Oldman said:
Probably single biggest difference between Old/New School is rider's taking a more educated course to their results. You can't and shouldn't try to peak for every race.
As for Lance or Carmichael having a new strategy-they were working off of models developed for Bugno, Indurain, Rominger, etc. Carmichael managed to create a franchise business out of hyping his programs but most of the basic information was available to anyone looking. The explosion in coaches and "coaches" is amazing. I reserve the quotes for those technicians that feel everything is analyzable and quantifiable. Old School types would go purely on pedigree and emotion. There should be lots of opinions on training origins, paths.
I couldn't agree more with this. Carmichael's techniques were quite simple and obvious, and it's just what Brodeal below says, the Europeans were lazy, and didn't bother trying new techniques becoz they were stuck/raised in the old skool..
IMO, Carmichael took the 'marathon training' approach and adapted it to cycling, with the sole aim of peaking for one race throughout the year (maybe this equivalent is one of the major marathons in the world)
This is nothing new, it was just 'different' to the common european belief of, 'i'll ride, race a bit, and try and capitalise if/when my form peaks', rather than actually targeted, progressive training techniques.
Another thing, you have to be the best of the best to actually ask your team manager if you can focus on one race per year, as the team invests money in you. Lance could afford to do this, and it's clear that this has been Contador's approach as well.
Other riders that have adopted this approach, I would say are guys like Cadel Evans, Andy Schleck (although those two do have Ardennes classics aspirations as well), Carlos Sastre (in 2008 especially) have all been targeting the Tour, and forgoe the Giro or delibretely hold back in week-long stage races so as to not 'overrace' before the tour. Classic example of overracing would be Menchov in the Giro (which I think was smart) and then was burnt out for the tour.
But of course, guys mentioned like Indurain (Tours), Rominger (Vueltas) also showed that targeted training for a specific goal is the way to really win.
The only problem with targeting one race, is, if you have a bad year, management may turn on you very quickly becuase basically your season looks like a waste (i.e. Silence threatening Cadel to be no#2 after the tour - yet changed their mind when he podiumed Vuelta and won WC.... Also, Rabo threatening Menchov with no#2 behind gesink -see other thread)