auscyclefan94 said:i personally think the collarbone helped him with his form. carbon crank, lance was not the third best rider, he would of finished about 5th by my estimates without the ttt. This years tour's ttt was far too descisive.
Oldman said:Sorry I missed so much. The answer is a qualified yes. It was the biggest race I could get into as an amateur and your boy was in it. I finished ahead of him. I was more than double his age and older than he is now. Does that qualify me as an authority-NO. I was asking what expertise suggests that no rider could win the Tour after sustaining a broken collarbone in the same season.
By the way...I was never questioning the sizable task that LA took on returning to the GTs. I was questioning the constant deification that generates from his publicity machine...I think that's what people were originally questioning. Seriously-I wasn't looking to start a shiiteystorm over this; just voicing my frustration over the level of self promotion and lack of respect for his competitors.
auscyclefan94 said:i personally think the collarbone helped him
Carboncrank said:I don't have anybody on ingore but I do have a "stupid" list.
You are on it.
Race radio, Señor_Contador and Publicus are on a "stupid infantile" list.
Carboncrank said:I don't have anybody on ingore but I do have a "stupid" list.
You are on it.
Race radio, Señor_Contador and Publicus are on a "stupid infantile" list.
Ripper said:Hmm, the calming breaths are not working. Perhaps a soothing warm soak in some bath salts and lavender oils?
When all else fails, massage can work wonders![]()
Carboncrank said:I've learned that Coppi won the tour 54 years ago after a collarbone injury, but I don't know when it happened.
I learned that Merckx won it 39 years ago, 8 or 9 months after being injured. He also wons some spring races, which he wouldn't have even been in if he'd been injured March 23rd. Would he have won the Giro too that year? I don't think so but that's debatable.
It's cool that you got to race at that level. I'd love to hear more. I never got to that level.
I believe that in order to win the tour most years you have to make it the focus of your year and if anything goes wrong with that, way more often than not you won't win. That's all I have been saying. History certainly proves it true. There are many stories of tour contenders that had illness or injury ruin the focus of their training in such a way that they failed. Many many more cases of that than cases of guys who had a metal plate and a dozen screws inserted at the end of March and went on to win the tour.
As far as self promotion goes I see the press coming to him way more than I see him going to the press. He seems to me to be reasonable, and cogent in every interview and more frank in his opinions than he really needs to be. I think that's a good thing.
I'd like to know why you think he doesn't respect his competitors. I see pictures and video all the time of him in engaging conversations with the riders before races. I've speed search through most of the pre race stuff for the tour down under and saw him talking amiable with Evans, Hincape, Valverde and others. Nobody shuns him. Nobody walks or turns away.
Of course, I assume you're talking about things outside the races themselves as my view is that once the race starts all bets are off (outside team of course).
Race Radio said:Better watch out, he might put you on one of his lists.
Carbon Crank...El Imbatido said:Or take a hard left-hander into the Jackhammer territory.
Carboncrank said:I don't have anybody on ingore but I do have a "stupid" list.
You are on it.
Race radio, Señor_Contador and Publicus are on a "stupid infantile" list.
Dr. Maserati said:Carbon Crank...
DING DING... we have a winner....
Guess who's back..... back again.... tell a friend
Jacks back...
Big GMaC said:may have been posted before, but I don't want to wade through the mess of chewed up carboncranks, interview after TdU
Tomalaris said "Lance you had never tasted defeat in the Tour before 2009..."
hmmm.... is that the best that Australia can do for journalism?
53 x 11 said:Same guy called Lancer's 3rd place at tdf a "victory for clean cycling"
and has wrote this **** http://www.sbs.com.au/cyclingcentral/blog-article/115657/One-for-the-ages-br
Big GMaC said:may have been posted before, but I don't want to wade through the mess of chewed up carboncranks, interview after TdU
Tomalaris said "Lance you had never tasted defeat in the Tour before 2009..."
hmmm.... is that the best that Australia can do for journalism?
Alpe d'Huez said:Need to hear from some people:
Do you want this thread to be a "Sticky"?
Do you want me to merge all the other LA threads into this one?
I think both may be a good idea, but want to hear what others say before just implementing it.
El Imbatido said:Have you ever seen any of SBS's coverage of cycling. Well that 'some guy' is Mike Tomalaris and he does all the intro and outro stuff & yes he is a fanboy to the max. He is like Phil & Paul when it comes to doping "Only a few bad apples do it OR he only tried it and it didn't work OR he made a mistake and he won't do that again" type of person. I made a reference the other day to Phil and Paul being Dumb & Dumber. Well Tomalaris is in a completely different catagory. He is "Dumber than Dumb and twice as dumb as Dumber" if that makes any sense.
Carboncrank said:I mean no disrepect to the racers you mention but what you've done here is so disingenous that I have to call it as I see it.
I like Wikipedia as much as the next guy but you can't just copy paste and unsourced section of a page and expect me to roll over for you. It's halarious that you added "cracked" to "head and knee" from 1954 and if there's any truth to it, it mainly proves the guy was a crashfest.
If in fact it's true he won in '52 after a collarbone, I'll stand corrected but the rest of what you posted about him is irrelevant, like the fact he was a prisioner in WWII. The same Wiki page tells of a well treated prisoner. I'll refrain from mentioning other things about him. He was certainly no pure untainted sportsman who won only through heroic courage over injury.
Eddy Merckx was injured near the end of 1969, after winning 37% of his races, not before.
So congratulations. You found one rider who had some kind of collarbone injury, maybe, who knows when, and won the tour.
I'll stand by my theory that a shattered collarbone with a 5 inch metal plate with 12 screws and a matching incision on March 23rd will impact your fitness on July 4th. It was not the main reason he lost. The main reason he lost was Alberto Contador. But it did have an impact and knowing that is but one of a zillion reasons it would be stupid for Johann to do anything to hurt Alberto's chances. The main result of any such attempt would too likely end with a non Astana rider winning.
I mean Johan is good, but give me a break. No DS would be good enough to manipulate that outcome unless there was some reason to be sure Lance was strong enough pull it off. Lance would have been a longshot even if Alberto hadn't been there.
But he made a good showing, and that drives you guys nuts. Not winning was not enough.
Carboncrank said:Since you evidently have a reading problem I'll repost what I wrote, but his time larger to make it easier for you.
"The main reason he lost was Alberto Contador. But it did have an impact and knowing that is but one of a zillion reasons it would be stupid for Johann to do anything to hurt Alberto's chances. The main result of any such attempt would too likely end with a non Astana rider winning.
I mean Johan is good, but give me a break. No DS would be good enough to manipulate that outcome unless there was some reason to be sure Lance was strong enough pull it off. Lance would have been a longshot even if Alberto hadn't been there.
But he made a good showing, and that drives you guys nuts. Not winning was not enough.
Publicus said:Just reading the new article on the front page and I wonder if one of the moderators can perhaps ask Team RadioShack/ Lance Armstrong to step on a scale. As I noted earlier in this thread, Armstrong looks almost exactly the same as he did at the TdF. I know weight is self-reported, but we should see visible evidence that he lost 8.8 pounds
Big GMaC said:Tomalaris said "Lance you had never tasted defeat in the Tour before 2009..."
hmmm.... is that the best that Australia can do for journalism?