The Cycling News forum is looking to add some volunteer moderators with Red Rick's recent retirement. If you're interested in helping keep our discussions on track, send a direct message to
In the meanwhile, please use the Report option if you see a post that doesn't fit within the forum rules.
Thanks!
Pinot is almost always prominent until he decides some calamity or another should befall him. Porte is usually just kind of there until he isn't, and when he does crash out it's often before a reasonable guide to his form can be seen.
Many races have been better for Pinot being in them. I can't possibly comprehend that anybody other than a myopic Aussie has ever looked at a GC battle at any Grand Tour and thought "you know what, that race would have been better with Richie Porte in it". He just retreats into his shell in three week races when he's the leader, much like Valverde. He's a much more active, much more proactive, much more dynamic racer in short stage races, but in the GTs he completely forgets that side of him exists. Either that or he's so paralysed by fear of losing time that he's too scared to try to gain it.
He would need a DS committee of Jacky Durand, Aleksandr Vinokourov and the ghost of Frank Vandenbroucke to wring anything interesting from him in a Grand Tour. He's been touted as a GT rider for a decade now, yet his record is no better than Ronan Pensec or Walter Riccomi's. He's a great one week rider, and he's now 35. At what point is he going to stop banging his head against the three week wall?
Remember white jersey battles outside the top 10.Top 15 in the youth competition:
1: Hirschi
2: Higuita
3: Pogacar
4: Bernal
5: Mas
6: Madouas
7: Martínez
8: Tejada
9: Eg
10: Kämna
11: Powless
12: C Swift
13: Asgreen
14: Cosnefroy
15: Gaudu
I think there have been Tours where the white jersey has been a bit easier to win...
Maybe the clearest sign yet of an imminent changing of the guard in cycling.Top 15 in the youth competition:
1: Hirschi
2: Higuita
3: Pogacar
4: Bernal
5: Mas
6: Madouas
7: Martínez
8: Tejada
9: Eg
10: Kämna
11: Powless
12: C Swift
13: Asgreen
14: Cosnefroy
15: Gaudu
...
25: Sivakov
I think there have been Tours where the white jersey has been a bit easier to win...
Aru will become a ski jumper. You hear it here first. I based this on his career trajectory resembling a ski jumping slope rather perfectly.Leave Richie alone, Brailsford's Plan B from way long ago when Froome was ruling the planet unless he crashed. I find it more interesting to see what will Aru do next. Work for Pogacar? Quit the Tour and go to the Giro? Quit the Giro and go home?
Pinot has withdrawn from two races on the final few stages while in a better GC spot than Porte has ever managed (and in last year's Tour had been a genuine contender for victory), has 5 GT top 10s to Porte's 2, and those include all 3 Grand Tours, has 1 Grand Tour podium to Porte's 0, has 6 Grand Tour stage wins - all mountain stages - to Porte's 0, and is five and a half years younger than Porte.But all listed here, it adds exactly to Pinot. And he's too banging his head to that same wall. And he hasn't even changed team for once, maybe nobody's interested of his services.
edit: yup, gonna leave porte/pinot now..
Pinot is almost always prominent until he decides some calamity or another should befall him. Porte is usually just kind of there until he isn't, and when he does crash out it's often before a reasonable guide to his form can be seen.
Many races have been better for Pinot being in them. I can't possibly comprehend that anybody other than a myopic Aussie has ever looked at a GC battle at any Grand Tour and thought "you know what, that race would have been better with Richie Porte in it". He just retreats into his shell in three week races when he's the leader, much like Valverde. He's a much more active, much more proactive, much more dynamic racer in short stage races, but in the GTs he completely forgets that side of him exists. Either that or he's so paralysed by fear of losing time that he's too scared to try to gain it.
He would need a DS committee of Jacky Durand, Aleksandr Vinokourov and the ghost of Frank Vandenbroucke to wring anything interesting from him in a Grand Tour. He's been touted as a GT rider for a decade now, yet his record is no better than Ronan Pensec or Walter Riccomi's. He's a great one week rider, and he's now 35. At what point is he going to stop banging his head against the three week wall?
Those damn Anglo-Saxons.Why does Porte even still get talked about as a GC contender ?
Why does Porte even still get talked about as a GC contender ?
But all listed here, it adds exactly to Pinot. And he's too banging his head to that same wall. And he hasn't even changed team for once, maybe nobody's interested of his services.
That is true. I had no idea that Betiol was there until I saw the stage results. very poor result from Betiol at the end if you ask me.EF not dropping back Bettiol to help Martinez is a strange tactic...They must have felt confident he could win the stage...?
Their PR for sure will say that. But for no reason would leave Roglic & Dumo alone with that team. But we'll see in week 3 of the Tour.People seem concerned (if that's the correct word) about Jumbo when Ineos went to the front. Their two GC men in Dumo and Rogo finished in the main bunch. Am I daft thinking their doms were maybe just saving their beans?
This isn't like any other year and maybe caution in the first grandy isn't a bad idea?
I shall say though, I only watched the last 25km
When has Aru ever worked for another rider in a gt? He's toast, the operation didn't really solve his problems, it looks like his engine is fried and his recovery pretty much gone.Leave Richie alone, Brailsford's Plan B from way long ago when Froome was ruling the planet unless he crashed. I find it more interesting to see what will Aru do next. Work for Pogacar? Quit the Tour and go to the Giro? Quit the Giro and go home?
They convinced him he's now being superdomestique again, to Bauke Mollema.He was spotted today finishing with the GC contender's group.
I was thinking that too. Is it just English speaking media that still include him as a contender?Those damn Anglo-Saxons.
That domestique point is actually really good. One day we'll look back at his career (or not tbf) and when the question arises, what was Richie Porte's greatest ever gt moment the answer will probably be something like, "remember that time when he led out his teammate?"Pinot has withdrawn from two races on the final few stages while in a better GC spot than Porte has ever managed (and in last year's Tour had been a genuine contender for victory), has 5 GT top 10s to Porte's 2, and those include all 3 Grand Tours, has 1 Grand Tour podium to Porte's 0, has 6 Grand Tour stage wins - all mountain stages - to Porte's 0, and is five and a half years younger than Porte.
Really, as Grand Tour racers, Porte isn't even remotely in the same league as Pinot. Sure, Pinot doesn't have the palmarès across one week that Porte does, but as a Grand Tour contender he is several leagues below Thibaut and has been since at least 2013. Porte's best GT performances have come on individual stages when he has been a domestique.
Richie Porte has competed as a GT leader for two of the richest teams in the péloton, with a crack squad of high level riders assembled on a budget far in excess of that which FDJ can muster to support Pinot, and has come away with fewer results. Significantly fewer results.
I think GVA and Bettiol are better than Impey on very long climbs. If this stage had a succession of shorter climbs, Impey might have been there but on days like today, which started with two huge climbs, I'm not surprised that GVA and Bettiol did better.Pretty surprised to see Daryl Impey so far back today. GVA was there, Bettiol too, probably Van Aert if he didn't have to push-start Dumoulin. Normally you'd expect Impey to survive too then.
That domestique point is actually really good. One day we'll look back at his career (or not tbf) and when the question arises, what was Richie Porte's greatest ever gt moment the answer will probably be something like, "remember that time when he led out his teammate?"