- Jan 27, 2012
- 15,230
- 2,615
- 28,180
The Vuelta organizer better get things right in the finale moving forward. Its a shame about Steven, hopefully he can recover and be ready for next year.
I think this is a real problem. Most Dutch riders won't have been practising long, technical descents from early age and so just aren't as good as many of their counterparts. Given they are also often tall and wiry, it's not so easy to get a good balanced position on descents.SoigneurNL said:movingtarget said:Surely the Dutch luck will turn soon in grand tours. It is becoming ridiculous.
Is it luck or is it something else? It isn't just the presumably mentally less strong riders that keep crashing (looking at you Kelderman!) but also mentally stronger riders like Dumoulin and Kruijswijk. Maybe the Dutch are not so good in steering? ;-)
Yesterday was just terrible luck.DFA123 said:I think this is a real problem. Most Dutch riders won't have been practising long, technical descents from early age and so just aren't as good as many of their counterparts. Given they are also often tall and wiry, it's not so easy to get a good balanced position on descents.SoigneurNL said:movingtarget said:Surely the Dutch luck will turn soon in grand tours. It is becoming ridiculous.
Is it luck or is it something else? It isn't just the presumably mentally less strong riders that keep crashing (looking at you Kelderman!) but also mentally stronger riders like Dumoulin and Kruijswijk. Maybe the Dutch are not so good in steering? ;-)
Its a definite technical disadvantage growing up in such a flat country. Just as I guess they have an advantage riding into crosswinds and headwinds over the Latin riders!![]()
DFA123 said:I think this is a real problem. Most Dutch riders won't have been practising long, technical descents from early age and so just aren't as good as many of their counterparts. Given they are also often tall and wiry, it's not so easy to get a good balanced position on descents.SoigneurNL said:movingtarget said:Surely the Dutch luck will turn soon in grand tours. It is becoming ridiculous.
Is it luck or is it something else? It isn't just the presumably mentally less strong riders that keep crashing (looking at you Kelderman!) but also mentally stronger riders like Dumoulin and Kruijswijk. Maybe the Dutch are not so good in steering? ;-)
Its a definite technical disadvantage growing up in such a flat country. Just as I guess they have an advantage riding into crosswinds and headwinds over the Latin riders!![]()
Nothing. I wasn't responsing to a comment about hitting the post. I was responding to a comment about Dutch riders crashing all the time. This instance had very little to do with lack of technical ability, but most crashes - including Kruijswijk at the Giro - were very much a result of lack of skills.movingtarget said:DFA123 said:I think this is a real problem. Most Dutch riders won't have been practising long, technical descents from early age and so just aren't as good as many of their counterparts. Given they are also often tall and wiry, it's not so easy to get a good balanced position on descents.SoigneurNL said:movingtarget said:Surely the Dutch luck will turn soon in grand tours. It is becoming ridiculous.
Is it luck or is it something else? It isn't just the presumably mentally less strong riders that keep crashing (looking at you Kelderman!) but also mentally stronger riders like Dumoulin and Kruijswijk. Maybe the Dutch are not so good in steering? ;-)
Its a definite technical disadvantage growing up in such a flat country. Just as I guess they have an advantage riding into crosswinds and headwinds over the Latin riders!![]()
What has this got to do with hitting a post, one of two that the Vuelta organizers forget to remove ? Other riders said the same thing. It is up to the organizers to make the route as safe as possible.
Tonton said:Can someone explain that to me? I mean it. IMO, SK doesn't look good right now. I'm watching him as a potential threat for my Tibopino at the Giro, and I don't see him building up. I'm not following him, so what do you mean?
You can't compare 2013 Contador with 2016 Quintana. Yeah, both were very bad in the tour, but Contador was bad for the whole year while Quintana had already won Catalunya and Romandie before the tdf and went on to win the Vuelta after the tour. The funny thing last year was that it seemed as if the bad tdf was a perfect preparation for the Vuelta and thats why I think his level in that tour will be comparable to his level in this years giro since his biggest goal for the season is still the tdf. Still I'm expecting him to be at least a bit better.Valv.Piti said:I think (a 2016) Kruijswijk is the biggest thread for Quintana. I can't ignore all the red lights on Nibali aint no more, Landa is the inconsistency himself, Aru hasn't shown anything since 2015, Pinot? Ain't have the top level and very inconsistent himself in GTs.
However, I do not agree on trying to dissect and analyze Quintana on his Tour de France 2016. Its like doing that to Contador in 2013, it doesn't do them justice. They were just plain bad, it happens, move on.
Valv.Piti said:I think (a 2016) Kruijswijk is the biggest thread for Quintana. I can't ignore all the red lights on Nibali aint no more, Landa is the inconsistency himself, Aru hasn't shown anything since 2015, Pinot? Ain't have the top level and very inconsistent himself in GTs.
However, I do not agree on trying to dissect and analyze Quintana on his Tour de France 2016. Its like doing that to Contador in 2013, it doesn't do them justice. They were just plain bad, it happens, move on.
Gigs_98 said:As good as Quintana is, I think he is a bit overestimated. He isn't completely peaking for the Giro he is doing a double attempt. Said differently, I don't expect him to be much stronger than in the tdf last year. And in that tdf he was beaten by Bardet, would've been beaten by Porte if he hadn't had bad luck in the first week and only finished 20 seconds in front of yates. No bad riders, but also not much stronger than Nibali, Aru, Pinot and Kruijswijk. And who knows, maybe Landa will get his 2015 shape again.
Kruijswijk isn't the top favorite but if he has last years shape he has a good chance to win.
movingtarget said:Gigs_98 said:As good as Quintana is, I think he is a bit overestimated. He isn't completely peaking for the Giro he is doing a double attempt. Said differently, I don't expect him to be much stronger than in the tdf last year. And in that tdf he was beaten by Bardet, would've been beaten by Porte if he hadn't had bad luck in the first week and only finished 20 seconds in front of yates. No bad riders, but also not much stronger than Nibali, Aru, Pinot and Kruijswijk. And who knows, maybe Landa will get his 2015 shape again.
Kruijswijk isn't the top favorite but if he has last years shape he has a good chance to win.
Well Quintana will have to be peaking for the Giro otherwise the double won't even be a single. Usually they would peak for the first one and do little between the races hoping to conserve as much as possible for the Tour. In 2011 Contador won a hard Giro but he probably should have backed off more in the third week as he had such a big lead but then he got involved in crashes in the Tour and supposedly hurt his knee as well while Evans just had a dream year plus avoiding accidents and bad luck. Contador admitted that the Giro still fatigued him going into the Tour. Quintana should just concentrate on one race and leave the other for Valverde although if you take out Contador's attack in the Vuelta, Froome would have gone close to a double and many people thought he had more in reserve in the Tour. I think his Vuelta ride supports that.
I think if Steven Kruijswijk can repeat last year's form then the long TT brings him right into the race because he climbed very well last year even though it was against a Nibali not at his best and Chaves who is still learning about how to ride GTs. I will be very interested to see how Chaves can go in the Tour after his good rides in the Giro and Vuelta. The lack of TT kms can only help him.
hfer07 said:movingtarget said:Gigs_98 said:As good as Quintana is, I think he is a bit overestimated. He isn't completely peaking for the Giro he is doing a double attempt. Said differently, I don't expect him to be much stronger than in the tdf last year. And in that tdf he was beaten by Bardet, would've been beaten by Porte if he hadn't had bad luck in the first week and only finished 20 seconds in front of yates. No bad riders, but also not much stronger than Nibali, Aru, Pinot and Kruijswijk. And who knows, maybe Landa will get his 2015 shape again.
Kruijswijk isn't the top favorite but if he has last years shape he has a good chance to win.
Well Quintana will have to be peaking for the Giro otherwise the double won't even be a single. Usually they would peak for the first one and do little between the races hoping to conserve as much as possible for the Tour. In 2011 Contador won a hard Giro but he probably should have backed off more in the third week as he had such a big lead but then he got involved in crashes in the Tour and supposedly hurt his knee as well while Evans just had a dream year plus avoiding accidents and bad luck. Contador admitted that the Giro still fatigued him going into the Tour. Quintana should just concentrate on one race and leave the other for Valverde although if you take out Contador's attack in the Vuelta, Froome would have gone close to a double and many people thought he had more in reserve in the Tour. I think his Vuelta ride supports that.
I think if Steven Kruijswijk can repeat last year's form then the long TT brings him right into the race because he climbed very well last year even though it was against a Nibali not at his best and Chaves who is still learning about how to ride GTs. I will be very interested to see how Chaves can go in the Tour after his good rides in the Giro and Vuelta. The lack of TT kms can only help him.
folks forget that Quintana was SICK in the Tour and yet he finished 3rd. then he won La Vuelta against Contador & Froome![]()
on topic: IF Kruijswijk gets back to last year's form, gets the proper support & positions in the top 5 by the ned of the 2nd week- he can get good chance to battle for the title. The bad news is that, because of last year's performance, he'll be marked. The other challenge is the competition: there is Quintana-no need to say anything at all - then there is Nibali, Aru and Landa: all three hugely motivated, hungry to prove themselves & for their teams as leaders, after a horrible start of the season. "G"? he may bother a bit but I foresee him fading in the last week.
