rhubroma said:
Why any people on the planet today should be without a state is beside me. Then, when it is the US led governments of the democratic, so called developed world in the UN that are largely responsible for the continual status of such territorial limbo and legitimacy, the hypocrisy knows no shame.
but you know the background to Balfour, then the League of NAtions decision?
The League of NAtions decision was a gerrymandered vote (we are talking the original partition, 1947 or so, before the Ben Gurion's haganah started ethnically cleansing)
it was a gerrymandered vote, the S American nations were heavily "leant" on, by the Americans, and the African nations were not for it. It was only the Americans and the Europeans who had a massive guilt to pay back the jewish nation on behalf of the european ashkenazism jews (and sepphardim) for the shoah. But before the holocaust, there was herzel and chaim weisman politically agitating for a state in the palestine mandate, that circa ~5% were jewish citizens then.
but the devils advocate, and it is valid, and a position i find credibile, this has been the grand arc of history. people dispossessed, holocausts, ethnic cleansing, it is a macro and meta psychological study of how we as humans consider the other. It was never jews qua jews, but jewish people qua "other". We are tribal, and their must be an other for this dichotomy to hold.
Just like America needed knew enemies after Gorbachov glasnost and peristroika. They needed to find new enemies. Just like Israel exists in relation to their enemies.
And even though i have a pretty good hold on the hirtory, i do support Israel and the people, like i am sure all posting here do, but i sought of require a cognitive dissonance to support them. I dont support the gov't. But it is a pretty unique nation, that can produce so many nobel laureates and science breakthru(s) and artist creations. It is up there with American in this unique type of innovation which advances humankind. I am not talking about economic advancement or GDP. (just science/tech/art).
And once it was Mesopotamia and the greater arab tribes who lead humanity thru the dark ages with science and mathematics. Which was built upon by the European nations.
I think Niall Ferguson of Kennedy School and Ian Morris of Stanford riff upon this is recent tomes of theirs. The NYtimes bestseller type books, not academic tomes. Tho I am sure they have done both with the same research. I think both are ex-Oxford, or they may have done time at Cambridge, either way, Oxbridge euros.
which is felicitous on this theme i am channeling, about new leadership over the arc of history. when huntington and fukuyama's theses have been discredited as neo-con bibles