I think he is very close to Aru when it comes to the climbing skills, and he will show it in France. Probably going to lose a lot on descents though
The Cycling News forum is looking to add some volunteer moderators with Red Rick's recent retirement. If you're interested in helping keep our discussions on track, send a direct message to
In the meanwhile, please use the Report option if you see a post that doesn't fit within the forum rules.
Thanks!
I disagree. His climbing weakness is greatly exagerated. He didn't lose time on the last descent at the GDL. And that's down the Croix de Fer that he took the precious 2 minutes that made his Alpe d'Huez win possible. When his head is in the right spot, he can descend as well as most. In the descent of the Col d'Allos when he fell, I think he lost focus, went ahead of himself in a scenario that looked like a repeat of his '12 win in Porrentruy. Daydreaming in a descent like that will cost ya...damian13ster said:I think he is very close to Aru when it comes to the climbing skills, and he will show it in France. Probably going to lose a lot on descents though
SeriousSam said:Pinot is in some third tier below Aru/Valverde/Purito though.
Alexandre B. said:SeriousSam said:Pinot is in some third tier below Aru/Valverde/Purito though.
Below Purito ? Have we seen the same season ?
True. He already committed to the '16 Tour in his interview/reaction to the course. BTW he's every bit as good as Aru, better than the aging Purito. The difference is the team. I hope FDJ doesn't send Geniez to Italy, Elissonde to Spain, and just load up for the Tour. Don't sprinkle what little talent you have. In '15 he was alone. Morabito may have been a great captain under other "programs", but with FDJ he's not much of a help. I still think Thibaut should force FDJ's hand and go for the Giro.Rollthedice said:As far as descending goes he is on Froome, Quintana level, no problems here if he's able to focus. He can certainly climb at Aru level, on longer climbs if he's in shape he is better than Valverde and Purito. Problem is he needs to be consistent throughout 3 weeks and he needs a stronger team. I think with the team Aru had in Giro and Vuelta he could've had similar results. Let Tour is different though, sadly he is probably more or less forced to ride it and he will probably never win.
Are you out of your mind SeriousSam? He beat Piti at the '14 TdF fair and square. Aru? We'll see. Purito? I think so.SeriousSam said:Pinot is in some third tier below Aru/Valverde/Purito though.
Mr.White said:Alexandre B. said:SeriousSam said:Pinot is in some third tier below Aru/Valverde/Purito though.
Below Purito ? Have we seen the same season ?
Well what's your point? Purito had a great season, arguably better than Pinot...
Alexandre B. said:Mr.White said:Alexandre B. said:SeriousSam said:Pinot is in some third tier below Aru/Valverde/Purito though.
Below Purito ? Have we seen the same season ?
Well what's your point? Purito had a great season, arguably better than Pinot...
I think he was talking about climbing/GT ability.
Are you out of your mind? Pinot 2014 would never been able to match Valverde 2015 in a Tour with a way stronger peloton. There was clearly something wrong with Valverde in that Tour. He got outkicked by Ten Dam and Zubeldia in some stages ffs. I'd rank Valverde above everyone but the big 4 including Aru. Maybe higher than Nibali too.Tonton said:Are you out of your mind SeriousSam? He beat Piti at the '14 TdF fair and square. Aru? We'll see. Purito? I think so.SeriousSam said:Pinot is in some third tier below Aru/Valverde/Purito though.
Mr.White said:Alexandre B. said:Mr.White said:Alexandre B. said:SeriousSam said:Pinot is in some third tier below Aru/Valverde/Purito though.
Below Purito ? Have we seen the same season ?
Well what's your point? Purito had a great season, arguably better than Pinot...
I think he was talking about climbing/GT ability.
So? And what's Purito, a roleur? a sprinter? He came 2nd in Vuelta with a stage win, plus 2 stages from the Tour. Did Pinot topped that?
Purito was a lot better than Pinot this year in terms of GC. When you are able to be the fastest rider on two of the hardest mountain stages and in top 3 on the rest, you are a top 5 GC rider. And he won a one-week race.Alexandre B. said:SeriousSam said:Pinot is in some third tier below Aru/Valverde/Purito though.
Below Purito ? Have we seen the same season ?
Tonton said:Are you out of your mind SeriousSam? He beat Piti at the '14 TdF fair and square. Aru? We'll see. Purito? I think so.SeriousSam said:Pinot is in some third tier below Aru/Valverde/Purito though.
Faded badly, so what? It's the race. You can't dismiss '14, turn around and talk about '15 when Pinot also had his share of misfortune. It's the race. And we may look back in a few years and see his '15 TdF as a blessing. Until then, things came a little bit too easy IMO. He showed great mental strength by not DNF, he hung in there when the French public was hammering him on social media. He overcame disillusions in Mende, then after his crash in the CdA descent, and finally got a well deserved win in AdH. He grew. So I hope he proves you wrong indeed: he's far from having reached his ceiling. My big worry is that he doesn't have a strong team.bala v said:Tonton said:Are you out of your mind SeriousSam? He beat Piti at the '14 TdF fair and square. Aru? We'll see. Purito? I think so.SeriousSam said:Pinot is in some third tier below Aru/Valverde/Purito though.
Piti faded badly at the end of the Tour '14. But he beat Pinot quite comfortably at the Tour '15, fair and square as you say. I don't think Pinot could beat top form Valverde, in any race, not just GT
Edit: And yes, I agree with SeriousSam, Pinot is below Valverde/Aru/Purito. He's in the same league with Uran, Landa and Majka. Of course he might prove I'm wrong next few seasons, but until then...
Tonton said:Are you out of your mind SeriousSam? He beat Piti at the '14 TdF fair and square. Aru? We'll see. Purito? I think so.SeriousSam said:Pinot is in some third tier below Aru/Valverde/Purito though.
It's not me making this argument: it's you guys. In '15 there were a bunch of guys ahead of Pinot in the final GC that are not as good as he is. My point is: don't use '15 if you dismiss '14. Take both or leave both. That being said, Valverde was in a great position to podium in '14. He was fading week 3, but it was the final ITT that did him.Velolover2 said:But Tonton, it was a Valverde who was struggling against Ten Dam, König and Zubeldia. It's not a great reference point.
Then I could use Nibali's record in one-week races and weak/tired competition in GC to prove that he is not a top 10 climber.
Tonton said:Check him out on Strava, not messing around, and with a multi-national following. BTW, there's no data missing with Thibaut Pinot, it's all in the open. Go Thibaut!
Jspear said:Tonton said:Check him out on Strava, not messing around, and with a multi-national following. BTW, there's no data missing with Thibaut Pinot, it's all in the open. Go Thibaut!
I'm glad I don't live where he does...I'd never (and prob most other people) hold the lead in any Strava segments he has done.