The Hitch said:
If sniper is arguing that its extremely stupid. Sceptics can't even get test results or blood profiles. How are we going to get hold of a body yet alone do the tests.
He didn't 'argue it' exactly, but when DW raised it as a possiblity (which wasn't wise; the rest of his stuff bore discussion), he, along with CC, certainly rowed in behind, and started lashing out when it was rebutted.
DW didn't really follow it up, he just left it hanging in the air - i'm sure he's more interested in the genuinely interesting stuff - but Sniper and CC jumped on board with alarming, well, naivite frankly. Since CC is on my ignore list, it was mainly sniper I saw therafter.
Of course, after the event, sniper backtracked, but even here he contradicted himself - one second saying he hadn't said anything about the cremation, as opposed to the death, of Txema,
I simply agreed with Dear Wiggo that Txema's death was fishy, regardless of the cremation.
the next...
And yes, I liked Cycle Chic subsequently pointing out the rareness of cremations among catholics. I thought it was a nice argument.
you know, it occasionally bears remembering, some people in here (and I don't include intelligent sceptics like Dear Wiggo in this) don't just
THINK sky dope, or even
KNOW sky dope...they
WANT sky to have doped; they're emotionally invested in it to justify a personal dislike.