Is he? De Lie has gravitated increasingly towards raw power and durability and is better on short hills than in flat sprints at this point, whereas Magnier is more a sprinter who gets over hills well. Also think De Lie is currently the better of the two at everything that isn't a flat sprint.
Magniers watts aren't even that special (in general, they are really good for someone his age). Similar to De Lie right now (and De Lie's sprint watts were higher 2 years ago). No idea what Logic is even saying. Also like you said, not the same type of rider right now. Magnier is already way better at full on bunch sprints cause of De Lie's positioning issue tho.
He's similar but better than De Lie imho.
I really really wonder what this is even based on.
Riders who got 2nd in the races he won this year: Blikra, Vernon, Vernon, Teutenberg, Conforti, Del Grosso, Lamperti, Dainese (fair enough but everything to do with amazing QS leadout and technical final).
He is very talented, but let's calm down a bit. I have no idea why you would even think he's better than De Lie.