• The Cycling News forum is still looking to add volunteer moderators with. If you're interested in helping keep our discussions on track, send a direct message to @SHaines here on the forum, or use the Contact Us form to message the Community Team.

    In the meanwhile, please use the Report option if you see a post that doesn't fit within the forum rules.

    Thanks!

7 rule changes to make the 2012 TdF more rider friendly

Mar 5, 2009
63
0
0
Memo To: Christophe Prudhomme of Amoury Sports Organization.

From: Chuck Chicken.

Subject: Request for rule changes to make things easier for the riders.

After watching the 2011 Tour de France (very exciting by the way) I was struck by rider comments about the conditions they were subjected to during the three-week event. Almost every day, there was some cause for concern of the rider's safety, or a challenge to a rider's ability to retain a hard-won position in the race. I therefore humbly and respectfully request the following seven rule changes. Please implement them before the 2012 Tour de France.

1) Frank and Andy Schleck are brothers and teammates. Since they went to all this effort to be born in the same family and insist on riding so close to each other in the peloton they could hold hands, I recommend that the equipment rules be changed to allow the Schleck's to ride a tandem bike. The Dude Who Found me assures me that people who ride tandems with a partner are stronger together than alone so let the boys have one. It just may have helped Andy in that time trial.

2) Here's another one for the Schlecks, after listening to the brother's rationally and reasonably explain the dangers of riding bicycles downhill, I recommend that riders be bussed down all descents. Just because descending has been part of the challenge of bicycle racing in every event for all of the sport's history, doesn't make descending less dangerous (deadly, even). Let's not lose another professional cyclist unnecessarily.

3) Since this seems to be a defacto rule anyway, please change the daily time-cut rule to read that the time-cut starts just behind whatever group Mark Cavendish finishes in. It's a waste of everyone's energy to establish a time-based cut-off for riders if a waiver is going to be given for Cavendish so let's just make it formal.

4) Alberto Contador had an off year. And losing time in the first week due to a split in the peloton proved too much for him. Because you can't always be sure that a favorite like Alberto will be fit enough to make up losses like that, I propose a rule change that on flat stages (ones won by a named sprint star), all riders get the same time as the winner.

5) Thomas Voekler is one of the most exciting cyclists of our time. To see a Frenchman in yellow, fighting with all his strength to keep it, was amazing. It is a shame that the honor of finishing the race in yellow was stolen from him at the final hour like that. You do own the race right? No-one would have blamed you if you simply stopped the race the last day Voekler was in yellow. Maybe the rule could be that if a French guy is in yellow ten days in row, the rest of the race is neutralized?

6) The fans who run along side racers up mountain climbs can get a little crazy. They come too close on the best day and on their worst, lay a hand on the riders. Contador had to punch a guy in the face this year to stop from getting knocked off his bike. I suggest that retractable batons be standard issue from now on. I bet those geniuses at Trek or Specialized can make one out of carbon fiber that mounts to the top of a handlebar. And I bet that once a few riders express their discomfort with crazy fans via baton, the rest of the crowds will simply fall into line.

7) This one may go without saying but rules need to be officially added to the book to be followed so here goes: please ban all cars and motorcycles from the race caravan. Watching a France tv VIP car knock Juan Antonio Flecha of Team Sky and Johnny Hoogerland of Omega Pharma Lotto (Ed correction - Vacansoleil-DCM) to the ground was horrifying. Something must be done. I recommend that all cars and motorcycles be suspended from the roads. I know this will create complications you need to work through to replace the roles of team and officials cars but don't worry about the television aspect - just put some cameras on the bikes themselves and shoot from the helicopter. And bring cars back when they can fly.

Thank you for your kind attention to this letter.
 
SteveMedcroft said:
Memo To: Christophe Prudhomme of Amoury Sports Organization.

From: Chuck Chicken.

Subject: Request for rule changes to make things easier for the riders.


7) This one may go without saying but rules need to be officially added to the book to be followed so here goes: please ban all cars and motorcycles from the race caravan. Watching a France tv VIP car knock Juan Antonio Flecha of Team Sky and Johnny Hoogerland of Omega Pharma Lotto to the ground was horrifying. Something must be done. I recommend that all cars and motorcycles be suspended from the roads. I know this will create complications you need to work through to replace the roles of team and officials cars but don't worry about the television aspect - just put some cameras on the bikes themselves and shoot from the helicopter. And bring cars back when they can fly.

.

Know something we dont?
 
Mar 10, 2009
6,158
1
0
A few more to add.

8. Any rider complaining about the new rules or old rules to the media get a time anti-bonus added of an hour. Or general whining about the race course which was publicized a year in advance! Forget it just DQ the rider.

9. Any rider swapping bikes must have the bad bike given to neutral support to carefully analyze the issue at hand so no defective bike frame or components get re-introduced into the pelOton. I mean, everyone (riders and DS's) are so heavily concerned with safety that I'm sure they don't want bad equipment which could cause some kind of accident on the road, right?
 
Feb 14, 2010
245
0
0
6. Batons? Come on. Give the riders Tazers! (and a replacement from the official motorbikes a rider fires one into a fan)

Supplementary use: a tazer shot inthe bum might get a dynamic attack out of some contenders (no names, no pack drill)
 
Mar 5, 2009
63
0
0
Richeypen said:
Know something we dont?

Actually, I think this qualifies me as knowing less than most people since I got that wrong ;) Vacansoleil-DCM. This is why I'm not a journalist.
 
Jul 19, 2010
83
0
0
Some more

10. In sprint stages, use of more than three hair care products produces a time penalty. (That should give Tyler a shot)

11. Tazers are fine, but if you tag a team car, you can't pull yourself along with the wires.

12. Every time Paul says "job of work" Phil gets to slap him with a wet fish.

13. The autobus cut off is determined by the clear bottle guy, if you're slower than him, you're out.
 
Jul 15, 2010
420
0
0
JohnNordin said:
Some more

10. In sprint stages, use of more than three hair care products produces a time penalty. (That should give Tyler a shot)

11. Tazers are fine, but if you tag a team car, you can't pull yourself along with the wires.

12. Every time Paul says "job of work" Phil gets to slap him with a wet fish.

13. The autobus cut off is determined by the clear bottle guy, if you're slower than him, you're out.


Surely 12 should be expanded to include any time Paul calls a rider over 6ft "a beast of a man" and anything to do with suitcases and courage.
 
May 24, 2010
35
0
0
SteveMedcroft said:
4) Alberto Contador had an off year. And losing time in the first week due to a split in the peloton proved too much for him. Because you can't always be sure that a favorite like Alberto will be fit enough to make up losses like that, I propose a rule change that on flat stages (ones won by a named sprint star), all riders get the same time as the winner.

I never knew Gilbert was a named sprint star ;)

In general, though, love it!
 
Feb 28, 2010
1,661
0
0
Love it. Okay so I'm a Cav fan (liked Cippo in his time as well), but I can still laugh at rule 3. Plus rule 5 `You do own the race right?' is brilliant.

The only rule I'd add, and it might sort out some of the issues you raise, is lose the first week (too many contendors losing time), and the last week (the climbing knocks out riders like Voekler), and you'd have a great race!
 
Oct 29, 2009
1,095
0
0
Lol @ the Schlecklet holding hands or riding a tandem....but it begs the question, Who is going to ride in front? I'd say Frank. That way Andy will always be able to see his brother. Could you imagine Andy looking around for Frank if he were right behind him? Andy may not know if he should attack or not.
 
Sep 27, 2009
1,008
0
0
ImmaculateKadence said:
Lol @ the Schlecklet holding hands or riding a tandem....but it begs the question, Who is going to ride in front? I'd say Frank. That way Andy will always be able to see his brother. Could you imagine Andy looking around for Frank if he were right behind him? Andy may not know if he should attack or not.

If Andy was in front he would be afraid to attack just in case the bike broke in two and he left Frank behind.
 
Feb 28, 2010
1,661
0
0
LukeSchmid said:
If Andy was in front he would be afraid to attack just in case the bike broke in two and he left Frank behind.

And best not to leave Andy in charge of stuff like front gear changes.
 
Oct 29, 2009
1,095
0
0
LukeSchmid said:
If Andy was in front he would be afraid to attack just in case the bike broke in two and he left Frank behind.

Hawkwood said:
And best not to leave Andy in charge of stuff like front gear changes.

Too funny. Between the chain jamming and need of contant assurance his brother is still back there, he might break his neck looking around for him....he is such a rubber necked attacker.