Trudgin said:
Eh? Surely Pinotti (and any professional rider / DS) have more right than most of us to comment on what they suspect another team may or may not be doing..
Even if you suspect them of not being entirly honest about their own choices previously...
I'm grateful the pro's want to make any comments
I don't know about Pinotti's past, but certainly his present is one of the more encouraging ones in the péloton.
Ferminal said:
My problem is not that (I have hope that Pinotti is clean), but what he hasn't said about Santambrogio/Ballan/Rihs/Ochowicz/Lelangue/Aldag/Holm/Zabel etc etc.
And there is far more against those names than there is against Sky.
How much did David Moncoutié say about Gaumont, or Millar, or Vandenbroucke, or Rutkiewicz, or the others he rode with? Sure, there's plenty of suspicious names that Pinotti has been around (and I have my concerns about High Road bearing in mind the number of riders who've suffered massive drops in level for a period of time after leaving them). But just because somebody doesn't talk about the guys around them doesn't mean they can't be clean or suspect somebody else, it just makes their account a bit limited.
del1962 said:
But after this Pinotti is quite happy to set up photo opputunities with Lance and seems to like him in 2009 and even though he know in 2011 that Lance is a doper, his attitude to Lance is a lot softer than his attitude towards De Luca from my reading of the article.
Maybe Pinotti felt that cycling had changed in that time and bearing in mind at that point Lance was still paying lip service to it all being about cancer awareness, Pinotti was naïve enough to take him on his word?
maltiv said:
Kiri did similar things at Movistar, though. His stage win in the 2011 Giro was insane, he was in a breakaway all day yet he rode up the last two mountains faster than the peloton. That was certainly better than anything he's done on Sky yet.
If Kiri is doping, then he's always been doping and Sky's doping doesn't seem to be particularly better than what he used to take...
Kiryienka's always been this kind of engine. Him doing this is not all that surprising. At Tinkoff he'd be blasting day long breaks, and Arroyo has him to thank for his Vuelta stage since Kiryienka carried him all the way to the line solo (Arroyo was monitoring the break for Valverde behind). Movistar basically signed him on that performance, and set him to work as Valverde's minder. When let off the leash in 2011 he won the Route du Sud, a País Vasco stage, was on the podium of the Critérium International and won that epic Giro stage where he rode with his sunglasses on at the end despite the grim weather because he didn't want people to see him crying. Putting him into péloton pulling duty is not a surprise because Sky have a strong hierarchy and this is what he's really good at.
thehog said:
Track rider turned beast! No wonder he's strong. Probably win Tour one day.
He rode for Tinkoff and Casse so most certainly clean
Two Giro wins in 7 years as a Pro.
Surprised no one saw this talent before.
They did. Don't misrepresent his palmarès. For one thing it's much better than you acknowledge:
2007:
7th, Tirreno-Adriatico
1 stage, Elektrotoer
8th, Österreich Rundfahrt
1 stage, Vuelta a Burgos
2008:
7th, Vuelta a Murcía
1 stage and 2 2nds, Giro d'Italia
2nd, Ster Elektrotoer
2nd in a stage, Vuelta a España
2009:
16th in the Vuelta as 3rd domestique (Rodríguez and Moreno were ahead of him in the food chain)
2010:
2nd in a stage, Tour de France
2011:
2nd, Critérium International
10th & a stage, Vuelta al País Vasco
1 mountain stage, Giro d'Italia
1st, Route du Sud
2012:
6th, Critérium du Dauphiné
3rd, World Championships ITT
You know he has a much stronger palmarès than you were giving him credit for. Besides, palmarès isn't everything. Sylwester Szmyd has one stage win (in the Dauphiné) in a 12-year career, but most people are happy to acknowledge that until recently he was possibly the best mountain domestique in the péloton. Winning races wasn't his job, and in the races where he could win he was domestiquing, and the races where he got his freedom he wasn't rounded enough to compete for the win.
If Sylwester Szmyd got on the front on a mountain stage in the Tour and started shredding the field for Valverde or Quintana, would you go ballistic about him coming from nowhere? If not, then don't about Kiryienka either.