roundabout said:You thought that Contador should beat Evans in both time trials even though to any rational observer it is far from certain.
And show me where you were "widely ridiculed" by me(unless offering actual results instead of mere opinion now counts as ridicule) and especially where I supported the idea that Evans is the best GC time trialist.
Thought so.
If you're going to hold a grudge try to make it factual next time.
Speaking of keeping it factual where did I say that Contador should beat Evans in both tts?
The discussion came from someone saying the opposite
User Guide said:Wiggins/Evans/Menchov will take at minimum 5 mins from 3 ITT's out of the Schlecks Contador at least 3-4 mins.
And I asked where people got the idea that Evans was a better tter from.
The discussion was all about the past, nothing about next year anyway.
(unless offering actual results instead of mere opinion now counts as ridicule)
I offered plenty of actual results.
For example, when in that very thread you accused me of not posting any evidence I offered this response, though I dont think you read it as you instead announced that you won't be reading my posts.
The Hitch said:Dont have any relevant arguments?
Contador winning more tts in his career, despite having a shorter career is not a relevant argument?
Contador having a better overall record vs Evans is not a relevant argument?
Contador beating Evans when they both came into the Tour fully prepared is not a relevant argument?
Contador keeping it close when he is off form, and crushing Evans when he is off form, is not a relevant argument?
Contador, if you add their tt times from TDFs they have faced eachother in, having a lower time, is not a relevant argument?
By the way that score is 2 minutes 59 seconds in Contadors favour.
In tts time matters more than position.
This is just taking in the "long" tts which you picked out yourself, which are actually skewed to Cadel. If we began to include Prologues and shorter tts at the Tour, Contadors lead would grow.
And the only actual results you offered was the 1 point about how if we look at Only the TDF and Only long tts going back to when Contador was still young, then Evans has a better record.
Which, to again disprove the idea that I wasn't looking at the facts, I responded to here.
The Hitch said:You need to apply some logic to the results though. Contador was young in 2007. He said even before the tt he expected to lose it. And in 2011 he was injured and heavily fatigued after you know what. That he limited his losses to Evans on the form of his life, to 1 minute shows just how great a tter he can be.
In 2010 Evans likewise was well out of it, no way can you take that result to suggest he is worse than Contador.
But Contador has won a Tour Itt in recent years. He has also been pretty solid in other tts he has done, winning many in smaller races, getting 4th in the Olympics, 3rd in the Giro, winning the uphill one, 6th in Tour prologue. 2nd to Cancellara in a pretty solid opening tt in Monaco. The results are just better than Evans ones.
BTW, I think if you were to add all those tt results (even if you select 2007 which imo is unfair because Contador was young), together, Contadors overall time would be better than Evans![]()
So you may have misread my posts if you felt I was talking about 2012 when I was talking about already completed tts. And it wasnt such a black and white case of you "offering actual results" and me offering "mere opinion".