Yeah, it's probably hard for any of us to shed all the bias in favour of our favorite teams, riders, players, etc. Fans develop a very emotional investment in sport. It's often hard to admit when a rival athlete or team is actually better.He wasn't at his best in neither case, and pushing big numbers on Plateau de beille is not any indication of that due to some clinical issues.
The signals were all there, lack of explosion, trouble in long climbs, he weighs even less because he lost a lot of muscular mass. I overestimated a lot what he could do on this Tour, but that's natural being super emotional and have a BIAS when you talk about your favourite rider.
In the end, it doesn't matter. It just gives us fodder for message board discussion until the next race.