Ryo Hazuki said:what does that matter? in 2011 gilbert was in ridiculous form. he's not anywhere near that so you can just as well forget that ascent
Well, it matters a lot.
That's like saying "Oh, 100 metres doesn't suit Usain Bolt, he was just in rediculous form in 2008 and 2012". If someone has the record at something, surely he must be suited to it, right?