I understand your approach. But I think you're forgetting an important point: if only the best rider counts, then it becomes increasingly important to have a few star riders. If you have a Pogi, you score tons of points in every race. If you don't have that, it becomes much more difficult. So I'm not a fan of your suggestion, because cycling is a team sport.
But I completely understand that you want the teams to race for victories and not for places.
Pogi and his team are going to rack up points no matter what. And honestly, that makes total sense. In what sport
doesn't the best athlete come out on top in the standings?
I actually think this change could help level the playing field a bit. Right now, a lot of teams don’t have big-name stars and end up getting crushed by teams that have 1) superstar riders, 2)
multiple of them, or 3) even three leaders all aiming for top 5-10s in most races. If UAE's results behind Pogi don’t count, suddenly there’s more room for other teams to compete with UAE across the season. Also, wouldn't it make a lot more sense if the biggest results in the biggest races determined who had the best season according to the uci ranking rather than who stacked the most riders consistently in the top 5-10 across a variety of lesser races? UAE stacking 4 guys in top 10 at every italian classics does not make them the best team imo. Winning mounuments and grand tours is what makes you the best team (which they incidentily also do of course).
Plus, I’d argue it could make the sport
more team-oriented. Take Liège–Bastogne–Liège, for example: Lidl-Trek had three riders finish 2nd, 5th, and 6th. That’s impressive, but imagine if they’d worked
together to try to win the race instead of each going for personal results. The current points system encourages riders and teams to aim for top placings for several riders rather than actually trying to
win.
The only ones who truly go all-in for the win in one-day races are guys like Pogacar, MVDP, and Remco. For them, the podium don't matter. Everyone else? They're playing it safe for two guys to top 10's.