Nonsense Shadow - your dislike for the
Gunslinger obscures the statistical evidence you're overlooking. You're correct on the defense - the Chiefs have an elite D that's going to keep them in games most of the time. But you still need an effective offense to score & win games, especially during crunch time when the chips are down.
Mahomes achieved
4000+ yds & 24+ TDs in each of his six seasons starting. 4000+ yds plus 24+ TDs passing are
benchmarks of what defines a good passing QB in the league. Less than dozen QBs have achieved this over the last 3 seasons - even with the 17 game schedule.
Less than half of all 1st rd QBs have a achieved a season with 4000+ yds & 24+ TDs. Last year Mahomes finished
6th in total passing yds throwing for 4183 & 27 TDs. Factor in his 389 yds rushing & you have 4572 yds total O (
269 average per game) --- that's an offensive machine! He was even better in the playoffs last year (4 games) with 1051 passing, 6 TDs, 141 rushing - 1192 total O or
298 average per game.
https://www.pro-football-reference.com/years/2023/passing.htm
Now let's look at 4th Qtr comebacks & game winning drives - a true benchmark of a great QB. Mahomes currently has
42 4th Qtr comebacks/game winning drives more than
any active QB except Rodgers, Stafford & Wilson! However, they have 19, 15 & 12 yrs in the league, respectively, vs Mahomes 7 yrs (and all are future HOF, btw).
Get Patrick Mahomes Career 4th quarter comebacks for regular season and playoff games on Pro-football-reference.com.
www.pro-football-reference.com
This season Mahomes is
7th in passing (3608 & 23 TDs). However, he has a career high
seven (7) 4th Qtr comebacks/game winning drives already this season & there still is a game or two to go! Like I said, the 4000/24 benchmark might be in jeopardy this year depending upon if he plays in the last two games of the season or just the one against Pittsburgh.
So, if you have a QB pumping out
4000+ yds & 24+ TDs routinely every season, you have an outstanding passing QB with good receivers (nothing new there). That's far from an "elite game manager." Lol. And if you have a QB with that kind of 4th Qtr comeback ability, you have an elite QB who's going to win you close games more often than not.