Deliberately specious? If I am specious it is purely accidental.
I was responding to Dave's predictable absoluteness of all things LA performance related, with the ever so predictable 'opinion' of LA talent = pack fodder. He says he has inside info that LA's power numbers went up over the GT, while others went down. I am just pointing out some issues with that. LA's could have gone up, but who is to say others went down? I am only pointing out that his competition, IN GENERAL, seemed to recover from the early onslaught. Let's take 2000 for example. Was JU weaker on Jaux Plane than on Hautacam, and LA vice versa? The question is stupid with such an obvious answer.
Of course, tactics play a part in a lot of this and we are talking about humans who have good days and bad days, so nothing is absolute. So, we are back to opinions and trying to piece together what is plausible. At least that is what I tend to do since I don't have super duper secret inside info that bolsters my prejudices. I look at results.
And, WTF are you talking about? Is that pain medicine causing some cloudiness? LA didn't make his mark on the first MTF in his early wins? Sestriere, Hautacam, AdH? Hello? BTW, I haven't posted in your get well thread, but I hope you are doing well and are healed soon.
So, you pick one year that Basso nipped LA on the first MTF finish in 2004 I believe, then pull some quote out from somewhere about JB's concern. I believe that was the tour LA won like 5 stages, and in fact beat Basso by 2 mins I believe on the AdH TT (which does support him getting stronger and Basso getting weaker, BTW, I admit). Anyway, you got me with that zinger, rubarb. Everything else in the saga must be discounted.
Finally, I really do envy your conviction about who did and didn't have talent during that time, or any time in the last XX years for that matter, in cycling. I envy your knowledge about the effects of PED's on one rider vs another. I'm sure you have it all figured out which of the PED users would have won if everybody was clean, and of course you know they would be Italian.