- Apr 15, 2016
- 4,246
- 676
- 17,680
Torn between 9 and 10. I think Van Aert winning after all the injuries he went through pushes me to 10 though.
I think this is very reductive for Roubaix. I don't think the worst edition was 1/10. Okay, 2024 may have been but that's it. Between 2016-2026, I wouldn't rate any of them lower than 5 with the exception of 2024 and maybe 2018. On the other hand, I wouldn't rate the best Tour of 2016-2025 a 10/10. (okay, 2022 was great but still)2016 , 2021 and 2022 were better
so 7 / 10
That's basically been eveyr Roubaix the last few years. Very aggressive and high octane middle section and prefinale, and then a comparatively tame finaleThe race didn‘t play out in an amazing way, after 50k to go it was just nothing going on, but the suspense and Wout winning is just the best outcome for me so 10/10. A bit CyclistAbi this reasoning but w/e.
Van der Poel group keeping close until like post Carrefour de l'Arbre was plenty of suspense. Plus Pogacar vs Van Aert aspect obviously.The race didn‘t play out in an amazing way, after 50k to go it was just nothing going on, but the suspense and Wout winning is just the best outcome for me so 10/10. A bit CyclistAbi this reasoning but w/e.
i think a good edition of a race is most naturally compared against other editions of the race . i have much higher expectations for roubaix than i have for liegeI think this is very reductive for Roubaix. I don't think the worst edition was 1/10. Okay, 2024 may have been but that's it. Between 2016-2026, I wouldn't rate any of them lower than 5 with the exception of 2024 and maybe 2018. On the other hand, I wouldn't rate the best Tour of 2016-2025 a 10/10. (okay, 2022 was great but still)
Well thats fair enough. And yes, I can't remember the last great Liege edition, which is a shame. Maybe Seixas can improve it from dismal to decent.i think a good edition of a race is most naturally compared against other editions of the race . i have much higher expectations for roubaix than i have for liege
In Liege all the numbers of 3 to 8 are different versions of "solo win from Redoute"i think a good edition of a race is most naturally compared against other editions of the race . i have much higher expectations for roubaix than i have for liege
May have probably gone for 9 but that's it. (Assuming he wins in sprint vs WvA). If he wins by dropping everyone then obviously rating would have changed based on how race changed.I rate it an 8.
Had a lot of drama, but some bad-timed mechanicals prevented us from a battle for the ages. I know this is Roubaix, but still having a great race mostly because of mechanicals is a bit pity for me.
Just out of curiosity, had Pogacar won would they impact the race rating? I think it shouldn't as the race is what happens for X kilometres and not who wins it, but.
