Pippo's weak? Low pain tolerance? Never rides aggressively? Give me a break. Just be honest: come right out and say you don't like the guy or his silly tattoos and be done with. But, please, enough with the selective race memories, already.
Has Pippo done his share of marking the favorites? Sure. That's what mortals do when Boonen and Cancellara are on form. But, how about re-watching his Het Volk win, his P-R 2009 chase of Boonen (or his 20km P-R solo chase back to the lead group after crashing one year), his solo chase of Boonen and Gilbert at Paris-Tours, and then try and say the guy's got no grit.
As for not winning, Pippo's got a lot more big wins than Flecha, and about as many as Ballan and Hushovd.
Flecha: Zurich '04; Het Nieuwsblad '10;
Ballan: De Panne '07; Flanders '07; Hamburg '07; Worlds '08;
Hushovd: Gent-Wevelgem '06; Het Nieuwsblad '09; Worlds '10;
Pozzato: Hamburg '05; Milan-San Remo '06; Het Volk '07; E3 Prijs '09.
When you look at Classics podiums and Top 10s, Pozzato compares very favorably there, as well. He's also the youngest amongst this group with Hushovd, Flecha, and Ballan.
So, yeah, Pippo doesn't match up to Boonen, Cancellara, and Gilbert. At the same time, he's at least as impressive as a bunch of the "hard men" of the Classics who enjoy tons of fan support around here.