Andy Schleck and Alberto Contador are
both great, just different riders???

Are y'all stoned, or what? Andy's record......
You call this GREAT??: 2011- ONE stage win at the TdF and coming in 2nd after miserable failure of strategy and performance on the penultimate days ITT. (BTW that's it for 2011, results wise)
2010- 2 stage wins at the TdF then handed the title that he DID NOT WIN on the road. Luxembourg ITT champ.... oh and oops! That's it for 2010 Wow! Great year.
2009-Probably the best year of his career so far- a year that showed "potential"
Luxembourg Road Champ, 1st Liege-Bastogne-Liege, won one stage of the Tour of Luxembourg, 2nd overall at the TdF, along with 1st in the young rider category.
2008- TdF Young rider-1st, 12th overall. 1 stage win in the Tour of Poland
2007-2nd overall at the Giro, and 1st young rider at the Giro(which put him on the map)
Is that GREATNESS???
Compare this to Alberto's palmares, and YES they sure are "different" riders.
2011- Alberto is stripped of his Giro D'Italia title that he won convincingly, along with the 6th place at the TdF, and some other results......but I digress.
2010-Oops, stripped him of his Tour de France victory, and GAVE it to the Great Andy Schleck. But before that debacle Alberto took the titles at Paris-Nice along with 1 stage win. And he took the Volta Algarve with 1 stage win, and the Vuelta Castilla y Leon with 1 stage win(ITT).
2009-He was the Spanish ITT Champ, He won the TdF, most notably taking 2 stage victories, and beating his own team, and Lance Armstrong, along with Schleck and the rest of the free world! And that after, he had taken the Volta Algarve(+1), and Pais Vasco(+2) titles along with stage wins in both and finishing 4th in Paris-Nice with 2 stage victories.
2008-Took the Giro title with one weeks notice that Astana had been invited (Are you listening, Frank?) and took 2 stages too. Won the Vuelta a Espana and took 2 stages. Also was 4th in the ITT at the Beijing Olympics, and took Castilla y Leon with 2 stage wins, and the Pais Vasco title with 2 stage wins.
2007 saw him take Castilla y Leon + 1 stage win, And The Paris- Nice title 2 stage wins and the Young rider jersey, Along with winning his first TOUR DE FRANCE title, along with the best young riders jersey, and 1 stage win.
DIFFERENT riders? You bet your bootie they are different riders. Alberto is a champion. Andy is an overrated, babied, cutie boy, that seems limited to one target a year. And he's yet to take a big one, on the road. He knows it and all his fans know it too, whether they want to admit it or not. The records do the talking. I've just put it on the table. chew on that a little.