Commentary on TNT and other WB brands

Page 33 - Get up to date with the latest news, scores & standings from the Cycling News Community.
Sep 8, 2012
110
0
0
argyllflyer said:
The long stages with no so much happening really requires someone like David Harmon.

The long stages with no so much happening really requires David Duffield.

It's a pity there is no English speaking commentator who can effortlessly alternate between the roles of erudite gentleman, competent observer, cynical wag and ferocious cheerleader as the occasion requires.
 
May 19, 2011
96
0
0
batchuba said:
The long stages with no so much happening really requires David Duffield.

It's a pity there is no English speaking commentator who can effortlessly alternate between the roles of erudite gentleman, competent observer, cynical wag and ferocious cheerleader as the occasion requires.

Man you should really be swedish. Roberto Vacchi is commentating legend and we're very lucky to have him. He checks of all the points you describe and more.
Häj.
 
Apr 10, 2011
4,818
0
0
Anyone could do that. IF you want that kind of thing then just hire some Brazillian commentators into cycling or just listen to the Norwegian pair.
 
Libertine Seguros said:
Kirby is great at calling the sprints and late attacks, if he remembers Samuel Dumoulin isn't in the race. His call of the Iljo Keisse win in Turkey last year was epic.

their was another feed on eurosport for me that day, young lad by himself going beserk was great.

eurosport should have worlds since they cover all the races
 
kirby/kelly completely missed/ignored the split in the peloton on the descent today, it was infuriating. not that there were really any great camera views of it, but i saw it pretty clearly myself. say what you want about phil and paul, they are far from great lately, but i doubt they would have failed to notice that split and/or not mention it at all. just awful commentating.
 
Oct 6, 2009
5,270
2
0
Kirby also kept yammering on while the graphics for top 40 stage finishers were on-screen, never commenting on them, nor noticing the time losses by Uran, Konig, Majka, Pinot, Mollema, etc. Not that every one of these were vital, or wholly unexpected, but you'd think a decent commentator would mention the GC shakeup.

But no, for him, apparently the GC significance goes no deeper than who's wearing the red jersey.
 
Sep 8, 2012
110
0
0
zlev11 said:
kirby/kelly completely missed/ignored the split in the peloton on the descent today, it was infuriating. not that there were really any great camera views of it, but i saw it pretty clearly myself. say what you want about phil and paul, they are far from great lately, but i doubt they would have failed to notice that split and/or not mention it at all. just awful commentating.

This has been one of the absolute worst commentary displays I've ever experienced.

Kirby, basically, doesn't give the slightest ****, because there is no Sky guys in there. He just keeps airily wittering away, occasionally mentioning something which happened a few minutes ago or getting a little enthused when an ( the ) anglophone goes to the front.

Kelly too, has been bad. Usually the reliable voice of reason, he has been confused and distracted too. In fairness though, he often has to try to find a way to drag the conversation back to the present while answering whatever cretinous and irrelevant point Kirby has put forth for prolonged discussion.

Yesterday, while attacks and counter-attacks were coming from the GC group on the final climb, the pair of them studiously ignored it all. They actually became an impediment to understanding, by overwhelming us with a stream of derisory waffling. And far from adding some sense of drama and excitement, they actively drained any sense of occasion from the day.

Kirby has adopted a peculiar bored, glazed-over, near patronizing tone throughout, as if he is watching a charity ride. The team are somehow making good racing a depressing chore. I'm ****ing done with them.

Finding myself a Flemish feed for the next stages. As far as I can make out, the Flemish language is mostly quotes from 1980's Arnold Schwarzenegger movies cobbled together, so its understandable enough.
 
batchuba said:
Finding myself a Flemish feed for the next stages. As far as I can make out, the Flemish language is mostly quotes from 1980's Arnold Schwarzenegger movies cobbled together, so its understandable enough.

This earlier response seems appropriate to repost.
Herr Katt said:
Man you should really be swedish. Roberto Vacchi is commentating legend and we're very lucky to have him. He checks of all the points you describe and more.
Häj.

Although I think he is somewhat better in the Giro (since he is of Italian origin) and the Tour (bysitter chemistry) than in the VueltA. Perhaps not that easy to find a swedish feed though...
 
when the pictures don't tell the story, the commentators need to be far more proactive about telling it, almost as if it were radio. I have been bamboozled at points in recent stages and I really miss David Harmon who could make these kind of stages come alive.
 
Sep 8, 2012
110
0
0
Hakkapelit said:
This earlier response seems appropriate to repost.


Although I think he is somewhat better in the Giro (since he is of Italian origin) and the Tour (bysitter chemistry) than in the VueltA. Perhaps not that easy to find a swedish feed though...

Aye, by the sounds of things, it would be worth learning Swedish just to be able to guzzle it. Spose I could shell out for the Eurosport player and choose whichever I wanted..

Incidentally, I (predictably not following through on my empty "threat") did watch the lads again yesterday and were back to "normal" at least. That is to say, they paid some attention to the race.

Meh, maybe the tantrum inducing performance of two days ago was a once off.
 
Sep 14, 2011
1,980
0
0
If Harmon isn't coming back, let's just hope that Eurosport do the sensible thing and make Rob Hatch their main cycling commentator. Kirby is getting beyond a joke, his Richeze comment yesterday was his worst so far.
 
Aug 27, 2012
51
0
0
Bernie's eyesore said:
If Harmon isn't coming back, let's just hope that Eurosport do the sensible thing and make Rob Hatch their main cycling commentator. Kirby is getting beyond a joke, his Richeze comment yesterday was his worst so far.

Bad but climbing the "uncategorised 'Cabeza de Carrera'" took the biscuit.

I must say reading the chat regards Dave Harmon is just really saddening, sorely missed as others have noted.
 
Jul 25, 2010
372
0
0
Harmon is busy with life, new love & business interests taking up his time, he's happy. There's an article knocking around the internets.