• The Cycling News forum is still looking to add volunteer moderators with. If you're interested in helping keep our discussions on track, send a direct message to @SHaines here on the forum, or use the Contact Us form to message the Community Team.

    In the meanwhile, please use the Report option if you see a post that doesn't fit within the forum rules.

    Thanks!

Tour de France Tour de France 2024, Stage 9: Troyes > Troyes, 199.0 km

Page 3 - Get up to date with the latest news, scores & standings from the Cycling News Community.
Visma should use their team strength here try and isolate Pog.
I don't think so, while their team is stronger for this it suits Pogi much more than Vingegaard and so making it hard will only play into his hands and increase the chance of him gaining time. Visma should aim just not to lose any time to Pogi and make it up in the third week
 
I think a lot depends on what Alpecin do. There options;
1. Put MVDP in the break, or maybe some others too. If this is the case I think the break will make it and it. But why would they do this when it would prevent them using their numbers and it adds a lot of randomness to the result as MVDP will be a marked man
2. Play for a sprint with Phillipsen or MVDP if he doesn't make it. However, Phillipsen hasn't been so strong and might well get beat even if he is there
3. Attack with MVDP from the peloton. This is the most likely I think. In which case, this will help Pogi as he just needs to stick with MVDP to gain time and doesn't need to attack himself. They can fall back on Phillipsen for a sprint or attack with others before to increase their chance

I predict MVDP and Pogi will get away alone and MVDP will win the stage with Pogi gaining a chunk of time over the other favourites
 
While great as a one day race this kind of stage can lead to a GC guy losing alot of time because of a mechanical or crash and not because of strength or tactics

So I dont think it should be in a grand tour
Is the ability to handle one's bike, pick lines, position oneself into sectors, etc., not part of being a great racer? Strength and tactics, sure great, but if those are the only two elements it's just a game of remote control for the DS's and the riders need never look up from their head units.
 
Is the ability to handle one's bike, pick lines, position oneself into sectors, etc., not part of being a great racer? Strength and tactics, sure great, but if those are the only two elements it's just a game of remote control for the DS's and the riders need never look up from their head units.

Sure, but then you puncture and all that really means nothing as in the end it's muce more about lottery. So the question is valid, on why should a lottery determine ones GC chances, compared to everything you wrote above.

Anyway, it is what it is and lets see on how this lottery unfolds tomorrow.
 
  • Like
Reactions: red_flanders
Sure, but then you puncture and all that really means nothing as in the end it's muce more about lottery. So the question is valid, on why should a lottery determine ones GC chances, compared to everything you wrote above.

Anyway, it is what it is and lets see on how this lottery unfolds tomorrow.
There is an element of luck to punctures but that is not the only factor. A wheelsucker, for example, or someone who sits in the wheels of his teammates is much more likely to puncture than a rider who takes some wind so they can ride with their head up. Knowing how to unweight the rear of the bike at certain moments. Some of these things cost energy. Is it any more of a lottery than when an important rider is crashed out by some flick of wheels in the peloton?

I'm happy to see how it plays out tomorrow. I'm not expecting major GC changes, but if they do occur I don't expect mechanicals to be the reason.
 
I better see MvdP and WvA in the break tomorrow. Or at least forcing the selection. Pidcock too, though I doubt he's allowed in the break. No Treaty of Troyes tomorrow, it's time for all out war.
Van Aert will be on babysitting duties for Vingegaard

I think MVDP's best bet is to attack from the peloton, as there are less factors in play and Vermeersch, Soren Kragh, Phillipsen, Axel Laurance and perhaps even Dillier are all interesting cards to play
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sandisfan
A wheelsucker, for example, or someone who sits in the wheels of his teammates is much more likely to puncture than a rider who takes some wind so they can ride with their head up. Knowing how to unweight the rear of the bike at certain moments. Some of these things cost energy.

Not really sure about that one, punctures to specifically target wheel suckers.

Is it any more of a lottery than when an important rider is crashed out by some flick of wheels in the peloton?

Yes in my opinion it's more about lottery.

I'm happy to see how it plays out tomorrow. I'm not expecting major GC changes, but if they do occur I don't expect mechanicals to be the reason.

I agree that big four likely wouldn't be that keen to capitalize on somebody puncturing. So if any GC gaps to be made indeed hopeful it will be due to racing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cassirer