Il Lombardia 2025, monument, October 11

[Krzysztof_O]

UAE has a ridiculously strong team for GT and hilly classics. Packed with riders that would otherwise contend for podiums. Are you suggesting Pogacar doesn’t benefit from that?

As strong team as UAE makes the probability of surprise basically zero in races like Liege and Lombardy. But yesterday it wasn't necessarily the case. They didn't drill as hard as last year for example. Sivakov alone was leading for a very long time. A weaker team could've done the job of controlling the break yesterday.

 

[HashRouge]

Of course I watched the WC? Do you think it likely that without UAE (and rather oddly Bora) drilling the peloton, the break might have got slightly more rope than the maximum 3.5 minutes they were allowed?

I’m not arguing there would be a different result but a comparison with country representation where teams are not as strong is not really valid.

UAE has a ridiculously strong team for GT and hilly classics. Packed with riders that would otherwise contend for podiums. Are you suggesting Pogacar doesn’t benefit from that?

He definitely does, I think some posters are just making the point that he doesn't necessarily need that team strength as we've seen him win big, multiple times, without it. I think the reality is that if UAE were weaker, someone else would step in to control the break because they always do.

 

[HashRouge]

Bummed Simmons was not rewarded with a podium after such a great ride, but he has improved massively this season and is on a great trajectory. A very long race and he dusted some seriously strong riders. He is going to get a big one next season if he keeps this up; chapeau!!

I said the same thing to my sister yesterday. I think he has some big wins ahead of him, but he perhaps just needs to ride a little bit smarter. I know he's controversial, but trying to be objective and just judge him based on what he shows on the road, it would be good to see him take a GT stage or decent one day win.

 

[Peyroteo94]

Of course I watched the WC? Do you think it likely that without UAE (and rather oddly Bora) drilling the peloton, the break might have got slightly more rope than the maximum 3.5 minutes they were allowed?

I’m not arguing there would be a different result but a comparison with country representation where teams are not as strong is not really valid.

UAE has a ridiculously strong team for GT and hilly classics. Packed with riders that would otherwise contend for podiums. Are you suggesting Pogacar doesn’t benefit from that?

Of course but the outcome was the same even if he was riding for a poor team like Slovenia.

 

[Cycling111]

There's no picture of when Simmons dropped Del Toro?

 

[Red Rick]

UAE either thought going on Ganda was lower variance or they wanted to maximize the chances of Del Toro getting podium. Pogacar could have easily gone on Crocetta.

 

[Krzysztof_O]

UAE either thought going on Ganda was lower variance or they wanted to maximize the chances of Del Toro getting podium. Pogacar could have easily gone on Crocetta.

I think UAE was counting on two podium spots, that's why they didn't go hard on earlier climbs (plus going on Ganda is a pretty safe bet for Pog). El Toro had his (already usual) post 200 km crisis though.

 

[Netserk]

UAE either thought going on Ganda was lower variance or they wanted to maximize the chances of Del Toro getting podium. Pogacar could have easily gone on Crocetta.

I think UAE was counting on two podium spots, that's why they didn't go hard on earlier climbs (plus going on Ganda is a pretty safe bet for Pog). El Toro had his (already usual) post 200 km crisis though.

Fully agree with both of you.

Which is why Evenepoel should have attacked before Ganda.

 

[Peyroteo94]

Fully agree with both of you.

Which is why Evenepoel should have attacked before Ganda.

To prevent Del Toro's podium?

 

[Krzysztof_O]

To prevent Del Toro's podium?

To cause chaos in a very predictable race. Maybe he believed too much he could follow (or limit his loss) once Pog attacks.

 

[Peyroteo94]

To cause chaos in a very predictable race.

Then I agree with you.

 

[Cycling111]

To prevent Del Toro's podium?

Del Toro wouldn't have been on the podium. It's clear he struggles from the 200 kilometers. San Sebastian was a lower-level race, and he also struggled.

In any case, I don't know how attacking earlier would have benefited Remco. The agonistics races and long-distance attacks benefit Pogacar.


If the Tour were to bring back the 250km stages of other decades, Pogacar would be even more superior to Vingegaard, who seems to be another rider adapted to the modern mileage of GT races.

 

[Cycling111]

I think UAE was counting on two podium spots, that's why they didn't go hard on earlier climbs (plus going on Ganda is a pretty safe bet for Pog). El Toro had his (already usual) post 200 km crisis though.

Adam Yates could have worked, but he never did. I don't understand being eleventh serves for someone who finished on the podium in Lombardy three years ago....

 

[Pogacsa]

Don't you think a more charitable explanation for why Del Toro didn't do as well as some expected is that he raced last Saturday (and won!), raced on Sunday, raced Tuesday (and was in the thick of it until Pogacar escaped), and raced Thursday (and won!)

For a 21 year old, that is a lot of racing and not exactly ideal preparation for a podium finish yesterday. But did admirably well none-the-less

 

[Salvarani]

Don't you think a more charitable explanation for why Del Toro didn't do as well as some expected is that he raced last Saturday (and won!), raced on Sunday, raced Tuesday (and was in the thick of it until Pogacar escaped), and raced Thursday (and won!)

For a 21 year old, that is a lot of racing and not exactly ideal preparation for a podium finish yesterday. But did admirably well none-the-less

Finishing 5th is a great result here.

 

[Cycling111]

Don't you think a more charitable explanation for why Del Toro didn't do as well as some expected is that he raced last Saturday (and won!), raced on Sunday, raced Tuesday (and was in the thick of it until Pogacar escaped), and raced Thursday (and won!)

For a 21 year old, that is a lot of racing and not exactly ideal preparation for a podium finish yesterday. But did admirably well none-the-less

It could be, but the same thing has happened to him in all three races over 200 km this year, also in San Sebastian.
And in the Giro, he had his two worst days on the two toughest stages.

By the way, if Del Toro wins today, that fatigue theory...
I think it's clearly an endurance issue. He has room for improvement.

 

[Tim Cahill]

Don't you think a more charitable explanation for why Del Toro didn't do as well as some expected is that he raced last Saturday (and won!), raced on Sunday, raced Tuesday (and was in the thick of it until Pogacar escaped), and raced Thursday (and won!)

For a 21 year old, that is a lot of racing and not exactly ideal preparation for a podium finish yesterday. But did admirably well none-the-less

Young

 

[hayneplane]

The rise of the Young Guns this late in the season is a good sign the future will be interesting.

Worth mentioning Pellizzari in this as he got two strong GC results in Giro/Vuelta. Understandable to not be be his best here after that as I don’t think anyone who did GC at the Vuelta has had a strong result in the one dayers since then.

 

[hayneplane]

Adam Yates could have worked, but he never did. I don't understand being eleventh serves for someone who finished on the podium in Lombardy three years ago....

Yates has been living in past performances for a while with this now a frequent occurrence of him dropping prior to even feeling the first touch of wind to his face yet then continuing on to get a placement.

 

[Netserk]

Worth mentioning Pellizzari in this as he got two strong GC results in Giro/Vuelta. Understandable to not be be his best here after that as I don’t think anyone who did GC at the Vuelta has had a strong result in the one dayers since then.

Pidcock somewhat, thanks to his class.

 

[hayneplane]

Pidcock somewhat, thanks to his class.

Yes fair. Top ten here and 2nd in Emilia was close to the best he could do even if optimally prepared.