• The Cycling News forum is still looking to add volunteer moderators with. If you're interested in helping keep our discussions on track, send a direct message to @SHaines here on the forum, or use the Contact Us form to message the Community Team.

    In the meanwhile, please use the Report option if you see a post that doesn't fit within the forum rules.

    Thanks!

Harcore cycling - road rash? Hold my beer!

Singer01

BANNED
Nov 18, 2013
2,043
2
5,485
After Nibali got up of the floor yesterday and did what had to be done (though ultimately futile, except gaining some massive 'man up' points), what other incidents of cyclists proving themselves warriors can you think of?
G and his pelvis, Tyler's breakaway with a broken collarbone and Hoogerland doing his Hellraiser impression are the ones that stand out in my memory.
 
Magni 1956 Giro is unbeatable for anyone.

From bikeraceinfo.com report of the race:

Coppi wasn’t the only rider suffering from bad luck. Magni explains, “During stage twelve [sometimes called stage ten because different accounts handle the two days of half-stages differently], from Grosseto to Livorno, I crashed on the descent out of Volterra and broke my left collarbone. At the hospital they said I should put on a plaster cast and quit. But I didn't want to. Since the next day was a rest day, I told the doctor to do nothing and that we should wait and see. The day after, I asked the doctor to put on an elastic bandage instead of a cast because I wanted to try to ride the following stage, Livorno to Lucca. It worked! I wasn't among the first riders but I finished.”

In fact, the next stage Magni referred to was a 45-kilometer individual time trial to Lucca. Fornara won the time trial, giving him the lead with Fantini 43 seconds behind.

[...]

Magni, however, was still having trouble with his broken collarbone. “Just before the stage started I tried to ride my bike on a climb and I noticed I couldn't use the muscles of my left arm to pull on the handlebar very hard. So my mechanic, Faliero Masi, the best mechanic of all time, cut a piece of inner tube and suggested I pull it with my mouth. That was a great idea!”

Meanwhile misfortune stuck to Magni like velcro. Stage sixteen to Rapallo took the Giro over the Apennines where Magni crashed again, this time breaking his humerus. “I didn’t have enough strength in my left arm,” he said, “and I crashed after hitting a ditch by the road. I fell on my already broken bone and fainted from the pain. The ambulance came to bring me to the hospital. In the ambulance they gave me water and I got back on my feet. When I realized that I was being taken to the hospital I screamed and told the driver to stop. I didn't want to abandon the Giro.

“I mounted my bike again and restarted pedaling. The peloton had waited for me, so I arrived in Rapallo in a relatively good position. I had no idea of how serious my condition was, I just knew that I was in a lot of pain but I didn't want to have X-rays that evening. During the days that followed I could hold my own.”The race arrived at the Dolomites for stage nineteen, a trip from Sondrio over the Stelvio (the not-so-famous south face) to Merano. The day’s riding didn’t change a lot. Torpado rider Cleto Maule won the stage with the bashed and battered Magni somehow second. Now it was Gaul’s turn to suffer at the hands of Lady Luck, having been harassed by three punctures on a day that should have been his. Instead, he finished in the second chasing group, six minutes behind Maule.

[...]

Fiorenzo Magni, riding with both a broken collarbone and humerus, finished third that fateful day in the Dolomites, 12 minutes 15 seconds behind Gaul. But it was enough to elevate him to second place overall.

About that day in frozen Hell, Magni said, “It snowed the whole day and it was very cold; I had not noticed how much. Along the way I saw many bikes parked next to bars and I asked what was going on. They told me that most of the peloton froze and had to quit. Then, before reaching Trent I saw the Pink Jersey quitting too! ‘What?? Am I seeing things?’ I wondered. If I were the Pink Jersey I would have continued, even if I had to walk, but I would never abandon!
“When we were in Trent my team car came up to me and said I was third. ‘Third!?!,’ I wondered again. I was third that day and became second in the GC.
“Actually, I thought about attacking Charly Gaul in the following stages and trying to win my fourth Giro. I tried attacking him a couple of times during the last two stages, but he was too strong.”

http://www.bikeraceinfo.com/giro/giro1956.html
 
Cool story about Magni. Probably unbeatable.

Although I recall a story from the 50's of a rider who apparently was hit by a boulder in a landslide in the Tour. The same race he apparently had already had a serious mishap by landing on a donkey and ridden on it until getting thrown off (I think journalists at the time were a bit fanciful).

Amador once completed the Tour after breaking his ankle on stage one.
 

Singer01

BANNED
Nov 18, 2013
2,043
2
5,485
Re:

King Boonen said:
Warriors or idiots, it’s such a fine line after all. Personally I think perpetuating the idea that riders should put themselves at significantly increased risk for our entertainment is pretty horrible.

I think it depends on the role as well, a Nibali deciding to get back on is one thing, a domestique being 'encouraged' to stay in the race is another.
 
Aug 31, 2012
7,550
3
0
Praising the warrior mentality, and pointing out how some true warriors would have continued in similar circumstances when someone quits (eg Porte), creates such a preassure
 

Singer01

BANNED
Nov 18, 2013
2,043
2
5,485
Re:

SeriousSam said:
Praising the warrior mentality, and pointing out how some true warriors would have continued in similar circumstances when someone quits (eg Porte), creates such a preassure
Not my intention. I've played on in a football match with a (minor) broken ankle. I've also had to walk off with a migraine.
 
Ilona Hoeksma was caught up in a pile-up in the last kilometre of stage 3 of the 2016 Route de France, breaking her shoulder, her collarbone, five ribs and five vertebrae, and suffering a collapsed lung. Although it took her over 10 minutes, she got up and crossed the line under her own steam in case she could be healthy to start the stage the following day.
 
Re:

RedheadDane said:
I may be naive, but I trust that nobody are being pressured to ride if they really can't continue.
Otoh, I think quite a few riders have to literally be told to stop sometimes.
I think that’s incredibly naive. You just need to watch a few races to see that riders are constantly encouraged to get back on and get riding.
 
Re: Re:

Singer01 said:
King Boonen said:
Warriors or idiots, it’s such a fine line after all. Personally I think perpetuating the idea that riders should put themselves at significantly increased risk for our entertainment is pretty horrible.

I think it depends on the role as well, a Nibali deciding to get back on is one thing, a domestique being 'encouraged' to stay in the race is another.
It all perpetuates the idea that they should get up and get riding until they physically can’t anymore. It’s not just cycling, every other sport has the same problem and they are slowly starting to tackle it.
 
Re: Re:

King Boonen said:
RedheadDane said:
I may be naive, but I trust that nobody are being pressured to ride if they really can't continue.
Otoh, I think quite a few riders have to literally be told to stop sometimes.
I think that’s incredibly naive. You just need to watch a few races to see that riders are constantly encouraged to get back on and get riding.
Who was that guy trying to get back on his bike with clear concussion symptoms in an American race? That was some scary sh*t.
 
Re: Re:

SafeBet said:
King Boonen said:
RedheadDane said:
I may be naive, but I trust that nobody are being pressured to ride if they really can't continue.
Otoh, I think quite a few riders have to literally be told to stop sometimes.
I think that’s incredibly naive. You just need to watch a few races to see that riders are constantly encouraged to get back on and get riding.
Who was that guy trying to get back on his bike with clear concussion symptoms in an American race? That was some scary sh*t.
That’s one I was thinking of, can’t remember who. He was so out of it didn’t they have to point him in the right direction?
 
Re:

King Boonen said:
Warriors or idiots, it’s such a fine line after all. Personally I think perpetuating the idea that riders should put themselves at significantly increased risk for our entertainment is pretty horrible.

Idiots more likely.Unfortunately the teams seems to encourage them to carry on in situation where is clear they are not able to do it.Imo the teams are more to blame than the riders.Seeing Contador back on the bike after that horrendous crash wasn't acceptable,just one example on the endless list.
 
I think it’s the nature of the sport that creates the pressure; nobody wants to climb into the car only to be told at the hospital “it’s just minor bruising, if you want to continue your bike race tomorrow, you can...” And every minute spent at the side of the road trying to work out if your extremities are all functional, the peloton is another 0.8km up the road. As said earlier, more often than not it’s the rider who wants to get on his bike, sometimes even against the wishes of support staff/DS’s etc.

And maybe that’s something that the UCI could look into, a facility to allow a rider to go to hospital on the race doctor’s recommendation, and still start the following day if they receive the all clear. Probably something that could be abused more than TUE’s, but worth investigating?
 
Talking of people who continued in a race when they shouldn't have done there was the Chris Horner one from the 2011 tour where he crashed and suffered concussion (same crash that Wiggins had to retire because of). He carried on to the finish but seemed to have no idea what had happened and despite being told several times he crashed he kept on asking what had happened. Can't find the original video but the link below talks about it.

http://articles.latimes.com/2012/may/12/sports/la-sp-amgen-tour-20120513