Not sure that it didn't hurt. He looked a bit off on the climbs but there could be other reasons for it.
The Cycling News forum is looking to add some volunteer moderators with Red Rick's recent retirement. If you're interested in helping keep our discussions on track, send a direct message to
In the meanwhile, please use the Report option if you see a post that doesn't fit within the forum rules.
Thanks!
Christian said:Andy already said he went into this year's Tour heavier than usual because of increased muscle mass ... didn't hurt his climbing but didn't really help his ITT either
Swabian Lass said:It will be interesting to see if JB can make a difference to Andy's TT. Because if he can't then Andy might as well not bother turning up if the leaked course info is correct.
Andy's talked a lot about working on his TT in the past, but I'm not convinced that he's taken it really seriously yet. I think that he's thought that he can put enough time into the other GC contenders in the mountains that he can get away with a less than optimal TT. Well, that didn't work this year and it certainly won't work next year. It's time to get serious.
I'll be fascinated to see if there's an improvement next year.
If that's the case, I say go back to last year's preparation... because he certainly seemed to be climbing with more ease, Contador being unable to drop him, ánd his TT was much better, putting Contador under serious pressure. Schleck on the Alpe d'Huez in 2008 was just toying with Evans, Schleck on the Alpe this year couldn't do anything.Christian said:Andy already said he went into this year's Tour heavier than usual because of increased muscle mass ... didn't hurt his climbing but didn't really help his ITT either
Swabian Lass said:It will be interesting to see if JB can make a difference to Andy's TT. Because if he can't then Andy might as well not bother turning up if the leaked course info is correct.
Andy's talked a lot about working on his TT in the past, but I'm not convinced that he's taken it really seriously yet. I think that he's thought that he can put enough time into the other GC contenders in the mountains that he can get away with a less than optimal TT. Well, that didn't work this year and it certainly won't work next year. It's time to get serious.
I'll be fascinated to see if there's an improvement next year.
That's just BS, remember last year? Andy was definitely good on a TT bike then. At least, not horifically bad.Thomsena said:Andy will never be any good on a TT bike. Nor will Frank. Not even JB-'magic' can change that.
theyoungest said:If that's the case, I say go back to last year's preparation... because he certainly seemed to be climbing with more ease, Contador being unable to drop him, ánd his TT was much better, putting Contador under serious pressure. Schleck on the Alpe d'Huez in 2008 was just toying with Evans, Schleck on the Alpe this year couldn't do anything.
That's just cliched talk of the Danish "the evil Schlecks backstabbed Saint Riis" cycling fan. Amirite?Thomsena said:Ok. Let me rephrase that..
Andy will never be any good on a TT bike compared to the hard working, dedicated top-favorites.. Nor will Frank. Not even JB-'magic' can change that.
Happy?
theyoungest said:That's just cliched talk of the Danish "the evil Schlecks backstabbed Saint Riis" cycling fan. Amirite?
I'm no Schleck fan, but it's a bit boring to keep reading about how awful his TTing is, when in fact the whole generation of new GC riders (Nibali, Kreuziger, Gesink) is equally bad. I don't think any of those guys would have done a better TT in Grenoble than Schleck, who was equal on time with guys like Westra and Malori.
No, certainly Kreuziger isn't. In a TT at the end of a grand tour, Schleck will beat him 9 times out of 10.GJB123 said:Any none of the riders you mentioned will have a snowball's chance in hell of winning the TdF. Besides that I think that objectively both Kreuziger and Nibali are intrinsically beter TT'er than any of the Schlecks will ever be.
Regards
GJ
theyoungest said:No, certainly Kreuziger isn't. In a TT at the end of a grand tour, Schleck will beat him 9 times out of 10.
In a one week race it's a different story.
Maybe, but none of these three riders constantly gets comments about his supposed laziness and lack of work ethic and complete suckage in the TT.GJB123 said:I haven't reviewed the statitstics, so I will take your word for it even though I think they hardly ever contested a TT at the end of a GT in anger in the same year. But even if it is true, that doesnt change my point that none of the three riders you mentioned will ever win the TdF.
theyoungest said:No, certainly Kreuziger isn't. In a TT at the end of a grand tour, Schleck will beat him 9 times out of 10.
In a one week race it's a different story.
theyoungest said:That's just cliched talk of the Danish "the evil Schlecks backstabbed Saint Riis" cycling fan. Amirite?
I'm no Schleck fan, but it's a bit boring to keep reading about how awful his TTing is, when in fact the whole generation of new GC riders (Nibali, Kreuziger, Gesink) is equally bad. I don't think any of those guys would have done a better TT in Grenoble than Schleck, who was equal on time with guys like Westra and Malori.
theyoungest said:If that's the case, I say go back to last year's preparation... because he certainly seemed to be climbing with more ease, Contador being unable to drop him, ánd his TT was much better, putting Contador under serious pressure. Schleck on the Alpe d'Huez in 2008 was just toying with Evans, Schleck on the Alpe this year couldn't do anything.
ghostofjoy said:remember that in this years tdf, andy made the idiotic mistake of going with contador's attack on the first climb, and therefore spent a huge chunk of time in the wind, fatiguing him significantly before alpe d'huez. evans went initially, but then had his mechanical and dropped back to the peloton.
even a motivated contador was dropped by sanchez and pierre rolland at the end of that stage.
Zaschrona said:Anyway, I thought Rudiger Selig (+ Will Clarke and Sam Bewley, but I understand they may go elsewhere) will be part of the team for the next season. Will he ride only for U23 team after all?
LaFlorecita said:And what exactly do you mean with the second bolded part?