I'm not as old as you are but I've been watching cycling for 40 years to give you a frame of reference. I don't think anyone here is suggesting that he has no weaknesses. We are simply saying that he has been doing things in his first two years that weren't even being done by the all time greats in the sports of cycling.
We simply disagree on his ceiling. I think his style is made for GTs because he loses less and recovers better than everyone else. So while people are questioning if he's able to do a 3 three week tour I think a 2 week tour will actually make him more difficult to beat. Sure, he'll have a higher chance of a crash and not finishing, but I have a hard time seeing anyone beat him if he's at or near top form in a GT.
Without being disrespectful to other riders, I believe that absent his crash he would have won Lombardia, Tirreno-Adriatico, GIro, World TT championships, and the Belgian TT championships, and would have have been a top contender for the WC RR and Belgian RR.
Things have changed in the cycling landscape as well as the pro sports landscape. Young players across all sports have had dynamic impacts at extremely young ages.
I understand the reluctance to believe that you might be watching someone who may end up as one of the greatest of all time, but when you see a 19 year old win Classica San Sebastian finish 2nd at WC ITT, win EU TT and then come back at 20 so much stronger and win every race he finished.
The only better TT'er at Remco's age was Anquetil.
I totally agree that, as you quote : "he would have won Lombardia, Tirreno-Adriatico, GIro, World TT championships, and the Belgian TT championships, and would have have been a top contender for the WC RR and Belgian RR." That was my own prediction, giving his talent and his form since august.
But I disagree that, because he shows that talent at 19, and this season, at 20, he automatically will destroy the opponents the coming decade.
I know, it's a bad habit to scott at people who are old(er) and have a lot of experience. But believe me, I've seen dozends of talents and one or two toptalents who didn't make it. While "experts", biased supporters and journalists did scribe them into heaven.
Not only talent counts. There is (mal)fortune, there are injurys, there is a private life, there are setbacks, there are (younger and better) opponents. In Evenepoels case there is a serious risk of no longer making progress by the age of 23, 24. He"ll still be a terrific rider, but maybe not at the level which he had counted on. And then it starts to haunt the head. Then, he"ll has to be mentally very strong to transcend that.
So, not for the first time. I predict that he will win grand tours, hill classics, a WC, maybe olympic gold. But I doubt he will prevail