- Apr 24, 2009
- 206
- 0
- 0
fulcrum said:Maybe, maybe not. Both Alberto and Lance had bottles. But we don't know if they had any water. If they did, why would Lance need to drink from an opponent's?
As the article said, the image is misleading because it was lacking context. By the time they show the riders, Lance is already all the way up to Ivan, but you can see Alberto moving to his right as if Lance had gotten in his way.
The Lance taking a sip and passing it to Alberto doesn't contradict the article, neither does the fact that Lance makes a gesture to keep the bottle (they have two cages in the bike). You cannot see Ivan at that point, but he could have been telling Armstrong "get me that bottle back". So the video seems inconclusive to me. I'd rather see the 5 seconds preceding that moment.
PD: in fact, if you look at the image, you can kind of see the latter part of a Lance launch for the bottle at around 3:59.
That fan with the green shirt is as bad as the sign blocking crucial frames of the Zapruder film.
HOW WILL WE EVER KNOW THE TRUTH!
You have to be careful about perspective in a 2D picture, but it sure looks as though Ivan and Armstrong are level and Contador is in between, but well behind. You are pushing up a 10% grade, watching the crazy guy running in front, trying to watch out for another attack....seems pretty easy to think that a guy next to you handing out a water bottle was giving it to you. There is nothing to indicate Armstrong even knew Contador was there.