Thoughtforfood said:
Question: Other countries achieve superior results with public education and teachers paid from tax dollars. How is it that the government is the problem, and that privatizing will fix it?
Its funny, I heard this Libertarian douchebag on the radio today going on and on about how people in Japan are not looting, and how they do here, and how it is all tied to social programs that make people think they deserve assistance...only the fu*king idiot didn't bother to address the fact that Japan has Universal health care and has had social programs since the 1920's.
You create this boogie man "government entitlement programs" and blame everything on it. The only problem is that there are FAR MORE numerous examples of these systems working than there are systems that adopt the "government keeping out of markets" that work. In fact, there still isn't a major industrialized nation that has adopted the limited government idea espoused by people who didn't study late 19th and early 20th century history...
I don't know what their structure is. How much influence does the unions have, for example? Do they use their due to buy political favor? How heavy is their administrative overhead? How much per student are they spending and how much of that goes to the teacher?
Private markets (generally) are extremely good and efficient at providing incentive. Good and efficient. Notice I didn't say perfect. Our public school system is neither good or efficient.
There are ideas with evidence to support how public schools can be fixed. I'm wondering why there is so much opposition to these ideas... particularly from those that represent teachers?
Pay teachers more.... elevate their standing. Fine. It reminds my of the trailer to the documentary "Waiting for Superman." Our kids suck at math and science but feel better about themselves than all the other kids from competing nations. We can't fire crappy teachers but we can pay them all more thereby elevating their standing so they are proud and feel better about themselves.
For what it's worth, I think teachers shoud be paid more. I'm wondering why, at $24 - $25,000 per student, they aren't? Let's say the average class size for any particular school for any particular grade is 25 kids. That's about $625,000 per school year per class. Teacher makes $50,000 plus a $15,000 per year benefit package (pulling numbers out of the air here...).
So.... is it really a funding problem?