CX v-brake problems: what happened here?

Feb 23, 2010
2,114
19
11,510
Second time this happened and as a mechanically inept individual riding my first ever CX bike and someone who runs to the LBS at the first sign of trouble, I want to understand what happened and why.

The bike is in the shop getting new (and different) brakes but in the meantime here's what the 'offending' 4ZA mini v-brake looked like before I took it there:

BEWSXmTCMAAnezo.jpg:large


You can see clearly a lot of play and all the silver bits of the caliper were totally loose. The spring had also gone floppy. It's not like the play could be tightened out anywhere - none of the screws or bolts appear to act on that. Meanwhile the whole brake obviously fails to function correctly with one caliper slack.

I didn't screw around with the bike before this. I rode it in moderate offroad conditions, no impacts or crashes (at least not in that area, anyway ;)), washed it and replaced the wheels and popped the noodle back in only to discover that the brake didn't work properly. Was it something I did? Could it be fixed easily?
 
Jul 23, 2009
5,412
19
17,510
L'arriviste said:
Second time this happened and as a mechanically inept individual riding my first ever CX bike and someone who runs to the LBS at the first sign of trouble, I want to understand what happened and why.

The bike is in the shop getting new (and different) brakes but in the meantime here's what the 'offending' 4ZA mini v-brake looked like before I took it there:

BEWSXmTCMAAnezo.jpg:large


You can see clearly a lot of play and all the silver bits of the caliper were totally loose. The spring had also gone floppy. It's not like the play could be tightened out anywhere - none of the screws or bolts appear to act on that. Meanwhile the whole brake obviously fails to function correctly with one caliper slack.

I didn't screw around with the bike before this. I rode it in moderate offroad conditions, no impacts or crashes (at least not in that area, anyway ;)), washed it and replaced the wheels and popped the noodle back in only to discover that the brake didn't work properly. Was it something I did? Could it be fixed easily?

I think the screw in post, the thing that goes into the fork, may have come loose, unscrewed. But tough to tell w/o seeing it.
 
Oct 20, 2012
285
0
0
It looks to me as like the brake wasn't installed properly in the first place (the screws weren't screwed straight) so got damaged completely while you rode the bike. Well done of changing it.. It's not wise to ride with damaged brakes. :)
 
Feb 23, 2010
2,114
19
11,510
alitogata said:
It looks to me as like the brake wasn't installed properly in the first place (the screws weren't screwed straight) so got damaged completely while you rode the bike. Well done of changing it.. It's not wise to ride with damaged brakes. :)

Bustedknuckle said:
I think the screw in post, the thing that goes into the fork, may have come loose, unscrewed. But tough to tell w/o seeing it.

Thanks! It was all tight though. Nothing loose there, just the brake caliper itself.
 
Aug 10, 2010
6,285
2
17,485
Is it possible that there are one of those convex washers in there, and things got rotated out of proper alignment?
 
Sep 29, 2012
422
0
0
If the boss was tight, and the mounting bolt was tight then the boss is too long as the mounting bolt was bottoming out.

The easiest way to solve it is to just get shorter bolts mounting bolts and put a spacer on the boss so that when the bolt tightens down, it tightens the caliber into place.
 
Jul 23, 2009
5,412
19
17,510
purcell said:
If the boss was tight, and the mounting bolt was tight then the boss is too long as the mounting bolt was bottoming out.

The easiest way to solve it is to just get shorter bolts mounting bolts and put a spacer on the boss so that when the bolt tightens down, it tightens the caliber into place.

Yep, or shorten the boss..
 
Feb 23, 2010
2,114
19
11,510
I should update this, now winter's coming on:

The LBS fitted TRP EuroX cantis instead. No problems since then. :p
 
Jan 13, 2010
491
0
0
It looks wrong but almost every one of these brakes is different so it's hard to tell what it's supposed to look like. Post a photo of the other caliper, please. It might help.
 
Feb 23, 2010
2,114
19
11,510
ustabe said:
It looks wrong but almost every one of these brakes is different so it's hard to tell what it's supposed to look like. Post a photo of the other caliper, please. It might help.

Hey, sorry, as I mentioned just above, in the time since I posted the query I no longer have those brakes now. :)

It happened twice and I'd had enough, so I had cantis put on and they've been excellent ever since.