Interesting thread topic but after reading thru 11 pages, maybe a more appropriate topic should be :
"whiteboy (the hardcore AS & team Saxo supporter) vs the rest who are not - showdown".
but heck, it's the internet forum and everyone is free to voice their opinions, so this is how i see it - looking at factual results and if it is solely AS vs AC, AC is definitely a class above AS. results speaks for itself. period. AS is definitely the up and coming future but for now, he still has to get more results to prove he can be in the same league as AC when it comes to stage races - perhaps we might get a chance to see that come july.
a bit off topic - even talking about climbing alone (and not the GC including TTs), no offense to those who only see (or fantsize) AS or AC dominating the climbs come this july, i hate to say it but don't forget other proven grand tour "old timers" who can climb just as good or better than these 2 young guns. well, I'll just list 3 of my personal favourite-like the guy from Texas, Basso, Leipheimer. I'm sure you guys have more to add to the list.