He didn't have ''a bad day'' in the Giro, he's just *** at gravel and after two weeks he faded due to his hampered winter preparation and lack of base. Even his level in the first 2 weeks in the Giro was not what it could have been, which to me was evident by his TT for one. Did you forget his crash in 2020. Giro was his first race after his recovery in nearly 9 months after a suboptimal winter. They say getting back to top form after such an injury takes longer than the actual recovery. It had its impact on the entirety of 2021.
He was said to be overtrained for the Olympics (trying to compensate for his lack of base) yet still put minutes into Almeida, Foss and McNulty, to name a few, who are all TT/GC riders, in the TT.
Valencia was not a bad day imho, as he didn't feel bad throughout the day/stage like he did saturday. I think that was the type of climb and his (lack of) specific preparation. He lost 40 seconds in the final 1.5k, not 4 minutes on 10k.
You could point to legitimate ''bad days'' for guys like Almeida (Giro stage 4, Lombardia...) or McNulty or Foss as well. McNulty had more off-days last year than Evenepoel had race-days but look at him this year. Evenepoel on his bad days still seems to limit his losses quite a bit better though. Finishes strong quite regularly (Giro stage 11 if you want to count it as a bad day, Lombardia, saturday...). What about Kelderman, Uran, Lopez, Hart... who all finished minutes behind him? Should they forget about ''becoming'' a GC rider?
I'll repeat, his Zoncolan effort was a lot better under more pressure and worse conditions than his effort yesterday.
It's a bit sad, if you really are a fan, to see you jumping to conclusions based on guesswork and unfair expectations. Not every bad performance has the same explanation. But if you want to give up on a (barely) 22 year old as a GC rider, knock yourself out.
wow. okay, listen i am aware internet forums are perhaps not the place to admit that one may have been wrong (i am talking about myself) or to show any subtlety or put things in context, but i am trying all the same. and i am sorry that seems to upset people who thought i may have been "on their side" more than anything.
however, i hope even you realize how many different excuses you are developing for his now many "underachievements" (btw, he is only underachieving because "fans" like you keep asserting that he must be a GT rider).
btw, i have been one to defend his crumble in the giro for the precise reasons you have presented. however, now we have several other occasions where he has crumbled and not shown the best recovery.
and i believe you know perfectly well that i was talking about the Olympic road race and not the ITT (in which he also somewhat underperformed, tbh)...
also, lombardia, was when i first expressed my doubts. he had been in absolute stellar form until then. however, when it came to following the best up a longer, steeper climb he was dropped surprisingly early -- very similar to TA -- and then fought back -- again similar to TA. So this is now much more the norm with him than the opposite.
"It's a bit sad, if you really are a fan, to see you jumping to conclusions based on guesswork and unfair expectations."
I find this comment particularly odd. I am not sure that my definition of "fandom" is to require that a rider be a GT rider no matter the evidence. Ala, VDP and WvA are amazing riders who will likely never win any GT. I am a huge fan of all three because I enjoy the way they ride -- they are exciting. I also think Remco is amazingly exciting -- not so much, however, when he is dropped by 30 riders. Given the right worlds course (maybe even last year's one) he could be a glorious world champion. again, not sure why he has put on weight to compete for FW and LBL. that makes very little sense to me.
And who is the cause of the "unfair expectations", a fan like me who says that maybe he shouldn't be expected to be a GT rider but could excel and do exploits in other races or a fan like you who keeps saying that he must be a GT rider no matter the evidence...