del1962 said:I think in Andulicia the day Chris lost time he only did so to a better GC rider than any at the Vuelta, so it is not really comparable
Taxus4a said:del1962 said:I think in Andulicia the day Chris lost time he only did so to a better GC rider than any at the Vuelta, so it is not really comparable
it is your opinion, I didnt see that this year in Tirreno, Quintana won,or la Volta, or le Tour, he just showed in il Giro that in days like today he is as good as Aru and he did a good ITT without the best riders of the world for ITT.
Today if Quintana and Contador prepare the bet for a GT, Quintana is better. The same Froome, of course,with the rest depends of some factors, but we could say yes.
Jspear said:Taxus4a said:del1962 said:I think in Andulicia the day Chris lost time he only did so to a better GC rider than any at the Vuelta, so it is not really comparable
it is your opinion, I didnt see that this year in Tirreno, Quintana won,or la Volta, or le Tour, he just showed in il Giro that in days like today he is as good as Aru and he did a good ITT without the best riders of the world for ITT.
Today if Quintana and Contador prepare the bet for a GT, Quintana is better. The same Froome, of course,with the rest depends of some factors, but we could say yes.
You seem to be stating this as fact. Can you really back this claim up?
Taxus4a said:del1962 said:I think in Andulicia the day Chris lost time he only did so to a better GC rider than any at the Vuelta, so it is not really comparable
it is your opinion, I didnt see that this year in Tirreno, Quintana won,or la Volta, or le Tour, he just showed in il Giro that in days like today he is as good as Aru and he did a good ITT without the best riders of the world for ITT.
Today if Quintana and Contador prepare the bet for a GT, Quintana is better. The same Froome, of course,with the rest depends of some factors, but we could say yes.
ray j willings said:I think Froome is Ok. It was very very hot today. He's not lost to much time. I think the main threat will come from the likes of Aru etc.
But Froome knows how to TT up a mountain and last year it got him on the podium.
It's still way to early to say Froome is out of this race but it won't be easy. I also think Quintana will be a lot more aggressive if it becomes a showdown between the 2 of them. He won't repeat the same mistakes of the tour but in no way is Froome out of this race.
Taxus4a said:ray j willings said:I think Froome is Ok. It was very very hot today. He's not lost to much time. I think the main threat will come from the likes of Aru etc.
But Froome knows how to TT up a mountain and last year it got him on the podium.
It's still way to early to say Froome is out of this race but it won't be easy. I also think Quintana will be a lot more aggressive if it becomes a showdown between the 2 of them. He won't repeat the same mistakes of the tour but in no way is Froome out of this race.
TYes, but in la Pierre it was very hot as well, very similar, and in Spain some people as perico Delgado said contador was affeted that day for the hot.
That is not an excuse for me, although with hot, anybody could be affected.
It is true that this year contenders: Valverde, Quintana, Pozzo, Chaves, Aru,... likes hot, maybe Purito dont like too much, and Landa, but anyway it was a bad day, but not for the hot. He is still well placed.
Taxus4a said:Jspear said:Taxus4a said:del1962 said:I think in Andulicia the day Chris lost time he only did so to a better GC rider than any at the Vuelta, so it is not really comparable
it is your opinion, I didnt see that this year in Tirreno, Quintana won,or la Volta, or le Tour, he just showed in il Giro that in days like today he is as good as Aru and he did a good ITT without the best riders of the world for ITT.
Today if Quintana and Contador prepare the bet for a GT, Quintana is better. The same Froome, of course,with the rest depends of some factors, but we could say yes.
You seem to be stating this as fact. Can you really back this claim up?
It is my opinion, but is what the year has showed. The last 2 Tour the france where quintana and contador has been at the ame time, Quintana was better.
And in the Giro Landa was better than him, and Quintana is better than Landa.
For Quintana thi is the first time he doubled Tour-Vuelta, so he should pay that, but I didnt talk about that.
ray j willings said:I think Froome is Ok. It was very very hot today. He's not lost to much time. I think the main threat will come from the likes of Aru etc.
But Froome knows how to TT up a mountain and last year it got him on the podium.
It's still way to early to say Froome is out of this race but it won't be easy. I also think Quintana will be a lot more aggressive if it becomes a showdown between the 2 of them. He won't repeat the same mistakes of the tour but in no way is Froome out of this race.
there's too much of generalization imo. each of froome, quintana and contador has series of great and inglorious showings both in heat and rainy weather to regard this a big factor.Red Rick said:Last year Froome got first dropped on a rainy day and didn't lose half a minute to 10 other guys. The heat favours him, and this year, instead of crashing out after 5 stages and going in the Vuelta with his shape getting better everyday, he's going having done 3 weeks of battle in the Tour and having ridden a number of crits that don't help his prepepartion.
Last year he started yoyoing from Aralar onwards, a stage in which he got 5th in the same time as Purito, Valverde and Contador
Jspear said:Taxus4a said:Jspear said:Taxus4a said:del1962 said:I think in Andulicia the day Chris lost time he only did so to a better GC rider than any at the Vuelta, so it is not really comparable
it is your opinion, I didnt see that this year in Tirreno, Quintana won,or la Volta, or le Tour, he just showed in il Giro that in days like today he is as good as Aru and he did a good ITT without the best riders of the world for ITT.
Today if Quintana and Contador prepare the bet for a GT, Quintana is better. The same Froome, of course,with the rest depends of some factors, but we could say yes.
You seem to be stating this as fact. Can you really back this claim up?
It is my opinion, but is what the year has showed. The last 2 Tour the france where quintana and contador has been at the ame time, Quintana was better.
And in the Giro Landa was better than him, and Quintana is better than Landa.
For Quintana thi is the first time he doubled Tour-Vuelta, so he should pay that, but I didnt talk about that.
You do realize how incredibly weak your points are right? In 2013 Rodriguez was also ahead of Contador. Do you think that Rodriguez is better than Contador too? In 2015 he had just raced the Giro before doing the Tour. Do you really think you can compare form like that. Do you think Aru is stronger than Froome since he is climbing better than Froome right now? Anyways...back to Froome.
Taxus4a said:Rodriguez can be better than Contador in some races, yes. He was better than Contador not just in that Tour, but in the Vuelta 2012 as well,althoug contador won, but I didnt say that.
I have to do an average, and doping an average about what we saw the last 3 years, today, if Quintana and Contador prepare a big Tour, with a normal parcours, not very favourable to anyone, IMO Quintana should be better.
But anyway, we will see next year if any of them have problems.
Jspear said:Taxus4a said:Rodriguez can be better than Contador in some races, yes. He was better than Contador not just in that Tour, but in the Vuelta 2012 as well,althoug contador won, but I didnt say that.
I have to do an average, and doping an average about what we saw the last 3 years, today, if Quintana and Contador prepare a big Tour, with a normal parcours, not very favourable to anyone, IMO Quintana should be better.
But anyway, we will see next year if any of them have problems.
Just curious: do you think Quintana is better than Froome since he climbed better than him in this years TdF?
Taxus4a said:Jspear said:Taxus4a said:Rodriguez can be better than Contador in some races, yes. He was better than Contador not just in that Tour, but in the Vuelta 2012 as well,althoug contador won, but I didnt say that.
I have to do an average, and doping an average about what we saw the last 3 years, today, if Quintana and Contador prepare a big Tour, with a normal parcours, not very favourable to anyone, IMO Quintana should be better.
But anyway, we will see next year if any of them have problems.
Just curious: do you think Quintana is better than Froome since he climbed better than him in this years TdF?
Froome is still better, that question is easier, both of them prepare the Tour a main objetive and Froome won, by a little difference, but won.
Metabolol said:I think Froome will get stronger and fight for the win but I think you have several riders who can win this.
He should be the best in the ITT but he's only a real monster in those when he's in peak shape, so we don't know how much time he could gain that way.Taxus4a said:Metabolol said:I think Froome will get stronger and fight for the win but I think you have several riders who can win this.
he just had a bad day, it is not a question ofbecome estronger, he is not going to be like he was in the Giro, but nobody will be even close, that is normal. He is the better in ITT of everybody, so this is not like in the Tour.
Mayomaniac said:He should be the best in the ITT but he's only a real monster in those when he's in peak shape, so we don't know how much time he could gain that way.Taxus4a said:Metabolol said:I think Froome will get stronger and fight for the win but I think you have several riders who can win this.
he just had a bad day, it is not a question ofbecome estronger, he is not going to be like he was in the Giro, but nobody will be even close, that is normal. He is the better in ITT of everybody, so this is not like in the Tour.