With the exception of Jones & Tannehill, those mentioned lasted only 4 or 5 yrs before being cut or traded with a few even performing much better than Herbert!
Your list sort of proves my point. Herbert isn't a bust. He's been average. Thus it's absurd that the Chargers gave him that outlandish contract.
That's the problem.
Wow, the Broncos really gonna go into full rebuild mode.
I honestly don't know what other choice they have. Look at it this way. They are going to be in salary cap hell for maybe 2 years paying for the Wilson disaster. Also, during the season some Bronco starters on defense got less playing time when Payton made some decisions, I think Simmons is being tossed away with that.
Not sure Sean Payton will get them to a contender position during his tenure, but we’ll see.
He needs a star QB, and there are holes on both sides of the ball. Not only is he going to have to draft super great, but he is going to have to make magic in 2025 and 2026 free agency, just to get them to make the playoffs. That's what I see anyway.
Bills and Chargers are doing the same. They have cap issues. Joey Bosa and Mack are both expected to be gone.
Yes, and this makes sense to me, though in different ways.
The Bills have the same regime, but if you look at Poyer and White being cut, it's because on paper they had one of the best defenses in the league last year, but White missed most of the season, and Poyer was hurt much of it. But the Bills had more players than them hurt. Losing Milano hurt, Von Miller still hasn't really recovered from tearing his ACL how many months ago that is now, and when they lost Bernard in the Steeler game in the playoffs, there went their best tackler and any real hope to beat KC. You simply can't plan and coach such a defense when half of your best defenders can't get through a season.
With the Chargers it's a new sheriff in town. I think they got most of their money's worth on Bosa and Mack, the team just wasn't complete enough, had a poor OL, Herbert couldn't stay healthy, so there's just not much point in keeping them unless they agree to play cheap. Eckler, like Josh Jacobs, and to some degree both Barkley and Pollard, had a drop off in production from the previous season. There is no way they are going to pay him a heap of money. The Chargers are going to have Harbaugh build around Herbert, and roll the dice (or trade him while he still has all that potential, and draft JJ McCarthey!).
Considering Mack is near the twilight of his career, and he can move across the entire DL from edge, to strong side DE, to even LB and inside, I wonder if the Raiders will sign him to some sort of deal if the money can be worked out?
No insider knowledge here, but I have a hunch the Raiders are trying to do some mega deal to get either the 2nd or 3rd pick in the draft and take Jayden Daniels.