i have to say firts that i'm to young to know the giro editions before 2002, but in this century i think the 2008 edition was definatly the most attractive and the sportive ambitioust giro (maybe even the best gt of this century on eye-level with the tdf 2003) with contador, ricco, sella, pellizotti, bruseghin and mentsjov fighting every day in the mountains. Alpe di pampeago, plan de corones, dolomite stars that was just a ****ing brutal giro. the low competition at the tdf in the same year was nothing against how heroically sella defeat the dolomites, how courageously contador defend his maglia rosa against the agressive cobra.
2005 comes next, of course. this colle delle finestre stage was the most exciting stage race i have ever seen. i mean anything could have happened there, if the stage just would have had 5km more, rujano would have won that giro.
at 3rd place i think i would prefer the 2003 giro, even if it was a one man show as in 2006 or 2007. but the monte zoncolan stage of that year, was the last moment il pirata showed his strengh and i'm grateful that i just have seen that, because for 1998-1999 i'm a bit to young.