Dennis was at the 2018 Giro riding for GC until he got blown out of it on Finestre.Dennis and Van Aert are clearly top 5 TTers and had they been here and riding for GC I reckon they would be top 15 at the rest day as well.
ok, let's try differently. in GTs Nibali is generally among the best out of GC contenders in ITT.I think Kittel had a World junior TT title. I'm not sure age grade races reflect what a rider will go on to do in senior ranks.
I included Nibali there as someone who would be considered more likely to win a race in the mountains, than against the clock.
I think in all honesty TGH is in a different category to pretty much any recent GT winner. I'll just call it the "2020 Giro category" and leave it at that.ok, let's try differently. in GTs Nibali is generally among the best out of GC contenders in ITT.
And I still don't get why he would be in a different category than TGH.
I guess it's a question of definitions then. My definition at least for the 2014 Tour is that Nibali was the best in the mountains and the best in the ITT out of GC contenders, so he was the best all-rounder.I think in all honesty TGH is in a different category to pretty much any recent GT winner. I'll just call it the "2020 Giro category" and leave it at that.
I agree that Nibali is better than most GT contenders of the 2010s against the clock. My point was that of recent multiple GT winners, he and Contador are the closest to being someone you could call a "pure climber." Nibali's stage wins in the mountains in 2014 were the sort of climbing dominance you usually see from someone nicknamed after a bird, or likely to be blown away by a stiff breeze anywhere above 2000m.
I wasn’t inferring either could win the race overall just that at this point in the race I think they would be well capable of being in or very close to the Maglia Rosa after 10 stages especially Van Aert who could have picked up lots of bonus seconds with the way the sprints have panned out.Dennis was at the 2018 Giro riding for GC until he got blown out of it on Finestre.
If the current generation of TT specialists had the wherewithal to be GC riders, you'd see them riding for GC. Roche, Lemond and Fignon were mentioned earlier as riders who won GTs by being able to win mountain stages and ITTs (and after them, Rominger); the equivalent to them in today's peloton is surely the likes of ROG, POG, Froome, Thomas, who have all won TT and mountain stages.
And lest we forget, Hampsten and Herrera both won GTs back in the 80s. And Pantani beat Ullrich in a TdF with over 120kms of ITT.
Ganna wouldn't come close to a grand tour win if we went back to 2 55km ITTs and a 65 km TTT. That wouldn't make up for him losing 10-15 minutes each and every day in the mountainsWho are the top GC riders presently? Roglic and Pogacar. Who is the most hyped GC talent? Evenepoel. Who was the dominant GC rider of the last period? Froome. The pinnacle of GC riding is still continuously occupied by extremely strong ITT riders, not one sided climbing specialists.
There are excellent ITT specialists who can’t compete for GC or at least haven’t done so, so far, like Ganna, Dennis, Kung. But excellent climbing specialists who ITT as well as Kung climbs also struggle as GC men. I don’t see why it would be more balanced if a Kung or Ganna was winning GTs. Simon Yates is probably the worst TTist to win a GT in the recent period. Despite being probably one of the three best climbers in the world he has won precisely one Vuelta and he’s not that bad a TTist.
There has been a shift from TTing to climbing, I absolutely agree. But I don’t think the current mixture is as unbalanced as you are making out when you look at the riders who actually win.
I think it definitely comes down to definitions.I guess it's a question of definitions then. My definition at least for the 2014 Tour is that Nibali was the best in the mountains and the best in the ITT out of GC contenders, so he was the best all-rounder.
But I see where you're coming from.
Remco Undroppapoel has never ridden for damage limitation or to simply to stay in contention.Much has been said about the possibility of Bernal (ex MTBer, alongside VdP and the others at the end of the gravel sections in Strade Bianche, etc) as a real contender for tomorrow. What of Evenepoel, who was kicking a pig's bladder around at the age when he should have been riding off-road for fun? Bike handling does not seem to be a great strength of his, although his team support should be outstanding. Can he stay in contention, or is he riding for damage limitation?
|Thread starter||Similar threads||Forum||Replies||Date|
|Giro d'Italia 2021 Giro d'Italia, Stage 21: Senago – Milano 30.3 km ITT||Professional Road Racing||323|
|B||Giro d'Italia 2021 Giro d'Italia, Stage 20: Verbania – Alpe Motta 165 km||Professional Road Racing||654|
|2021 Giro d'Italia, Stage 19: Abbiategrasso - Alpe di Mera 166 km||Professional Road Racing||631|
|Giro d'Italia 2021 Giro d'Italia, Stage 18: Rovereto – Stradella 232 km||Professional Road Racing||270|
|Giro d'Italia 2021 Giro d'Italia, Stage 17: Canazei - Sega di Ala 193 km||Professional Road Racing||963|
|Giro d'Italia 2021 Giro d'Italia, Stage 21: Senago – Milano 30.3 km ITT|
|Giro d'Italia 2021 Giro d'Italia, Stage 20: Verbania – Alpe Motta 165 km|
|2021 Giro d'Italia, Stage 19: Abbiategrasso - Alpe di Mera 166 km|
|Giro d'Italia 2021 Giro d'Italia, Stage 18: Rovereto – Stradella 232 km|
|Giro d'Italia 2021 Giro d'Italia, Stage 17: Canazei - Sega di Ala 193 km|