• We hope all of you have a great holiday season and wonderful Christmas. Thanks so much for being part of the Cycling News community in 2025 and beyond!

2017 Tour de France startlist & field speculation

Page 6 - Get up to date with the latest news, scores & standings from the Cycling News Community.
Aug 18, 2010
11,435
3,594
28,180
So neither of the two teams expected to provide the main challenge for Sky have taken a climbing-focused squad. Sky on the other hand have gone for the full mountain train of boredom.
 
Aug 3, 2015
22,756
10,725
28,180
Re:

Zinoviev Letter said:
So neither of the two teams expected to provide the main challenge for Sky have taken a climbing-focused squad. Sky on the other hand have gone for the full mountain train of boredom.
Looking at the route, I think its a decent thought process.. It obviously also depends on what riders you have at your disposal and it just so happens BMC and Movistar have a lot of good rouleurs/allrounders and not necessarily very good climbing domestiques (both team also focused quite a lot on the Giro).
 
Nov 29, 2010
2,326
0
0
Re:

Zinoviev Letter said:
So neither of the two teams expected to provide the main challenge for Sky have taken a climbing-focused squad. Sky on the other hand have gone for the full mountain train of boredom.

Sky have taken an everything-focused squad because they can.

For the flat lands maybe only Quickstep will bring a stronger team than: Thomas, Rowe, Knees, Kwiatkowski, Kiryenka + Froome so I don't think you can call it climbing-focused. They just do everything, like always.
 
May 10, 2013
5,455
3,245
23,180
Yeah, I think Sky only looks that strong in mountains because they have some of the best all-rounders in the peloton, not because they've chosed a climbing-oriented roster. Guys like Kwiatkowski and Thomas can be counted on both mountains and flat terrain. If Sky didn't have the luxury of having guys like these, who knows how many rouleurs they would've decided to bring instead.
 
Nov 6, 2009
799
115
10,180
Re: Re:

Escarabajo said:
deValtos said:
Nairo
Valverde
Erviti
BETANCUR!!
Sutterlin
Bennati
Jesus Herrada
Castro
Amador
Betancur!!!!!!!

Holy smoke!!

Surpricing they cut Daniel Moreno who apeared to have okay form and would have been the best mountainhelper on paper. I would think Amadors form is more doubtful after the Giro where he looked very tired in the end, but he could be good of course. Valverde will have a strong team in the Vuelta now also with Moreno, Soler and Fernandez all fresh. I am not that overwhelmed by their team for the Tour now though.
 
Jun 10, 2017
5,246
3,467
23,180
Re: Re:

deValtos said:
Zinoviev Letter said:
So neither of the two teams expected to provide the main challenge for Sky have taken a climbing-focused squad. Sky on the other hand have gone for the full mountain train of boredom.

Sky have taken an everything-focused squad because they can.

For the flat lands maybe only Quickstep will bring a stronger team than: Thomas, Rowe, Knees, Kwiatkowski, Kiryenka + Froome so I don't think you can call it climbing-focused. They just do everything, like always.
I think the difference with Sky is that we know that recent monument winner Kwiat is going there purely as Froome's domestique. Whereas with Trek and BMC, we know recent monument winners Degenkolb and VanAvermaet are free to chase stages.

Recent monument winner Valverde is also, apparently, going as a pure domestique for Quintana, but I'd say it's more than likely he'll end up high on the GC anyway, and I wouldn't be surprised if he wins a stage.
 
Jun 10, 2017
5,246
3,467
23,180
There's been a lot of bike racing since the 2015 Roubaix yes, but a) he did win 2 of them in one season, so that has to count for something and b) it's 2 seasons ago, not 10. Most of the guys he beat are still racing.

None of which makes much difference to the central point of what I was saying, which was that most of the genuine Yellow Jersey contenders have a classics rider in their squad, but only Froome and Quintana have that classics rider locked down as 100% working for the team, not for themselves.


I Gilbert riding the Tour? I very much doubt he's doing it purely as Dan Martin's gofer.
 
Aug 3, 2015
22,756
10,725
28,180
Gilbert should definitely be riding the Tour, yeah. Correct me if Im wrong, but I think thats the last team make it official, but he should be a certainty.
 
Jul 27, 2009
6,638
2,529
23,180
I guess Quick Steps instant plan was to put Alafpolak into yellow after the PDBF stage. Now it's either Martin or Gilbert. With Martin being much more likely!
 
Jun 10, 2017
5,246
3,467
23,180
I think I can be quite confident in saying it's QS's plan to have Martin as high on the GC as possible, but not anybody else. If Gilbert or someone else can slip into yellow during the first week, well and good, but PhilGil's job is to hunt stages.

I can see the team setting up a bit of an uphill sprint train on PDBF alright. If Valverde is really only working for Quintana, then Martin's usual summit finish bete noir mightn't be still in contention at the end...
 
Mar 25, 2013
664
1
9,985
Re:

deValtos said:
Nairo
Valverde
Erviti
BETANCUR!!
Sutterlin
Bennati
Jesus Herrada
Castro
Amador

I thought Ruben Fernandez is the one to miss out. Not followed his progress this year but last year he was quite good. Dont know whats the thinking there.
 
May 4, 2011
4,285
783
17,680
Re: Re:

saneguy said:
deValtos said:
Nairo
Valverde
Erviti
BETANCUR!!
Sutterlin
Bennati
Jesus Herrada
Castro
Amador

I thought Ruben Fernandez is the one to miss out. Not followed his progress this year but last year he was quite good. Dont know whats the thinking there.
Valverde apparently wants a fresh Fernandez, Dani Moreno and Soler for his Vuelta assault. He was promised a good team for the Vuelta, anyway.

In return, he'll be Quintana's super dom here. At least, that's the plan.
 
May 5, 2010
51,871
30,424
28,180
Re:

Leinster said:
There's been a lot of bike racing since the 2015 Roubaix yes, but a) he did win 2 of them in one season, so that has to count for something and b) it's 2 seasons ago, not 10. Most of the guys he beat are still racing.

Just thought it was kinda funny that the other three examples were guys who'd won a Monument this year, and then Degenkolb.
 
Nov 7, 2010
8,820
246
17,880
Re: Re:

jaylew said:
Alexandre B. said:
Direct Energie

Thomas Boudat
Lilian Calmejane
Sylvain Chavanel
Yohann Gène
Adrien Petit
Perrig Quéméneur
Romain Sicard
Angelo Tulik
Thomas Voeckler

Leaving Coquard out makes them look so small and petty. He stuck with the team during some tough times when he could have left for WT, he tells the team his plans well in advance so they can plan out next year and you're going to blame the guy for wanting to step up a level after 5 years with the team? Pathetic. Well, they've definitely made sure no one will ever let them know they're leaving before the Tour again. Is Calmejane under contract for next year? It would be funny if he decided to sign with someone else for 2018.
Completely agree. It's a disgraceful decision. If DE don't want to be used as a stepping stone by their most talented young riders, then they should go for WT status. But it's ridiculous to leave out your best rider because he has ambitions above pro-conti level. I imagine the sponsors won't be too happy with this either.
 
Aug 3, 2015
22,756
10,725
28,180
QS last team confirmed:

Kittel
Martin
Gilbert
Sabatini
Trentin
Bauer
Stybar
Vermote
Brambilla
 
Apr 16, 2009
17,605
6,862
28,180
If GC is Martin's target he will have to do it on his own on that team. It won't be the first time.

Besides his target is top 10. I don't think you need too much help for that. If his target is podium then he needs to switch teams IMHO.
 
Jul 15, 2016
2,152
192
6,680
Re:

Anderis said:
If something happens to Brambilla, Martin will have no help in the mountains at all.

Martin's ticket to winning is to pull a rabbit out of the hat by getting lucky in a break. Brambilla is the perfect help for that.

Besides that he just needs to stick with the Sky train (or Movistar or BMC, depending on the day).
 
Nov 29, 2010
2,326
0
0
Re: Re:

janraaskalt said:
deValtos said:
janraaskalt said:
Can Trek-Segafredo select another rider to start with 9?

What happened?

Not allowed to say what happened in this part of the forum, but Andre Cardoso won't start.

Oh ***, for reals?

Well I believe they should since its a few days before the team presentation. Yea 99.9% sure they can.

HAIMAR LADS! :lol:

I knew he was going to top20 this TDF despite not being in the startlist.