gillan1969 said:sniper said:Ullrich grew up in Eastern Germany.
Sorry, but his early results mean very little as he was very possibly doped already as a junior.
yup but he was a good GC rider young...doped or undoped...
armstrong was not a good GC rider young (doped or undoped) he was a punchy classics guy.....neither was wiggins (pursuit) or Froome (just sh*t) or Horner (not that good)...they do not pass the straight face test
now we have G Thomas who seemlessly combines the ability of the northern one day specialist and now super climber...again...straight face test...fail
Ullrich, roche, lemond, delgado and even Indurain, who was on a steady trajectory, do pass the straight face test...doped or otherwise...although Indurian should never have been able to climb 'that' fast.......
The Hegelian said:Salient point about Indurain. In the end, we're not in the sphere of reasoning here, but the old straight face test somehow just works!
One always had the sense in those Indurain tours, that Bugno or Chiapucci or some other climber were going to properly crack him, and it was always frustrating that they never could. But, illusory as it was, it was not so unbelievable that the entire narrative collapses into comedy.
42x16ss said:del1962 said:i thought this was an Armstrong thread not a thread for posters to repeat there opinions we have heard time and time again on other riders LOL![]()
Andynonomous said:I know that it is speculative, but how many Tour de France's DO YOU THINK that Armstrong would have won, if everybody (including Armstrong) rode clean ? Just give me a number.
I ask this, because the tennis crowd (MensTennisForums) are asking.
The Hegelian said:gillan1969 said:sniper said:Ullrich grew up in Eastern Germany.
Sorry, but his early results mean very little as he was very possibly doped already as a junior.
yup but he was a good GC rider young...doped or undoped...
armstrong was not a good GC rider young (doped or undoped) he was a punchy classics guy.....neither was wiggins (pursuit) or Froome (just sh*t) or Horner (not that good)...they do not pass the straight face test
now we have G Thomas who seemlessly combines the ability of the northern one day specialist and now super climber...again...straight face test...fail
Ullrich, roche, lemond, delgado and even Indurain, who was on a steady trajectory, do pass the straight face test...doped or otherwise...although Indurian should never have been able to climb 'that' fast.......
Salient point about Indurain. In the end, we're not in the sphere of reasoning here, but the old straight face test somehow just works!
One always had the sense in those Indurain tours, that Bugno or Chiapucci or some other climber were going to properly crack him, and it was always frustrating that they never could. But, illusory as it was, it was not so unbelievable that the entire narrative collapses into comedy.