I think the Browns were hoping Mayfield would be the next Drew Brees, or close. Ha!
No need to make excuses for Mayfield. As I said, his biggest issue is poor decision making in critical situations. All great QB's have had key games they've blown due to bad decisions. Brett Favre, Peyton Manning and Aaron Rodgers come to mind. They get criticized for it often. But in the big picture, greats rise above those moments. I don't think we ever saw any indication Mayfield was going to rise to that level. He looked (looks) more like on the same trajectory of an Andy Dalton, or maybe Carson Wentz. One of you mentioned Sam Bradford. Sam was a better player I think, just hurt too often in his career. Sam was also always much more grown up. A gentleman.
Let's not forget, the Clown Browns are paying $10m of that! So Carolina only pays $8m! This is in the Mitch Trubiski, Tyrod Taylor pay range!
No, never near that level in his career. More like Andy Dalton, like I said, who was taken in the 2nd round. Baker's arm strength was quite good, as was his accuracy mid-field. But he was considered short, not mobile, and would try to force plays, or not pull the trigger early in plays, which often translates into bad news at the NFL level. Oh, and the tiny hands thing.
Five QBs were taken in the first round the year Mayfield was drafted:
#1 - Mayfield.
#3 - Sam Darnold - Seemed to have a lot of upside, but that upside never really panned out. Going to the Jets also killed hope of that.
#7 - Josh Allen - Seemed wild, but landed on the perfect team for him in every single way. MVP level player now.
#10 - Josh Rosen - Taken by Arizona. Mel Kieper said he was the best QB in the draft and NFL ready. He never got used to NFL speed, and never seemed serious. Pretty much a near total bust. The following year Arizona dumped him to get Kyler Murray.
#31 - Lamar Jackson - Was considered a risk. Called a RB or WR by some scouts. Ended up winning an MVP, and is still one of the most dangerous QBs in the league, and a much better passer than most anyone expected.
Mason Rudolph is the only other QB taken that year who's seen decent playing time. Better than Josh Rosen. Almost as good as Sam Darnold.