LaFlorecita said:
Well I certainly didn't expect him to win

I think the oohing and ahhing is just because most of us are excited that Contador is showing signs of life

no one except Jens believes this is the return of the old Contador
Last year he was pretty good as well, though, in Oman and T-A (apart from the brutal hilly stage which took its toll on Froome as well) and in like half the key Tour stages, particularly Ventoux and the second ITT. I think some of the posters in this thread are underrating the 2013 Contador a fair bit.
Netserk said:
Lol @ where you have placed Nibali. Just a tiny bit better than Valverde, and clearly worse than both Purito and Porte. Ridiculous.
Pretty hard to compare riders who didn't target the same GT last year, though Purito being clearly better than Nibali is not inconceivable to me - assuming this is GTs only. Purito was on fire in the Alps doing most of the pacing on Alpe d'Huez and Semnoz and posting great climbing times.
Nibali had a great season, but the Giro had a weak field, and the key mountain stages were cut short. In spite of all that, he still wasn't able to really distance Duarte, Uran and them on Tre Cime. Nibali would have lost bucket loads of time in the Alps had he done the Tour, IMO, but it's all speculation, of course.