim Wellens into a hilly race with the worst weather conditions possible? This. Wellens first was part of a break, which was about to be caught, so Wellens decided to attack and ride the last 70km alone at the front and while the peloton was only 38 seconds behind the break when Wellens attacked the Belgian eventually won the stage by almost 4 minutes. Unsurprisingly Wellens later also won the gc of the Tour de Pologne.

Vuelta a España stage 10: Lugones - Lagos de Covadonga
When making this list I had 8 stages which I definitely wanted to include in the poll. This was the one I wasn't sure about but at the end I decided that the climb to the Lagos de Covadonga was possibly the best climb of the whole year and therefore deserves a place in the top ten stages.
Chris Froome, who was one of the 3 big favorites for the race, dropped extremely early on the last ascent, even early for Froome circumstances. Everyone in the forum agrees that this isn't a typical Froome yoyo, this time he is just in bad shape. But Alberto Contador is afraid that Froome might recover and therefore attacks relatively early with only Quintana on his wheel. The two cooperate quite well, but suddenly Froome reveals that he simply did the biggest yoyo ever and overtakes the riders one by one. Quintana gets nervous and attacks Contador, who can't follow the attack on completely cracks. Froome catches almost all the favorites, including Contador and after he was already around one minute behind Quintana earlier on the climb he only finishes 25 seconds behind the Colombian while Contador loses 1:05.

Vuelta a España stage 15: Sabiñanigo - Formigal
After being dropped numerous times Contador decides that he has nothing to lose and tries a seemingly impossible attack early in a stage which was earlier described as one of the most boring ones of the whole vuelta, by uninformed cn forum posters (like me). But the leader of the race, Quintana, and his Movistar team follow the attack and the break manages to get an advantage, since Froome is almost isolated in the peloton. Quintana pulls the group up the last climb to Formigal and nobody, not even Contador, who worked a lot earlier in the stage, except Brambilla can follow. At the end the Italian outsprints Quintana but that doesn't really matter since the Colombian won the whole the Vuelta on this stage.

Eneco Tour stage 7: Bornem - Geraardsbergen
A typical Eneco tour stage, which makes you wonder why the classics don't get raced like that. After the race leader Rohan Dennis crashed out the peloton splits into two groups. Riders continuously attack from the first group and at the end a crucial 3 men break with Niki Terpstra, EBH and Naesen forms. The group often gets close to the first group but never manages to catch them, so the Dutch Terpstra wins the Eneco Tour and EBH the stage.

Sorry if I forgot a stage (I can still change the poll if thats the case) and for possible typos
 
For me it's:
1.) Risoul
2.) Formigal
3.) Zakopane

The Risoul was the most dramatic finish for a gt which I have ever seen. Formigal was ofc also incredibly and we basically had 100 km of action, but back then I thought it won't matter since I expected Quintana to win anyway. Now I know that this stage was actually crucial but it didn't feel like that back then. Then the Zakopane is just pure craziness. Would have been nr. 1 easily, but the context of the gt stages just put them one step above a stage from a WT race for which I usually don't really care about.
 
Re:

Netserk said:
Am I the only one who found stage stage 14 to be better than 16 in the Giro?

I was going to say the same - altho it lacked attacks on Giau (which would have made it epic), it was still one of the days I enjoyed the much. A true queen stage in the dolomites, attrition, big gaps and a GC winner of the stage.

Voted stage 15 of the Vuelta tho, stage 19 in the Giro close.
 
Re:

Netserk said:
Am I the only one who found stage stage 14 to be better than 16 in the Giro?
I thought about that stage too, but I didn't want 3 giro stages in the poll and decided that stage 16 was probably a bit better. After all stage 14 only really had action on the final climb.
 
Despite all the epicness with the race leader and another big favourite going in the early break, the Formigal stage doesn't quite win the prize for me. In other years it could've been the best for sure, but at the end of the day, most of the stage was just two groups racing against each other. A very, very glorified version of the Doha WC, to put it in a bit of a silly way.

The Risoul stage had so much more going on, so many emotional ups and downs, so much drama, turning the whole story of the race upside down. That Nibali actually won the Giro the next day just adds to the significance. Yes, you can argue that a lot of it was caused by a crash, but for people like me, who see crashes like that, where it's obviously the rider's own fault, as part of the game, it just adds to the drama.

So I voted Risoul. And Zakopane. Just because outrageous madness like that needs some love.
 
Re: Re:

Gigs_98 said:
Netserk said:
Am I the only one who found stage stage 14 to be better than 16 in the Giro?
I thought about that stage too, but I didn't want 3 giro stages in the poll and decided that stage 16 was probably a bit better. After all stage 14 only really had action on the final climb.
Well, stage 14 of the Giro was miles better than stage 12 of TdF or 10 of the Vuelta, so I think its justified. Its pretty sad to think about stage 12 of the Tour actually was the best it had to offer, ugh. I guess stage 19 was decent, so was a couple of other stages, but man.
 
Re: Re:

Valv.Piti said:
Gigs_98 said:
Netserk said:
Am I the only one who found stage stage 14 to be better than 16 in the Giro?
I thought about that stage too, but I didn't want 3 giro stages in the poll and decided that stage 16 was probably a bit better. After all stage 14 only really had action on the final climb.
Well, stage 14 of the Giro was miles better than stage 12 of TdF or 10 of the Vuelta, so I think its justified. Its pretty sad to think about stage 12 of the Tour actually was the best it had to offer, ugh. I guess stage 19 was decent, so was a couple of other stages, but man.
Stage 5 was the best TDF stage, IMO.
 
Aramon, Risoul and Nice. In that order. Don't know what the Ventoux stage is doing in the poll. Is it really necessary to include TDF stages just for the sake of including them? If it's the case, the stage to Andorra Arcalis should have been the TDF stage-option
 
Re:

Cance > TheRest said:
Aramon, Risoul and Nice. In that order. Don't know what the Ventoux stage is doing in the poll. Is it really necessary to include TDF stages just for the sake of including them? If it's the case, the stage to Andorra Arcalis should have been the TDF stage-option
There are people who absolutely adore a few races. After this years tour there were still many people who said that it was a great gt, better than the giro. Therefore I though it makes sense to feature at least one tdf stage in the poll, generally I agree though that there are other stages which were probably better.

I disagree about the Arcalis stage though. There was action on one climb, and the moves were actually cursed to fail right from the beginning. And the climb to Arcalis also wasn't that great, at least not even close to the Ventoux.

zlev11 said:
the best TDF stage was stage 11
I also thought about that stage, but at the end there were only a few kilometers of crosswind action, which caused hardly any time differences between gc riders.
 
Re: Re:

Gigs_98 said:
Cance > TheRest said:
Aramon, Risoul and Nice. In that order. Don't know what the Ventoux stage is doing in the poll. Is it really necessary to include TDF stages just for the sake of including them? If it's the case, the stage to Andorra Arcalis should have been the TDF stage-option
There are people who absolutely adore a few races. After this years tour there were still many people who said that it was a great gt, better than the giro. Therefore I though it makes sense to feature at least one tdf stage in the poll, generally I agree though that there are other stages which were probably better.

I disagree about the Arcalis stage though. There was action on one climb, and the moves were actually cursed to fail right from the beginning. And the climb to Arcalis also wasn't that great, at least not even close to the Ventoux.

zlev11 said:
the best TDF stage was stage 11
I also thought about that stage, but at the end there were only a few kilometers of crosswind action, which caused hardly any time differences between gc riders.

I think it's very close, but had Geraint Thomas been a bit more heads up, he waited and didn't realize, even though he was right there, the split was happening for several seconds he had to get out of the saddle a sprint for quite awhile, 10, 15, 20 seconds or so and killed himself just getting on the back of the break and wasn't able to pull nearly as long and strong and it made a material difference. It could have been 5 to 10 seconds more if he hadn't hesitated.
 
Re:

Squire said:
Despite all the epicness with the race leader and another big favourite going in the early break, the Formigal stage doesn't quite win the prize for me. In other years it could've been the best for sure, but at the end of the day, most of the stage was just two groups racing against each other. A very, very glorified version of the Doha WC, to put it in a bit of a silly way.

The Risoul stage had so much more going on, so many emotional ups and downs, so much drama, turning the whole story of the race upside down. That Nibali actually won the Giro the next day just adds to the significance. Yes, you can argue that a lot of it was caused by a crash, but for people like me, who see crashes like that, where it's obviously the rider's own fault, as part of the game, it just adds to the drama.

So I voted Risoul. And Zakopane. Just because outrageous madness like that needs some love.

Formigal needed Contador and Quintana to go on a huge duel up the final climb imo
 
Re: Re:

Gigs_98 said:
Cance > TheRest said:
Aramon, Risoul and Nice. In that order. Don't know what the Ventoux stage is doing in the poll. Is it really necessary to include TDF stages just for the sake of including them? If it's the case, the stage to Andorra Arcalis should have been the TDF stage-option
There are people who absolutely adore a few races. After this years tour there were still many people who said that it was a great gt, better than the giro. Therefore I though it makes sense to feature at least one tdf stage in the poll, generally I agree though that there are other stages which were probably better.

I disagree about the Arcalis stage though. There was action on one climb, and the moves were actually cursed to fail right from the beginning. And the climb to Arcalis also wasn't that great, at least not even close to the Ventoux.

zlev11 said:
the best TDF stage was stage 11
I also thought about that stage, but at the end there were only a few kilometers of crosswind action, which caused hardly any time differences between gc riders.
I guess I just think the action on Ventoux was mostly a result of bad management from the organizers. Comically as it was to see Froome running, it wasn't really the riders who created the action. In the aftermath Froome somehow avoided being penalized for violating the rules and no real time gaps appeared between him and Bauke (which could have made the rest of the Tour a lot more exciting). Another catastrophic decision.
Additionally, the peloton decided to let a group of 3rd tier escapees fight it out for the win, which just made the stage even worse.

Atleast there was some (albeit unsuccesful) long range attacks from Valverde on stage 9, and it was a great rider who won the stage ahead of two other "good" riders (Costa and Majka).