The Hitch said:
Another way to look at it is that Gilbert can only do classics with loads of hills in them. He just about manages when the hills are cobbled.
Joaquim Rodriguez can do hilly classics, mountain stages of gts, and overall gts.
Its a bit dumb to claim that a guy who cant tt cant perform in stage races cant really sprint or do cobbles and sure as hell cant climb mountains, is definately not a 1 trick pony yet label Purito as such.
Rodriguez can only climb, so naturally he's going to be up there in GTs and the hillier one day races where a climber has the advantage as well.
He can't time trial: he's absolutely horrible in it. He'll never win a GT or a stage race with a time trial in it(and every stage race should have some time trial kms...).
He can't descent.
Every climber in the peloton can get over big hills otherwise they wouldn't really be climbers now would they?
If Rodriguez is not a one trick pony then I don't know who is...
Gilbert just about manages cobbles? He got third twice in the Ronde. He dropped everyone on the Kemmelberg in the Tour of Belgium. He dropped everyone on the Gitsberg at the Belgian nats. And you say he can just about manage hills with cobbles on?
And Gilbert can't handle flat cobbles?
http://www.sporza.be/permalink/1.516750
http://www.sporza.be/permalink/1.516747
Gilbert has a few top 10 placings in GT time trials by the way. It's already an impressive result for Jrod if he can finish inside the top 100 on a flat time trial.