• The Cycling News forum is still looking to add volunteer moderators with. If you're interested in helping keep our discussions on track, send a direct message to @SHaines here on the forum, or use the Contact Us form to message the Community Team.

    In the meanwhile, please use the Report option if you see a post that doesn't fit within the forum rules.

    Thanks!

Worlds USA

Page 3 - Get up to date with the latest news, scores & standings from the Cycling News Community.
Toggle sidebar Toggle sidebar
TRDean

TRDean

Mar 18, 2009
1,844
1
0
karlboss said:
Folks reading this forum are mostly cyclists, and odds on posses a body type that doesn't lend itself to football codes. However Rugby Union players and League players would definitely last and excel if they swapped codes, physical abilities are similar.

As for a specific example...Ben Roethlisberger...I think he has a pretty ring :p
Click to expand...

The physical abilities are not similar...rugby players don't average 240-300 lbs. They are not running 4.4 40 times either. I have watch both sports and while I most definitely respect rugby...and how tough those players are...they are not in the same category as NFL players. Just imagine a stacked 290 lb man running at you full speed (4.8 40 time) with the intent to take your head off.

TFF put some great pictures up...and there are more...hell I'd add Bob Sanders...Albert Haynesworth...Shawn Merriman...each one of which wants to demolish the guy in front of him.
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
karlboss said:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VkbjtAfpNc4
note the lack of padding
Click to expand...

meh...No disrespect to Rugby Union or Aussie rules football, but I honestly don't think you understand (as TR points out above) just how big and FAST many of those guys are.

They used to not have padding in the NFL years ago. You can go check the death toll yourself from that period. I am fairly certain that the death toll in rugby is negligible. That was not the case for American football. That is why they instituted the safety equipment. I guess maybe our guys just hit harder?

Anyway, I'll take my chances with someone like Julius Peppers who is 6'7 283lbs, and can run the 40 in 4.68 seconds against ANY of those guys. Again, heads would roll, literally.
 
G

ggusta

Jul 26, 2009
1,597
7
10,495
usedtobefast said:
the truth is, american sports fans do not really follow bike racing. we have 63,000 licensed riders of all types in the usa. pretty small for a country this size. how many play the big sports? i don't know myself, but you could look it up. it is surely a much larger number of participants. just baseball/softball will dwarf cycling. the talent pool is shallow by comparison. our really good riders are world class, but how many are there? at the very top 10 women, and maybe
20 men, give or take. we do well with the good ones we have, but it is a job.
an athlete can make much more money doing anything else. i have confess,
watching a time trial on tv can be damn boring. they can be exciting sometimes,but John Q Public is just going to glaze over. unless you understand
the sport and all it's machinations, most folks just change the channel. i could go on, but enough for now.
Click to expand...

+1

That's really all there is to say about it.

Every small town can field a softball league of adults but competitive cycling isn't even a blip on the radar. (Except for He who cannot be named.) For our big names to pass on it, it probably comes down to time and money rather than some sense of national pride.
 
T

twothirds

Sep 30, 2009
306
0
0
TRDean said:
The physical abilities are not similar...rugby players don't average 240-300 lbs. They are not running 4.4 40 times either. I have watch both sports and while I most definitely respect rugby...and how tough those players are...they are not in the same category as NFL players. Just imagine a stacked 290 lb man running at you full speed (4.8 40 time) with the intent to take your head off.

TFF put some great pictures up...and there are more...hell I'd add Bob Sanders...Albert Haynesworth...Shawn Merriman...each one of which wants to demolish the guy in front of him.
Click to expand...

So the guys are capable of running for 5 seconds at a time and then taking a minutes rest. The football players wouldn't last 5 minutes in a rugby match.
 
TRDean

TRDean

Mar 18, 2009
1,844
1
0
twothirds said:
So the guys are capable of running for 5 seconds at a time and then taking a minutes rest. The football players wouldn't last 5 minutes in a rugby match.
Click to expand...

Very funny...stupid but funny.
 
Astana1

Astana1

Aug 16, 2009
401
0
0
twothirds said:
So the guys are capable of running for 5 seconds at a time and then taking a minutes rest. The football players wouldn't last 5 minutes in a rugby match.
Click to expand...

Seriously. The more you people talk the more ignorant and stupid you appear. A minute is a gross overstatement. And in football you're 100% on every play. Not the case in Rugby or AF.

If they conditioned themselves for Rugby they would be fine. But Rugby players would probably never be big enough or fast enough to reach equivalent success in football.
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
twothirds said:
So the guys are capable of running for 5 seconds at a time and then taking a minutes rest. The football players wouldn't last 5 minutes in a rugby match.
Click to expand...

Actually, Dhani Jones an NFL player practiced and even played in a match in London, and he lasted just fine. Funny thing is, he is just a mediocre LB, and not all that big.

I am not saying rugby is a sport for wimps. I actually respect the talent level and physical ability. What I find amusing is the assertion that because NFL players wear pads, they are somehow wussies. That is just stupid, no other way to put it.
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
Astana1 said:
Seriously. The more you people talk the more ignorant and stupid you appear. A minute is a gross overstatement. And in football you're 100% on every play. Not the case in Rugby or AF.

If they conditioned themselves for Rugby they would be fine. But Rugby players would probably never be big enough or fast enough to reach equivalent success in football.
Click to expand...

Exactly, if someone like Ray Lewis conditioned himself for rugby, he would destroy people there like he does here. You take someone like Meriman 4.56 40, 6'6 270, and he could literally kill people without pads. Running for 4.46 seconds isn't the point. It is the fact that speed is carrying 270 pounds of weight, and smashing into something else that makes the speed important.

Its just stupid to think NFL players couldn't play rugby. And while I am sure there are rugby and AF players who could play in the NFL if so trained. I am willing to bet the number is far less than the other way around.
 
TRDean

TRDean

Mar 18, 2009
1,844
1
0
Thoughtforfood said:
Exactly, if someone like Ray Lewis conditioned himself for rugby, he would destroy people there like he does here. You take someone like Meriman 4.56 40, 6'6 270, and he could literally kill people without pads. Running for 4.46 seconds isn't the point. It is the fact that speed is carrying 270 pounds of weight, and smashing into something else that makes the speed important.

Its just stupid to think NFL players couldn't play rugby. And while I am sure there are rugby and AF players who could play in the NFL if so trained. I am willing to bet the number is far less than the other way around.
Click to expand...

Hey TFF...the Panthers SUCK!!! Delhomme is a class 1 looser. LOL
 
TRDean

TRDean

Mar 18, 2009
1,844
1
0
Back on track here...

I think the US team did OK. I really don't care that the "big" name guys didn't compete. I think that the only thing they should have done was they should have placed a rider in the early move. Any one of them could have done it. They would have gotten the face time and still had some riders finish in the 50s. I think there is a group of younger riders coming up who will place more emphasis on the worlds and the US will be a stronger nation. We shall see.

Glad to see Tim Duggan really getting back into form.
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
TRDean said:
Hey TFF...the Panthers SUCK!!! Delhomme is a class 1 looser. LOL
Click to expand...

Next you'll tell me that water is wet...:D

The bad news is that I have season tickets.
 
auscyclefan94

auscyclefan94

Jun 16, 2009
19,654
2
0
TRDean said:
Back on track here...

I think the US team did OK. I really don't care that the "big" name guys didn't compete. I think that the only thing they should have done was they should have placed a rider in the early move. Any one of them could have done it. They would have gotten the face time and still had some riders finish in the 50s. I think there is a group of younger riders coming up who will place more emphasis on the worlds and the US will be a stronger nation. We shall see.

Glad to see Tim Duggan really getting back into form.
Click to expand...

They did have their b-team in so did relatively well.
 
C

Cloxxki

Mar 19, 2009
2,819
1
11,485
To end the dispute, USA and RestOfWorld will each draft one ball team. Two matches will be played, one AF, one Rugby. Much different strategies, unlikely people being out-run.
Should make great television as well.

In car racing, the off-season features stars-only races in alternative vehicles, suc as in Wembley and Bercy. You'll see true talent percevering. Schumacher and Loeb have a hard time finding a match, be it touring cars, go-carts or buggies.
 
T

twothirds

Sep 30, 2009
306
0
0
Astana1 said:
Seriously. The more you people talk the more ignorant and stupid you appear. A minute is a gross overstatement. And in football you're 100% on every play. Not the case in Rugby or AF.

If they conditioned themselves for Rugby they would be fine. But Rugby players would probably never be big enough or fast enough to reach equivalent success in football.
Click to expand...

I don't mean any disrespect to football players. I have two cousins that were starting a starting DE and LB for a top university team. I trained with football players when I was track racing before going back to school.

I've also played both sports at a competitive level as well, so I'm not as ignorant as you think.

Any athlete can condition themselves for another sports if it requires similar athletic attributes and skills. Cavendish started on the track and conditioned himself for the road, and Wiggins from the track as well. It just takes time.
 
U

US Patent Exploding Cyclist

Sep 9, 2009
196
0
0
Having played both sports I can say that Rugby Players have to be tougher and overall in better condition, but Football is a much more violent sport and has a much different, read "more explosive", kind of athlete.

If the comparison between the two sports is based on measurable athletic stats such as speed, strength, and agility than NFL players are superior to the majority of World Class Rugby players. I can't say that an NFL player would definitely "dominate" a Rugby match, but based on measurable athletic abilities, speed/strength/agility, it seams that that would be possible.

As for the original topic, it would've been nice to see a stronger USA team at the worlds. I'm new to cycling and would have enjoyed having an American to root for during the road race. It was nice to see Zirbel hold the lead in the TT for a while. In my opnion the National Champion should have to represent their country at the Worlds, otherwise what's the point of racing Nationals if you won't go to Worlds? People can be disappointed in the "Big Dogs" for not going, I'm more dissapointed with Zabriskie and Hincapie.
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
US Patent Exploding Cyclist said:
Having played both sports I can say that Rugby Players have to be tougher and overall in better condition, but Football is a much more violent sport and has a much different, read "more explosive", kind of athlete.

If the comparison between the two sports is based on measurable athletic stats such as speed, strength, and agility than NFL players are superior to the majority of World Class Rugby players. I can't say that an NFL player would definitely "dominate" a Rugby match, but based on measurable athletic abilities, speed/strength/agility, it seams that that would be possible.

As for the original topic, it would've been nice to see a stronger USA team at the worlds. I'm new to cycling and would have enjoyed having an American to root for during the road race. It was nice to see Zirbel hold the lead in the TT for a while. In my opnion the National Champion should have to represent their country at the Worlds, otherwise what's the point of racing Nationals if you won't go to Worlds? People can be disappointed in the "Big Dogs" for not going, I'm more dissapointed with Zabriskie and Hincapie.
Click to expand...

Yea, apparently he had more important things to do, like buy a car...
 
K

kukiniloa

Apr 21, 2009
174
0
0
Blame USA Cycling??

Probably not for fielding a weak Men's RR Team at World's....

but if you've ever raced sanctioned events, you'd know this is one messed up organization! But that's another thread!
 
Astana1

Astana1

Aug 16, 2009
401
0
0
No idea on Hincapie. But Zabriskie raced worlds like the previous four years and this year he took off because of tendinitis in his achilles. There's only like four or five interviews with him available open source to confirm that.

I think guys like Reggie Bush, Ladanian Tomlinson, or Fast Willie Parker would run circles around most Rugby players. But most linemen would need to totally recondition themselves to last a full Rugby match.
 
R

runninboy

Jun 16, 2009
860
0
0
Astana1 said:
Rugby and AFL players are tough. But they don't hit with same inertia and violence that you see in American Football. I've talked to many Rugby players about this and the human body simply cannot hit like that without padding.

Thems are the facts...
Click to expand...

Just to illustrate the above quote.
I played for a good high school football team, the same school that produced John Elway. My first year we were watching film and this linebacker, a rather large Samoan named Frank Malamalauena (230 lbs and ran a 4.5 40)shattered a wide receivers face mask & helmet with a vicious hit.
I quit the team that day and went back to track(my position had been wide reciever:(
Frank went to UCLA and broke his neck, however even with a broken neck( i think they used metal rods) he made it to the NFL.
the short bursts of power & intensity involved in American football would be lethal if not for the strength of the athletes involved.
Just the other day a running back dropped a 270 weight on his larynx, the doctor said because of his strong neck he will recover to play again but it would have been a lethal blow to the average man
 
R

runninboy

Jun 16, 2009
860
0
0
kukiniloa said:
Probably not for fielding a weak Men's RR Team at World's....

but if you've ever raced sanctioned events, you'd know this is one messed up organization! But that's another thread!
Click to expand...

agreed
Chris Horner has always been a good rider for worlds and yet the idiots always seem to pass him over for some lesser riders who end up dropping out or placing 110th. I like Jason McCartney and the other guys but in a one day race like worlds or the Olympics the one American who should be at the top of the selection is Horner.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

TRENDING THREADS

Latest posts

Share this page

COMPANY
RESOURCES
FOLLOW
Top Bottom