BMC in disarray?

Page 5 - Get up to date with the latest news, scores & standings from the Cycling News Community.
Aug 29, 2011
3,701
2,090
16,680
jens_attacks said:
i'm now 100% sure they will unleash the beast on the poggio.

It almost looks like it. Perhaps holding back a little, and then when they're think you weak...

No, doubt that.
 
May 12, 2010
1,998
0
0
Peyote said:
I think he will play a big role in Vlaanderen. There is still Tirreno and Sanremo (300km) to get in shape

Yeah, but if you look at the level that guys like Boonen, Flecha and Cancellara have now, he has to make a lot of progress to even match these guys (who presumably will improve to De Ronde as well). Not impossible, but time is running short for those races (not for AGR, Fleche and Liège of course).
 
Mar 6, 2011
45
0
0
Lanark said:
Yeah, but if you look at the level that guys like Boonen, Flecha and Cancellara have now, he has to make a lot of progress to even match these guys (who presumably will improve to De Ronde as well). Not impossible, but time is running short for those races (not for AGR, Fleche and Liège of course).

It will be hard to defeat them. Impossible maybe if you look at Cancellara today. But he aims at the Ardennes. And i think that's smart. Especially this year.
 
Jan 11, 2010
15,621
4,560
28,180
Peyote said:
It will be hard to defeat them. Impossible maybe if you look at Cancellara today. But he aims at the Ardennes. And i think that's smart. Especially this year.
He aimed for the Ardennes last year as well, and it's fair to say he was a bit stronger already at this stage. Although not much. I think Strade Bianche was simply raced a little harder this year.
 
Aug 29, 2011
3,701
2,090
16,680
Instead of firing cannonballs at everything, Gilbert will just fire precision bullets at every monument this time. Much more effective.
 
Mar 10, 2009
9,245
23
17,530
Lanark said:
Ballan and Van Avermaet actually worked quite well together today, Cancellara was just hors category.

I know this all in hindsight, but I couldn't understand what they seeked to gain by attacking when they did. It just seems to me that it would've been best to wait for Cancellara to attack, see if they could reel him in which would've been more likely had they not attacked and wasted resources earlier, and then counter attack once he's reeled in. It seemed to me Cancellara rode the much smarter race. Ballan and Van Avermaet's attacks seemed way too early to achieve anything other leaving them both with nothing left to respond when Cancellara made his move. Bennati wasn't likely to stay away IMO anyway. He's no breakaway expert, nor is he a dangerous solo/tt'ist.
 
Mar 10, 2009
1,384
0
0
thehog said:
Be that as it may he is always firing at this part of the season.

Besides he had loads left at the end of last season. In fact he rode strong all year.

I don't think you know what you're talking about.

This year is a different year for Phil. He doesn't have anything to prove with regard to the Ardennes classics. And last year, Phil did not have the Olympics or WC to shoot for. Of course, given the later weighting of his race programme his training will be structured to peak later or at least to peak twice. Expecting him to deliver results in what amount to 3rd tier races is just naive.
 
Dec 30, 2011
3,547
0
0
thehog said:
Be that as it may he is always firing at this part of the season.

Besides he had loads left at the end of last season. In fact he rode strong all year.

I don't think you know what you're talking about.
You evidently didn't watch Lombardia last year, Gilbert was absolutely shattered.
 

thehog

BANNED
Jul 27, 2009
31,285
2
22,485
Froome19 said:
You evidently didn't watch Lombardia last year, Gilbert was absolutely shattered.

You obviously have no idea who you are talking to.

Don't speak to me like this again.
 
Jan 27, 2012
15,231
2,623
28,180
thehog said:
They should have won today.

I still see no problem. The team decided to let GvA and Ballan have a go before the real action starts. I am 100% sure, Gilbert could have played in the final if he and the team wanted to. At this point everybody understands their position in the team without getting told. The plan didn't win anything today, but it will later.
 
Mar 13, 2009
2,890
0
0
1 or 2 mistakes in hindsight, Ballan should have ridden for GVA, should have marked Cancellara. Lesson learned move on. Had a rider in the early break, took responsibility to chase Bennati, attacked late in the race. Solid signs early in the season I'd say. Rode for the win instead of riding for second.
 
Jun 14, 2010
34,930
60
22,580
Angliru said:
I know this all in hindsight, but I couldn't understand what they seeked to gain by attacking when they did. It just seems to me that it would've been best to wait for Cancellara to attack, see if they could reel him in which would've been more likely had they not attacked and wasted resources earlier, and then counter attack once he's reeled in. It seemed to me Cancellara rode the much smarter race. Ballan and Van Avermaet's attacks seemed way too early to achieve anything other leaving them both with nothing left to respond when Cancellara made his move. Bennati wasn't likely to stay away IMO anyway. He's no breakaway expert, nor is he a dangerous solo/tt'ist.

They attacked when they did so that canc would work to bring one back and then the other would attack. Probably didn't know canc was that strong and might have been better to attack on a flat where there's more slipstream. in hindsight nothing probably would have worked.

Oh and el p, call me when Phil does a 13 km solo vs a group like that rather than just another attack on the last hill :D

Im losing count of how many times canc does it.
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
The Hitch said:
They attacked when they did so that canc would work to bring one back and then the other would attack. Probably didn't know canc was that strong and might have been better to attack on a flat where there's more slipstream. in hindsight nothing probably would have worked.

Oh and el p, call me when Phil does a 13 km solo vs a group like that rather than just another attack on the last hill :D

Im losing count of how many times canc does it.

This.

When Bennati went, no BMC. Why? Liquigas saw it. At least Oss was astute enough to see what was going to happen. He was shelled but he raced his bike.

BMC could not let Canc have a free ride. BMC could not be put in the position to chase. They did both.

Not a great start. But, the season is young and they will win their fair share.
 
Jan 27, 2012
15,231
2,623
28,180
karlboss said:
1 or 2 mistakes in hindsight, Ballan should have ridden for GVA, should have marked Cancellara. Lesson learned move on. Had a rider in the early break, took responsibility to chase Bennati, attacked late in the race. Solid signs early in the season I'd say. Rode for the win instead of riding for second.

Sure, the end game tactics could have been better, but none of the BMC riders in the final could have touched Cancellara today in any case. GvA and Ballan no match for Cancellara in form.
 
Mar 13, 2009
2,890
0
0
Dazed and Confused said:
Sure, the end game tactics could have been better, but none of the BMC riders in the final could have touched Cancellara today in any case. GvA and Ballan no match for Cancellara in form.
Not so sure, If GVA didn't work to bring bennati back, and then sat on Cancellara's wheel...but we'll never know.