The Cycling News forum is still looking to add volunteer moderators with. If you're interested in helping keep our discussions on track, send a direct message to
In the meanwhile, please use the Report option if you see a post that doesn't fit within the forum rules.
Thanks!
Surely not both of them? It's a bit of competition between them I fear. Jakobsen being the bigger talent and (classic) pure, raw sprinting ability and Hodeg more of a 'Freire' perhaps.I expect something like Hodeg, Jakobsen, Serry, Devenyns, Capecchi and maybe De Plus,
Good start. Tomorrow will tell us if he can challenge for top-5perico said:Currently 13th overall. 42 seconds off Kwiat.
I think it is reasonable for him to ride cautiously in the early stages of the first GT he will ride for GC. If he is still feeling good later in the race, then he can attack. If there had been a stage win on the line today, perhaps that would have been different, but why risk so much to get 10-15 seconds?Gigs_98 said:He looked strong today but I'm slightly disappointed with how defensive he was. Always at the back of the group and neither pulling (understandable) nor attacking (less understandable) when the group slowed down. Anyway, he entered the top 10 and I'm hoping for more good performances in the coming weeks.
shalgo said:I think it is reasonable for him to ride cautiously in the early stages of the first GT he will ride for GC. If he is still feeling good later in the race, then he can attack. If there had been a stage win on the line today, perhaps that would have been different, but why risk so much to get 10-15 seconds?Gigs_98 said:He looked strong today but I'm slightly disappointed with how defensive he was. Always at the back of the group and neither pulling (understandable) nor attacking (less understandable) when the group slowed down. Anyway, he entered the top 10 and I'm hoping for more good performances in the coming weeks.
While being out of position at times, he jumped the gaps easily. I was happy with his performance.LaFlorecita said:At times I was willing him to move a bit further to the front of the pack, but in the end he survived just fine. The legs seem to be responding. Maybe he can try an attack on Sunday.
Oh come on, he's shown his talent plenty of times and now he has one bad day and suddenly we're going to be all pessimistic? Even if he can't finish high up on GC this Vuelta that doesn't mean anything about the rest of his career.Gigs_98 said:Ofc we shouldn't jump to conclusions too early but let's just say, I fear this Vuelta will be the confirmation that he is not the next spanish super climber in the making.
As I wrote I don't want to jump to conclusions yet, it's just that I fear he won't fulfill the expectations for this vuelta. And I disagree that that wouldn't mean anything. You are right that Mas has shown great climbing before, especially in the vuelta al pais vasco, but that was one breakaway win in a preparation race. It was mightily impressive but if that ends up being his most impressive performance of the year he showed progression from last year but not the kind of progression one would expect from a future gt winner. It's just that the climbers who were seen as future stars when they were still very young rarely have a slow progression and then suddenly turn great from one year to another. For the same reason I wrote after Soler's PN victory that I saw that race as confirmation that he will struggle to become a gt winner. Soler was good but not as good as you'd expect a future gt winner with 24 years.LaFlorecita said:Oh come on, he's shown his talent plenty of times and now he has one bad day and suddenly we're going to be all pessimistic? Even if he can't finish high up on GC this Vuelta that doesn't mean anything about the rest of his career.Gigs_98 said:Ofc we shouldn't jump to conclusions too early but let's just say, I fear this Vuelta will be the confirmation that he is not the next spanish super climber in the making.
Yes, in a way. On the bright side, there usually is little competition for GC guys in the squad. In the Vuelta, it's him and De Plus. They can both take a shot at GC, there is no "big fish" in the team for whom they have to work and sacrifice their chances. So it depends on how you look at it. He gets a lot of freedom at QS just because there is no "top dog" GC contender in the team. It also means there is little support both in the team as well as the entourage for GC contenders unfortunately.Kwibus said:QS is one of the best teams, but not for developing gc riders.
I don't see him as a future GT winner. I see him becoming a very respectable GC climbers who'll win mountain stages, some one-week stage races and might have a shot at winning a GT at some point with some luck, but will more likely be a top-10 contender.Gigs_98 said:As I wrote I don't want to jump to conclusions yet, it's just that I fear he won't fulfill the expectations for this vuelta. And I disagree that that wouldn't mean anything. You are right that Mas has shown great climbing before, especially in the vuelta al pais vasco, but that was one breakaway win in a preparation race. It was mightily impressive but if that ends up being his most impressive performance of the year he showed progression from last year but not the kind of progression one would expect from a future gt winner. It's just that the climbers who were seen as future stars when they were still very young rarely have a slow progression and then suddenly turn great from one year to another. For the same reason I wrote after Soler's PN victory that I saw that race as confirmation that he will struggle to become a gt winner. Soler was good but not as good as you'd expect a future gt winner with 24 years.LaFlorecita said:Oh come on, he's shown his talent plenty of times and now he has one bad day and suddenly we're going to be all pessimistic? Even if he can't finish high up on GC this Vuelta that doesn't mean anything about the rest of his career.Gigs_98 said:Ofc we shouldn't jump to conclusions too early but let's just say, I fear this Vuelta will be the confirmation that he is not the next spanish super climber in the making.
LaFlorecita said:I don't see him as a future GT winner. I see him becoming a very respectable GC climbers who'll win mountain stages, some one-week stage races and might have a shot at winning a GT at some point with some luck, but will more likely be a top-10 contender.Gigs_98 said:As I wrote I don't want to jump to conclusions yet, it's just that I fear he won't fulfill the expectations for this vuelta. And I disagree that that wouldn't mean anything. You are right that Mas has shown great climbing before, especially in the vuelta al pais vasco, but that was one breakaway win in a preparation race. It was mightily impressive but if that ends up being his most impressive performance of the year he showed progression from last year but not the kind of progression one would expect from a future gt winner. It's just that the climbers who were seen as future stars when they were still very young rarely have a slow progression and then suddenly turn great from one year to another. For the same reason I wrote after Soler's PN victory that I saw that race as confirmation that he will struggle to become a gt winner. Soler was good but not as good as you'd expect a future gt winner with 24 years.LaFlorecita said:Oh come on, he's shown his talent plenty of times and now he has one bad day and suddenly we're going to be all pessimistic? Even if he can't finish high up on GC this Vuelta that doesn't mean anything about the rest of his career.Gigs_98 said:Ofc we shouldn't jump to conclusions too early but let's just say, I fear this Vuelta will be the confirmation that he is not the next spanish super climber in the making.
Jesus Christ.Taxus4a said:I think he could get the level of Contador post 2011, so to win a 3 weeks race if the best riders are out of in bad shape. Of course the same as Contador, not the Tour. enric Mas has showed a impressive level so far for his age, as Contador did.
Contador was 31 in his first Tour, he didnt work for anybody, as Mas is ot working as well. I thing Mas will be top 20, wich is similar.
Anyway I think Contador was a better rider, he has difficult to get that level, but he on the way so far.
Then our opinions don't differ that much anyway. What I was trying to say is that this vuelta might very well destroy the picture of Mas being the next contador, expectations that were never very reasonable anyway but where there nontheless.LaFlorecita said:I don't see him as a future GT winner. I see him becoming a very respectable GC climbers who'll win mountain stages, some one-week stage races and might have a shot at winning a GT at some point with some luck, but will more likely be a top-10 contender.Gigs_98 said:As I wrote I don't want to jump to conclusions yet, it's just that I fear he won't fulfill the expectations for this vuelta. And I disagree that that wouldn't mean anything. You are right that Mas has shown great climbing before, especially in the vuelta al pais vasco, but that was one breakaway win in a preparation race. It was mightily impressive but if that ends up being his most impressive performance of the year he showed progression from last year but not the kind of progression one would expect from a future gt winner. It's just that the climbers who were seen as future stars when they were still very young rarely have a slow progression and then suddenly turn great from one year to another. For the same reason I wrote after Soler's PN victory that I saw that race as confirmation that he will struggle to become a gt winner. Soler was good but not as good as you'd expect a future gt winner with 24 years.LaFlorecita said:Oh come on, he's shown his talent plenty of times and now he has one bad day and suddenly we're going to be all pessimistic? Even if he can't finish high up on GC this Vuelta that doesn't mean anything about the rest of his career.Gigs_98 said:Ofc we shouldn't jump to conclusions too early but let's just say, I fear this Vuelta will be the confirmation that he is not the next spanish super climber in the making.
LaFlorecita said:Jesus Christ.Taxus4a said:I think he could get the level of Contador post 2011, so to win a 3 weeks race if the best riders are out of in bad shape. Of course the same as Contador, not the Tour. enric Mas has showed a impressive level so far for his age, as Contador did.
Contador was 31 in his first Tour, he didnt work for anybody, as Mas is ot working as well. I thing Mas will be top 20, wich is similar.
Anyway I think Contador was a better rider, he has difficult to get that level, but he on the way so far.
And I am a Nigerian princeTaxus4a said:LaFlorecita said:I don't see him as a future GT winner. I see him becoming a very respectable GC climbers who'll win mountain stages, some one-week stage races and might have a shot at winning a GT at some point with some luck, but will more likely be a top-10 contender.Gigs_98 said:As I wrote I don't want to jump to conclusions yet, it's just that I fear he won't fulfill the expectations for this vuelta. And I disagree that that wouldn't mean anything. You are right that Mas has shown great climbing before, especially in the vuelta al pais vasco, but that was one breakaway win in a preparation race. It was mightily impressive but if that ends up being his most impressive performance of the year he showed progression from last year but not the kind of progression one would expect from a future gt winner. It's just that the climbers who were seen as future stars when they were still very young rarely have a slow progression and then suddenly turn great from one year to another. For the same reason I wrote after Soler's PN victory that I saw that race as confirmation that he will struggle to become a gt winner. Soler was good but not as good as you'd expect a future gt winner with 24 years.LaFlorecita said:Oh come on, he's shown his talent plenty of times and now he has one bad day and suddenly we're going to be all pessimistic? Even if he can't finish high up on GC this Vuelta that doesn't mean anything about the rest of his career.Gigs_98 said:Ofc we shouldn't jump to conclusions too early but let's just say, I fear this Vuelta will be the confirmation that he is not the next spanish super climber in the making.
I think he could get the level of Contador post 2011, so to win a 3 weeks race if the best riders are out of in bad shape. Of course the same as Contador, not the Tour. enric Mas has showed a impressive level so far for his age, as Contador did.
Contador was 31 in his first Tour, he didnt work for anybody, as Mas is ot working as well. I thing Mas will be top 20, wich is similar.
Anyway I think Contador was a better rider, he has difficult to get that level, but he on the way so far.