Do spoilers in a race thread get your goat?

[topcat]

An Irishman walks into a race thread and gives away classified information about another race that's taking place at the same time.
Do you get neurotic that the other race has been ruined for you or do you congratulate him on being an Irishman?

 

[tobydawq]

A poll with so many ridiculous options has no merit.

If I'm on catch-up (which sadly happens more and more often), I won't read the forum before I'm up to date.

 

[Ilmaestro99]

I never watch races so if there were no spoilers I wouldnt know what happened

 

[topcat]

This thread really needs a vicious argument to get going.

 

[jmdirt]

As I stated in the mod thread:

Even if you don't care about messing things up for others, posting about race A in the thread for race B is off topic.

 

[Potomac]

All those possible choices and no Vino? This forum is dead.

 

[red_flanders]

As I stated in the mod thread:

Even if you don't care about messing things up for others, posting about race A in the thread for race B is off topic.

I had a similar reaction when I read this thread, but this one seems to be about spoilers in the thread for that race. Which I don't think is an issue at all.

What defense there could be for posting a spoiler in a thread A about race B I can't fathom. If you don't care about messing things up for other posters...welp. IMO have a nice vacation. But I'm 100% with you that doing so is also obviously off-topic.

 

[jmdirt]

I had a similar reaction when I read this thread, but this one seems to be about spoilers in the thread for that race. Which I don't think is an issue at all.

What defense there could be for posting a spoiler in a thread A about race B I can't fathom. If you don't care about messing things up for other posters...welp. IMO have a nice vacation. But I'm 100% with you that doing so is also obviously off-topic.

If that is the case I misunderstood. I thought that the debate was about posting, for example, the P-N winner in the T-A thread.

 

[Hugh Januss]

This thread really needs a vicious argument to get going.

Roger that. How's this?

 

[Hugh Januss]

I never watch races so if there were no spoilers I wouldnt know what happened

Even with spoilers do you know what's happening?

 

[RedheadDane]

If that is the case I misunderstood. I thought that the debate was about posting, for example, the P-N winner in the T-A thread.

I think it is:

An Irishman walks into a race thread and gives away classified information about another race that's taking place at the same time.

What defense there could be for posting a spoiler in a thread A about race B I can't fathom. If you don't care about messing things up for other posters...welp. IMO have a nice vacation. But I'm 100% with you that doing so is also obviously off-topic.

I think most cases of posting about race A in the thread for race B are either:

1. Those situations where people get stunned that the same team gets multiple wins in a day, and makes a post like "Oh, wow! Trek got 10 wins in the same day!" in the thread for the latest-finishing race. Now, I agree that the thread for that particular team would be the correct place to post about such matters, but I can understand if someone might get carried away.
(Also, I suppose if a team managed to get 10 wins in a day, it would probably be during the big National Championship Sunday, so... that wouldn't be a problem.)

2. People getting threads mixed up, and for example does stuff like posting about Milano-San Remo in the Milano-Torino thread.


As for caring about it:
Well, I don't care about reading the result of race A in the thread for race B; either I have already watched race A, or I won't.
I will of course take care not to post about the result of race A in the thread for race B.

 

[Armchair Cyclist]

I had a similar reaction when I read this thread, but this one seems to be about spoilers in the thread for that race. Which I don't think is an issue at all.

I would consider it impossible to post a spoiler about race A in the thread for race A. During the race, the race thread is essentially a running commentary. If there is a lot of on-forum activity during a race I haven't watched live, I sometimes try to follow the discussion while watching: the trick is to check the time stamps before scrolling up enough to read the message.

If I ever wrote anything suggesting that race A comments in thread A was what I was asking people to be wary of, then I apologise for not making myself clear.

 

[Devil's Elbow]

1. Those situations where people get stunned that the same team gets multiple wins in a day, and makes a post like "Oh, wow! Trek got 10 wins in the same day!" in the thread for the latest-finishing race. Now, I agree that the thread for that particular team would be the correct place to post about such matters, but I can understand if someone might get carried away.

And if anyone wants to make such a post, they have two separate spoiler tags they can use. There is simply zero reason to spoil other races on the same day in a race thread, and a lot of reasons/ways not to.