Team Visma LAB

[Krzysztof_O]

“We secretly hoped she wouldn’t win” – Marlen Reusser joins growing concern over Pauline Ferrand-Prévot's dramatic weight loss tactics at 2025 Tour de France Femmes

Marlen Reusser doesn’t often mince her words. The Swiss time trial specialist and trained physician has long been a voice of reason and reflection in the professional peloton — but her recent comments...

cyclinguptodate.com

Losing 4 kilos since Roubaix is huge and I'm wondering how much of it was muscles and how much fat? (maybe 50/50?). How they managed it without losing form is interesting.

As for weight concerns, Kenyan or Ethiopian runners looked almost like from concentration camps for decades. Endurance athletes being super thin is really nothing new.

 

[Divergence]

“We secretly hoped she wouldn’t win” – Marlen Reusser joins growing concern over Pauline Ferrand-Prévot's dramatic weight loss tactics at 2025 Tour de France Femmes

Marlen Reusser doesn’t often mince her words. The Swiss time trial specialist and trained physician has long been a voice of reason and reflection in the professional peloton — but her recent comments...

cyclinguptodate.com

Losing 4 kilos since Roubaix is huge and I'm wondering how much of it was muscles and how much fat? (maybe 50/50?). How they managed it without losing form is interesting.

As for weight concerns, Kenyan or Ethiopian runners looked almost like from concentration camps for decades. Endurance athletes being super thin is really nothing new.

It is a myth that losing weight means losing muscle. Many so called nutritionists do not understand physiology and idk when and where but this myth was formed. And riders like believing it is true. It takes off the pressure to be super disciplined with your diet.
The reality is that if one goes on about losing wight in a proper manner (not by starving), weight can be lost, muscle mass preserved and the athlete would never experience REDS.

 

[pastronef]

"we secretly hoped she wouldn't win"
ffs
what's that
Reusser and Vollering are former XD-Works riders, a team that butchered races and rivals with a huge show of superiority.
and oh boy, they're suddenly concerned about Pauline
bad losers. just bad losers

 

[Krzysztof_O]

It is a myth that losing weight means losing muscle. Many so called nutritionists do not understand physiology and idk when and where but this myth was formed. And riders like believing it is true. It takes off the pressure to be super disciplined with your diet.
The reality is that if one goes on about losing wight in a proper manner (not by starving), weight can be lost, muscle mass preserved and the athlete would never experience REDS.

So was all 4 kg fat? It would mean she was operating at quite a high fat % during Roubaix. I would think she was a bit more powerful during a race like Roubaix (so some muscle lost as well).

 

[Valv.Piti]

Listening to these girls like Demi and Reusser is just super cringe. W/kg is king (or queen), they know that.

 

[yaco]

"we secretly hoped she wouldn't win"
ffs
what's that
Reusser and Vollering are former XD-Works riders, a team that butchered races and rivals with a huge show of superiority.
and oh boy, they're suddenly concerned about Pauline
bad losers. just bad losers

Grace Brown of the Cyclists Alliance today bemoaned the endless debate about the weights of the female peleton, among some other thoughtful suggestions to do with health. However, this endless debate is being fuelled by statements from the female peleton and they are not doing themselves any favors. I'd argue the mens peleton ( GC types ) is even skinnier and their is no debate about them,especially from fellow riders. It does seem like a case of sour grapes.

 

[Divergence]

So was all 4 kg fat? It would mean she was operating at quite a high fat % during Roubaix. I would think she was a bit more powerful during a race like Roubaix (so some muscle lost as well).

I would say that it is very possible that a very high portion of the 5kg was fat. Maybe some fluids. And maybe a little muscle mass loss both from where it matters and from where it does not but nothing too significant. I would guess she does not have a lower absolute power now compared to PR. Probably even higher.

 

[Rackham]

Grace Brown of the Cyclists Alliance today bemoaned the endless debate about the weights of the female peleton, among some other thoughtful suggestions to do with health. However, this endless debate is being fuelled by statements from the female peleton and they are not doing themselves any favors. I'd argue the mens peleton ( GC types ) is even skinnier and their is no debate about them,especially from fellow riders. It does seem like a case of sour grapes.

Grace Brown with the take of the ages, i.e. turning a medical conversation into a war of the sexes.

She has it backwards, as per usual for such 'outspoken' people, i.e. people care more about women than they do men. And no matter the protestations it'll always be troubling when women lose 4kg in a few months, miss their monthlies and hit the skeleton levels for various reasons, i.e. with the socially indisputable fact anorexia is statistically a female centric problem playing a big role in the reactions you're seeing.

We've just had a decade + of war on skinny models and thinness. Now suddenly with Ozempic taking off like it's skittles and big pharma pushing weight loss drugs, we've gone full circle and we're back to "how dare you hypocritical misogynists talk about weight!". More power to PFP for pulling something risky off the way she did but it's not an example for "young girls". And before someone says that was never the point - au contraire, that's entirely the point of televised sport, i.e. to influence French girls into emulating the 'wins' of such a champion in their daily lives no matter the nature of their pursuits.

And because this is the clinic I'll call a spade a spade here: massive weight loss combined with maintaining power levels has the smell of PED's written all over it. That's most likely an 'unspoken' truth in the women's peloton right now and I'd wager it's playing a role in some of the reactions you're seeing, such as the critical comments by Marlen Reusser.

 

[Libertine Seguros]

And because this is the clinic I'll call a spade a spade here: massive weight loss combined with maintaining power levels has the smell of PED's written all over it. That's most likely an 'unspoken' truth in the women's peloton right now and I'd wager it's playing a role in some of the reactions you're seeing, such as the critical comments by Marlen Reusser.

It was a thought that occurred to me, definitely, that the discourse being framed that way is a helpfully innocent way to be able to say "something doesn't feel right here" without having to know or say anything dangerous.

As I said yesterday, the women's péloton has never really had to deal with super-peakers for this type of race, only the ITT mayflies, for at least a generation, so for a lot of these riders, they're used to the riders who are the best over a type of terrain being at least among the best over that terrain all year long, while selective calendars and super-peaking have got a bad rep from the Lance generation that a lot of these riders grew up having drilled into them, so when the status quo is so comprehensively ripped up by somebody who hasn't got the long history of riding at least among the best on that kind of terrain, it would cause a bit of disquiet even if there were no other implications, because it fundamentally changes what the péloton thinks it has known for the last several years.

 

[Revelation]

Destroyer of (cycling) worlds. Clearly going over the top on both sides to win at all cost, thankfully Pogacar was there at least on the men's side to stop them.