Franklin said:
Really? He's been pro for three years. If we scratch 2011 he has been pretty good indeed. A debut of 7th in the Giro* and Super domestique in 2012, all padded with pretty solid wins.
He was a very good TTer and a pretty good climber. And yes, now he's gone above very good climber
* Yes, he got a lot of free minutes, but even then he did manage to hang on.
That Giro as evidence of his being a very good climber has been debunked many times.
On Terminillo almost all the GC men came in together. Porte lost 26" on them and came in together with Wiggins. That's nothing too major.
But then he got the maglia rosa, and was up at the top. On the first mountain stage after that, a one climb stage over Monte Grappa, Nibali won; Basso, Scarponi and Evans came in at 23". Vino at 1'34". Then a large group came in at 2'25" containing peripheral GC contenders like Cunego and also most of the best climbers from the L'Aquila break - Sastre, Arroyo, Tondó. Even freaking Cioni and Gerdemann stayed in that group. Richie came in at 4'46. Just behind Chris Froome. Rigoberto Urán, who is now domestiquing for guys like Porte, came in at 3'01 after pacing Arroyo up the whole climb. So that's over 4 mins on the GC elites, and 2 minutes on guys like Gerdemann. OK. Let's move on.
Zoncolán... a true beast. Maybe Richie showed what a very good climber he can be here? Well, he managed 18th, which is pretty reasonable. It was nearly 6 minutes back from Basso, mind, and he was outclimbed by a guy now domestiquing at Sky (Cataldo), Dupont and even a past-his-prime Charlie Wegelius.
Kronplatz then, another mountain monster, this time against the clock, which should surely have suited Porte... and indeed it did! He improved his finishing position from the previous day to 17th, by beating vaunted super-climber Yuriy Trofimov by one second! He gave up 2'17 to Garzelli, but Garzelli had saved himself for the stage by riding easy the previous day, so the 1'35 to Evans is more appropriate to use as a guide.
How about Aprica then? Was that the stage where his climbing chops came to the fore? Once more he's improving his positions, to 14th! Still struggling to crack the 5 minute barrier though, finishing 5'31" back from the Scarponi/Nibali/Basso trio, and over 2 minutes behind the group with Arroyo, Evans, Vino, Sastre and Gadret. Porte's group is led home by Branislau Samoilau.
Tonale, then, surely this must have been the time? This stage would look to suit Richie better - a lower average percentage and more of a grinding climb than the super-steep slopes of the previous days. And indeed, he stays inside the 5 minute mark comfortably, losing only 1'42 on the stage winner (who was from the break), 1'26 from Evans and 1'17 from Basso and Scarponi! Drops down to 19th on the day, mind, with his mountain nemesis Yuriy Trofimov this time pipping him on the line.
So really, his performances as a mountain goat were not all that convincing in that Giro, and it was his performances in the time trials, in the chaos in Middelburg (when Evans, Kiserlovski, Cunego and Sastre lost 46", Pinotti lost 1'07", and the Strade Bianche (where he gained 18" on Nibali, 23" on Basso, 1'08" on Kiserlovski, 2'10" on Mollema, 2'33" on Cataldo, 3'38" on Sastre and Tondó) that gave him the position to defend, plus it was no doubt a help to his defence of his position that Cunego (who was 4th to Zoncolán) missed the L'Aquila break and that Kiserlovski had to work for Nibali and Basso.
That Giro showed a lot of promise in Richie Porte, but it was foremost as a time triallist and secondmost as a potential climbing helper. He was hanging on to the bunch throughout, it never indicated that obliterating the field was a possibility.