Ostweiller didn't throw at the Combine either. What does that tell you? Case Keenum threw poorly there, which bumped him way down the draft. As I noted, the best QB at the Combine was Weeden. Kirk Cousins threw fairly well, but not with as strong of arm. Weeden had a better pro day. Actually, if you go back to the college bowl games, Weeden outplayed Luck head to head, and played better than RG3, Cousins, Tannehill, and probably everyone else. But he's 28, so...
RG3 and Luck did however throw extensively at their pro-day. Both looked great.
Agree, the team and system the player is drafted under will dictate a great deal. Hence, the luckiest QBs over the last decade are probably Eli Manning and Tom Brady. Picture them playing for Cleveland and Buffalo...
Vince Young and Matt Leinhart? Tim Tebow and Mark Sanchez? (I'm blindly guessing and not going to look it up).
Generally true most college stats are useless. College systems are so different. The level of play different. Remember Timmy Chang anyone? Threw 60 times a game in a spread offense. Every pass was a quick slant, rub or screen. Great way to pile up monster stats. Guy never played a down in the NFL. You have to watch players within their system, and in key games they play. Then evaluate them accordingly.
RG3 and Luck did however throw extensively at their pro-day. Both looked great.
Agree, the team and system the player is drafted under will dictate a great deal. Hence, the luckiest QBs over the last decade are probably Eli Manning and Tom Brady. Picture them playing for Cleveland and Buffalo...
BTW, College Stats are absolute useless. Guess who this two Div. I QB´s are:
a.) 57.7%, 7.3 Y/A, 74/64 TD/Int (42-6 W-L-Team-Record in his career = .875 W-Pct.).
b.) 64.0%, 8.4 Y/A, 66/36 TD/Int (35-4 W-L-Team-Record in his career = .897 W-Pct.).
Vince Young and Matt Leinhart? Tim Tebow and Mark Sanchez? (I'm blindly guessing and not going to look it up).
Generally true most college stats are useless. College systems are so different. The level of play different. Remember Timmy Chang anyone? Threw 60 times a game in a spread offense. Every pass was a quick slant, rub or screen. Great way to pile up monster stats. Guy never played a down in the NFL. You have to watch players within their system, and in key games they play. Then evaluate them accordingly.