Thoughts on the XFL, and why it might succeed, at least for a couple seasons.
• First, Vince McMahon and the WWE are now flush with liquid cash, much more than last time around. He's always been wealthy, but his net worth may top $2b by the end of this year.
• The league will operate as a single-entity. That is, the league owns and manages all teams, staff, everything. This is how MLS and the UFC operate, I think the WNBA too. MLS has adapted and from what I can tell, have exceptions that XFL aren't likely to consider, but for the XFL, I think it's a good idea. The WWE is single-entity as well, and obviously very successful, though of course the matches are worked.
• The WWE has a fairly established network, and the idea of streaming future games elsewhere to buyers like Amazon, Google/YouTube, Facebook, Yahoo! etc. has a lot of potential. Last time they relied on NBC (left out of football) to broadcast the games. When ratings dropped, sponsorship did, and that single outlet dried up. This won't be as likely this time.
• The XFL is focusing on what the NFL doesn't in other ways. Vince wants the games faster, down to 2 hours if possible. He also wants nothing to do with all the legal negativity around players. Meaning, you get a DUI, you're cut form the league. He also wants players to stand for the national anthem for example.
• Vince seemed pretty open to being very aggressive and open minded with other rules. Considering the league is a single-entity this is possible, but also runs the risk of being autocratic if he, as chairman, isn't open minded enough. Pro-wrestling professionals have said when it comes to booking the WWE (matchmaking and organizing), Vince is very good at making quick decisions others stumble on, that pan out and lead to success. Can he do that in the XFL?
• He's also going to really focus on safety, while this sounds good, and him being open minded to rules, this will be tough.
• He views the XFL as a full-time job for players. Meaning they'll get a weekly paycheck, with bonuses for teams that win, but not leaving teams that don't completely dry. The idea is to get players involved in their team and the league as a whole, in their communities and such. An interesting tactic.
Last time the XFL was almost a gimmick, with cheerleades, and marketed on hard hitting play, with things like fair catches eliminated. This league will be different in that it will focus on football, with some new wrinkles.
I think if you look at the old XFL, and some recent NFL Pro-Bowl games, specifically the 2016 Pro Bowl, you may see an example of what an XFL game might be like. There were cameras on the field a lot of the time, many players and coaches were mic'd up, kickoffs were eliminated, even the goal posts were moved in. It didn't seem like a gimmick, more like an open minded test.
Here's some thoughts on what I think the XFL could do. Some of these are rules the NFL could adopt.
1. Eliminate the kick-offs. Use Greg Schiavo's idea. After a TD one team gets the ball at the 25 yard line. Or, the team that just scored can get the ball at their own 40, and have it 4th down and 15 yards to go.
2. Eliminate punts inside opposing teams territory. Almost always a fair catch, or touchback, which is, well, boring.
3. Eliminate instant replay. Or, just have someone watching a TV in a booth, and if they see something on TV before the next team snaps the ball, buzz the on-field refs.
4. Eliminate post-scoring commercial breaks.
5. Eliminate the two-minute warning, or have it only in the 2nd half.
6. Cut time-outs to 2, or make 2 of 3 just 40 second time outs, or 3 per game total.
7. Make every player who suffers a concussion sit at least 1 game.
8. Make pass interference a 15 yard penalty and automatic first down, like college.
9. Have the clock start as soon as the ball is set on every play, except with less than 4 minutes to go in the game.
10. Shorten the quarters to 12 minutes, like the NBA.
11. Eliminate halftime, or cut it way down, and don't have the players leave the field.
12. Change the catch rule to the old days. Possession with both hands, both feet down, a catch.
13. Eliminate the fumble-touchback "Derek Carr" rule, and have it just be a loss of down.
14. Make limitations on how many FGs, even kicking extra points, a team can attempt in a game.
15. Start the season on this weekend - the same weekend as the pointless ProBowl. Or, the week right after the Super Bowl.
Good Q&E with Vince on their website
http://www.xfl.com.