What are you guys even discussing? Obviously crashes, mishaps etc. ARE legitimate excuses, and often there's no way of telling if a rider would have won/done better in other circumstances. One important thing as a top athlete is the mental mindset, and if the Winners gene is strong, the riders themselves will usually use (misuse?) these excuses to pad their confidence towards new goals.
Why it should be any different with fans beats me. And it's not solely on Remco fans, It's human to look for reasons to defeats, regardless if it's pure speculation or not.
With regards to todays race, Remco should win over Tarling, since his form is proven.